ChatGPT Selections

Forum » Rugby » ChatGPT Selections

Oct 18, 2024, 11:43

Im very impressed .... seriously impressed actually

I saw Mpowers team post for the EOYT and I decided to ask ChatGPT this question below.

"Given how successful the Springboks have been over the last few years, and your ability to analyse all the stats available for each playing position, what current Springbok players would you select to play in your team, if your life depended on it, and provide the reasons why"

I have to say, for me, it's very hard to disagree with this team selection, and whilst I initially thought that I would rather have Kwagga coming off the bench and not starting, I have also previously mentioned and pushed to see Kwagga start, because he offers so much physically and gains so many turnovers, especially for his size, but that would possibly mean Siya / Fourie / V-S coming on later to replace him and I am not sure if he would be as impactful as kwagga is when he usually comes on so late in the game, so I am actually quite happy to start Kwagga, just to try it out.

I also questioned the DDA selection, but as much as I have really disliked his play for a while, he does seem to have improved over the last few games, so I'll give him the credit he is due.

Then we have the selection of Duane, who as we know has retired, but I don't think up until the last update, ChatGPT knew this

This team, including the replacements is bloody solid.

This was the reply I got:

If I had to choose a Springbok team and my life depended on it, I'd go for a mix of experience, consistency, and X-factor players who have proven themselves in key moments. Here’s my selection, based on their form over the last few years:

1. Loosehead Prop: Steven Kitshoff

Kitshoff is an immovable force in the scrum and a solid player around the park. His work rate and tackling are exceptional, plus he’s consistently strong in set pieces. His experience and aggression give him the edge over most looseheads in the game.

2. Hooker: Malcolm Marx

Marx is not just a beast in the scrum and lineout; his turnover ability at the breakdown is world-class. He’s a strong ball carrier and often adds massive impact when the team needs it. His size and power make him a nightmare for any opposition.

3. Tighthead Prop: Frans Malherbe

Malherbe is arguably one of the best scrummagers in the world. His technique in the tight phases is immaculate, and he brings a calming presence to the front row. Not the flashiest player, but his consistency and reliability make him crucial.

4. Lock: Eben Etzebeth

Etzebeth is a physical and mental enforcer. His athleticism and aggression, combined with his ability to dominate in the lineout and collisions, make him one of the top locks globally. His leadership and imposing figure set the tone for the pack.

5. Lock: Franco Mostert

Mostert is an absolute workhorse. He covers an incredible amount of ground and is equally efficient in defense and carrying the ball. His lineout ability, along with his tireless work ethic, makes him the perfect partner to Etzebeth.

6. Blindside Flanker: Pieter-Steph Du Toit

Du Toit is the engine of the team. His tackling, work rate, and leadership are immense, and he's always in the thick of the action. His ability to be everywhere on the field while maintaining high standards in defense and breakdown work is unmatched.

7. Openside Flanker: Kwagga Smith

Smith’s dynamism and versatility offer something unique to the Springboks. He’s quick, incredibly strong for his size, and has the heart of a lion. His ability to play across multiple positions and adapt in high-pressure situations makes him an asset.

8. Number 8: Duane Vermeulen

Despite his age, Vermeulen’s experience and rugby IQ remain invaluable. His leadership on and off the field, his brutal physicality, and his ability to dominate in both attack and defense make him the perfect player for a do-or-die game.

9. Scrumhalf: Faf de Klerk

De Klerk is a world-class disruptor. His sniping runs, energy, and quick service from the base of the ruck can change the tempo of the game. His defensive work rate, especially against much bigger players, also adds another layer of security.

10. Flyhalf: Handré Pollard

Pollard’s game management, reliable boot, and calm demeanor under pressure make him my pick. He’s solid in defense, has a great tactical kicking game, and can control a game with his passing and decision-making.

11. Left Wing: Makazole Mapimpi

Mapimpi’s pace and finishing ability are second to none. He’s consistently lethal with ball in hand, and his work off the ball, especially in defense, has improved dramatically over the years. You need someone who can score tries out of nowhere, and Mapimpi delivers.

