Kearns wants the Jaguares out of Super Rugby

Forum » Rugby » Kearns wants the Jaguares out of Super Rugby

May 27, 2019, 15:10

The following from News 24:-

"Wallabies great Phil Kearns has called for the Jaguares to be kicked out of Super Rugby, claiming they have an unfair advantage as their line-up is so similar to Argentina's national team.

The hooker, now a television pundit, said the franchise had "hoodwinked" governing body SANZAAR and had ended up not only with a strong Super Rugby team, but also a better chance at this year's World Cup.

"They're the national team," the 67-Test veteran told Fox Sports. "They shouldn't even be in the comp.

"This is a provincial competition. Have a provincial team in it - that's what it's about. It's not about having national teams being in it."

Kearns was speaking after the Jaguares, most of them Argentina internationals, beat his former team the Waratahs 23-15 in Sydney on Saturday.

According to Fox, they had more than 1 000 international caps across their squad.

"I think Argentina have been incredibly smart and have hoodwinked the rest of SANZAAR because they're going to have a magnificent World Cup team, there's no doubt about it," Kearns, a two-time World Cup winner, added.

"They've played together for the last three years."

The Jaguares have the third best record in Super Rugby so far and are on a run of six wins from seven games, topping the South African conference by three points from the Sharks.

They entered the tournament in 2016 when it was boosted from 15 to 18 teams. It has since been cut back to 15, with South Africa's Southern Kings and Cheetahs, along with Australia's Western Force, axed.

Kearns' comments come after fellow Wallaby great Mark Ella argued that the Jaguares should compete with teams in their own region, due to the huge travel requirements.

He also called for the Pumas to be dumped from the Rugby Championship - which also involves Australia, New Zealand and South Africa - and play in the Americas Rugby Championship.

"No other sporting teams in any competition anywhere in the world endure the epic road trips of southern hemisphere rugby nations," he wrote in The Australian.

"In Super Rugby, the Jaguares play in the South African conference, their nearest neighbour, yet it is still 8 000 kilometres from Buenos Aires to Johannesburg. It just adds to the sense that Argentina are not where they belong.

"I would prefer to see Argentina play in the Americas Championship with Brazil, Canada, Chile, the US and Uruguay," added the former Wallabies captain.

Ella said the Pumas could still play the All Blacks, the Wallabies and the Springboks in the June Test window, and Six Nations teams in the November Test window.

"That way the Pumas could still experience competition against tier-one nations as well as promote rugby in the Americas, which has enormous potential for the growth of the game," he added.:

Allow me to make 1 comment on this baloney -   BS

May 27, 2019, 15:44

They are the best team in the South African conference. 

May 27, 2019, 16:44

Are they?   Look at the results within the Conference - and the results  against NZ and Aussie teams and then tell me where the problem really is.   Lets look at the results of the Jaguaresin game played:  

Within Conference 


Bulls at home            27 -  12 

Bulls away                20  -  22   

Sharks away              17 -  51 

Stormers                    30  -  25


Lion at home             16 - 25

Lions away                39 - 47

Stormers away            8 -  35

NZ  Conference


Blues at home            23 - 19

Hurricanes away        20 - 28    


Chiefs at home          27 -  30

Highlanders  away    30  -  27

Australian Conference


Brumbies at home      20 - 15

Waratahs  away          16 - 23       

So what is Kearns all about?   The factual  situation is as follows as a win - loss record of the Jaguares:-

SA teans   -    Win 4   Lose 3

NZ teams  -    Win 2   Lose 2

Aussie teams   Win 2  lose  0

Get the message?



May 27, 2019, 17:36

It's a con job benefitting Argentina. Win lose or draw it was a competition made for franchise/ptovincial teams not an international side. They have more than a head start going into the Rugby Championships and WC.

May 27, 2019, 18:12

It was done to give Argie rugby a boost. It's working...

Since when is sport supposed to be fair. There is a big difference in being fair or allowing a fair contest. Sport is supposed to be a fair contest...nothing more.

May 27, 2019, 20:10

I agree in principle that pumas aka jaguars should not be in the comp. However, I do believe that if Argentina want to compete in Super rugby then they should field a minimum of two teams. That way it will be fair. It will also be better for their rugby, but they will also need to prove that they can support them financially. But they should also be competitive. I would even go as far as to say that they need to field 3 teams like Aus did back in the day.

You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top