Wallabies head coach Joe Schmidt and powerhouse lock Will Skelton are under fire as Australia stumbles to a 0-2 deficit in the British and Irish Lions series. Former All Black Sir John Kirwan didn't hold back, lambasting Schmidt’s tactics and post-game comments following a heart-wrenching 29-26 defeat in Melbourne—a game that saw Australia blow an 18-point lead.
Kirwan, speaking on the Rivals podcast, was particularly critical of Schmidt's decision to sub out key players Rob Valetini and Will Skelton early, despite their impactful performances. “
'I listened to the post-match press conference and… just run them (Valetini and Skelton) until they can’t run would be my theory.'
I remember playing with a guy called Peter Fatialofa, who was the worst trainer but the best player. He would just go and go and go, and keep going. It’s a once-in-a-lifetime and I wouldn’t have taken them off,” Kirwan expressed.
The removal of Valetini and Skelton coincided with a surge by the Lions, who scored twice in the final 25 minutes to clinch the game and the series. Although it was later revealed that Valetini was injured, the timing of Skelton's substitution was questioned by many, including Kirwan.
The frustration spilled over into Schmidt’s post-game presser. Captain Harry Wilson’s remarks about the Wallabies being a work-in-progress did not sit well with Kirwan. “
'That is just bull****, this is Australia, this is one of the best teams in the world. This is the bloody two-time World Cup champions, I just don’t understand the dialogue at the moment.'
” Kirwan stated, clearly irked by the notion of Australia positioning itself as a developing team.
Further to his criticisms, Kirwan questioned the effectiveness of Super Rugby in preparing players for the rigors of Test rugby, especially compared to the northern hemisphere. This ongoing debate touches on a sensitive nerve across southern hemisphere rugby nations, questioning whether their domestic competitions are adequately equipping players for international challenges.
Kirwan’s sharp critique underscores the high expectations surrounding top-tier rugby nations and the intense scrutiny that comes with underperformance on such a grand stage. With one Test left in Sydney, the Wallabies face not just a battle against the Lions, but also a battle to restore faith in their national rugby prowess.
2,193 posts
Wallabies head coach Joe Schmidt and powerhouse lock Will Skelton are under fire as Australia stumbles to a 0-2 deficit in the British and Irish Lions series. Former All Black Sir John Kirwan didn't hold back, lambasting Schmidt’s tactics and post-game comments following a heart-wrenching 29-26 defeat in Melbourne—a game that saw Australia blow an 18-point lead.
Kirwan, speaking on the Rivals podcast, was particularly critical of Schmidt's decision to sub out key players Rob Valetini and Will Skelton early, despite their impactful performances. “
'I listened to the post-match press conference and… just run them (Valetini and Skelton) until they can’t run would be my theory.'
I remember playing with a guy called Peter Fatialofa, who was the worst trainer but the best player. He would just go and go and go, and keep going. It’s a once-in-a-lifetime and I wouldn’t have taken them off,” Kirwan expressed.The removal of Valetini and Skelton coincided with a surge by the Lions, who scored twice in the final 25 minutes to clinch the game and the series. Although it was later revealed that Valetini was injured, the timing of Skelton's substitution was questioned by many, including Kirwan.
The frustration spilled over into Schmidt’s post-game presser. Captain Harry Wilson’s remarks about the Wallabies being a work-in-progress did not sit well with Kirwan. “
'That is just bull****, this is Australia, this is one of the best teams in the world. This is the bloody two-time World Cup champions, I just don’t understand the dialogue at the moment.'
” Kirwan stated, clearly irked by the notion of Australia positioning itself as a developing team.Further to his criticisms, Kirwan questioned the effectiveness of Super Rugby in preparing players for the rigors of Test rugby, especially compared to the northern hemisphere. This ongoing debate touches on a sensitive nerve across southern hemisphere rugby nations, questioning whether their domestic competitions are adequately equipping players for international challenges.
Kirwan’s sharp critique underscores the high expectations surrounding top-tier rugby nations and the intense scrutiny that comes with underperformance on such a grand stage. With one Test left in Sydney, the Wallabies face not just a battle against the Lions, but also a battle to restore faith in their national rugby prowess.