12. Inside Centre: Damian de Allende

De Allende is a physical presence in the midfield and has the ability to crash through defenders or offload in the tackle. His defense is rock-solid, and his decision-making in high-pressure games is dependable. He’s an excellent carrier and sets the platform for others.

13. Outside Centre: Lukhanyo Am

Am is an incredible reader of the game, and his defense is possibly the best among centers in the world. His ability to intercept passes and shut down attacking threats is uncanny. He’s also very creative on attack, with sharp distribution and tactical awareness.

14. Right Wing: Cheslin Kolbe

Kolbe’s footwork is unrivaled, and his ability to break tackles and create something from nothing is legendary. Despite his smaller frame, he’s fearless on defense and under the high ball. Kolbe is a game-changer who can swing a match in a single moment of brilliance.

15. Fullback: Willie le Roux

Le Roux’s experience and rugby intelligence are vital in the back three. He acts as a second playmaker, has an excellent tactical kicking game, and his vision often sets up tries. His ability to read the game and provide an extra layer of security in the backfield is invaluable.

Impact Players (Bench):

  • 16. Bongi Mbonambi – Consistent and solid in the lineout; a great option to bring energy late in the game.
  • 17. Ox Nché – Dynamic in open play and a strong scrummager to relieve Kitshoff.

    18. Trevor Nyakane – A versatile front-rower who can cover both sides of the scrum and bring fresh legs.

    19. RG Snyman – His physicality and mobility make him a fantastic replacement lock.

    20. Jasper Wiese – A strong ball carrier who offers an explosive impact from the bench.

    21. Cobus Reinach – Fast and sharp, he can speed up the game if needed.

    22. Damian Willemse – Versatile across the backline, Willemse can cover multiple positions and brings flair.

    23. Kurt-Lee Arendse – His pace and agility can exploit tiring defenses late in the game.

    Why these players?

This team has a balance of raw power, tactical intelligence, and game-breaking ability. The forwards are designed to dominate the set-piece, control the breakdown, and maintain a high work rate, while the backs can create opportunities and exploit weaknesses with precision and flair. With a bench packed with dynamic impact players, this team would have the ability to grind down opponents and finish strongly—essential in a match with everything on the line.


Oct 18, 2024, 12:59

Uh-oh . . . DumbAss is masking his rugby ignorance by posting ChatGPT opinions rather than his own . . . and neither one knows that Duane Vermeulen has retired.

This could get very tiresome very quickly!

Oct 18, 2024, 14:11

Sic you really are a pathetic fellow.

Oct 18, 2024, 17:11

Looks like even Chat Gpt Hasn’t found a proper replacement for Duane yet. Interesting choices here.

Oct 18, 2024, 17:48

"Interesting choices here."

Mpower, I'm not trying to be combative or insulting, but I would say that if you even think there's a choice here then you haven't been watching a lot of provincial rugby.

Oct 18, 2024, 18:18

All I am saying is that Chat gpt is making interesting choices. I do know that most of his first choice players is not first choice anymore.

Most of the First choice players is on the bench. I think DA knows this to and put it on here, for interest sake.

Oct 18, 2024, 18:35

So forgetting AI for a sec, who would be your shortlist for #8?

Oct 18, 2024, 18:39

ChatGPT will readily admit it doesn't use data within the last year or two which might explain why it's still picking the retired Duane Vermeulen, but stop defaulting to AI like DumbAss and tell us who is your pick?

Oct 18, 2024, 18:45

Hanekom first choice. Wiese and Elrigh Louw Runner up.

Oct 18, 2024, 18:52

Ok, that's more like reality.

Thanks.

Oct 18, 2024, 19:02

But then there is also Roos and Francke Horn….i think Dave would say Roos at 8 but I like Roos at 6. With my Runner up choice, I am putting Francke Horn down to. Elrigh is versatile, but better at 7 I would say.

Oct 18, 2024, 19:16

I would also like to pick Evan Roos in the same back row as Camerom Hanekom (assuming Roos recovers his form of a year ago) but I'm not going to compromise on the nation-building qualities of Siya Kolisi so unless Rassie playes PSdT as a lock, there's only room for one.

Oct 18, 2024, 20:12

Here's ChatGPT's selection:

list in order the top ten current #8 players you would select in a Springbok rugby XV
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT

Here’s a list of the top 10 current #8 players who could be considered for a Springbok XV. This includes players who are in or near the Springbok setup and those who are highly regarded for their performances domestically or abroad.


Top 10 Current Number 8s for a Springbok XV

  1. Duane Vermeulen

    • Club: Free State Cheetahs
    • Known for: Elite leadership, physical dominance, and breakdown work.
    • Key Achievements: 2019 World Cup hero; instrumental in the 2023 Rugby Championship; still a key squad leader at 37.
  2. Jasper Wiese

    • Club: Leicester Tigers
    • Known for: Powerful ball-carrying, work rate, and defensive physicality.
    • Key Achievements: Starting No. 8 for the 2023 Rugby World Cup campaign, growing into a force in the Springbok pack.
  3. Evan Roos

    • Club: Stormers
    • Known for: Explosive speed, aggression in open play, and attacking flair.
    • Key Achievements: 2022 URC Player of the Season; seen as the future of South African rugby at No. 8.
  4. Elrigh Louw

    • Club: Bulls
    • Known for: Strong ball-carrying, physicality, and tackling ability.
    • Key Achievements: Regular in the Bulls’ URC campaign, made a solid Springbok debut in 2023.
  5. Jean-Luc du Preez

    • Club: Sale Sharks
    • Known for: Versatility (also plays flank and lock), size, and powerful carrying.
    • Key Achievements: Consistent performer in England, contributing to Sale's success in the Premiership.
  6. Sikhumbuzo Notshe

    • Club: Sharks
    • Known for: Elusive running, good offloading, and line-out support.
    • Key Achievements: Played for the Springboks in 2019; known for his attacking edge in open play.
  7. Marcel Theunissen

    • Club: Stormers
    • Known for: Work rate, speed in transition, and breakdown presence.
    • Key Achievements: Emerging talent with strong URC performances for the Stormers.
  8. Jaco Coetzee

    • Club: Kobelco Kobe Steelers (Japan)
    • Known for: Dynamic playstyle, physicality, and offloading.
    • Key Achievements: Played for the Stormers and Munster; showing promise abroad in Japan.
  9. Phepsi Buthelezi

    • Club: Sharks
    • Known for: Leadership (captained the Sharks), pace, and breakdown skills.
    • Key Achievements: Captain of the Sharks in the Currie Cup; pushing for a Springbok call-up.
  10. Henco Venter

  • Club: Sharks
  • Known for: Consistency, defensive work, and solid ball-carrying.
  • Key Achievements: A dependable option in domestic competitions; provides depth and experience.

Summary

  • Vermeulen and Wiese are the front-runners for starting roles, with Vermeulen still vital as a mentor and Wiese a regular starter.
  • Roos and Louw represent the future, with the former known for his attacking prowess.
  • Players like Jean-Luc du Preez and Notshe offer versatility, while young talents like Theunissen and Buthelezi are emerging as exciting prospects.

This list balances proven international experience and promising domestic talent, offering the Springboks both power and flair at No. 8 for years to come.

LMAO! A generational talent like Cameron Hanekom doesn't even make ChatGPT's top 10. Again, further proof that ChatGPT ignores recent data and proof that AI isn't always on the button, despite what noobs like DumbAss think.

Oct 18, 2024, 20:54

That system is a joke if Hanekom is not included in the options at 8. Also it’s Dan du Preez that plays at 8 not JL. As for Vermeulen having retired well that says it all

Mapimpi ahead of Arendse is a joke as is Ox ahead of Kitshoff presently given Kitshoff is not playing and Ox is probably the best loosehead in the game right now

Powder puff ahead of RG is insulting

Willemse not in the starting side is a joke

Nyakane on the bench - he is history as is Reinach

 
You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top