The recent announcement of Moana Pasifika's potential disbandment at the end of the Super Rugby Pacific season has ignited a fervent dialogue about the sustainability and support structures necessary for rugby teams in the Pacific. The crisis comes after the team's financial backers declared an inability to continue funding beyond the current season, leaving players and staff in precarious positions and sparking calls for intervention from rugby's governing bodies.
Mils Muliaina, former All Blacks full-back, expressed his dismay on the Sky Sport’s Breakdown show, highlighting the foundational flaws that beset Moana Pasifika from the outset. "It’s obviously really gut-wrenching that Moana Pasifika are gone," Muliaina remarked. He questioned the initial setup, noting, "It was set up with a lot of emotion; there needed to be a team. Was it set up properly? Possibly not."
"What does it look like now for Moana Pasifika, and do they need to be saved? I still think there’s got to be a discussion around the investment that New Zealand and possibly even World Rugby need to put into that,"
Stephen Donald, echoing Muliaina’s sentiments, advocated for a robust investment strategy from World Rugby, particularly in light of the expanded Rugby World Cup format which now features a round of 16. "Without doubt, they need to be saved, but from a bigger picture point of view, World Rugby needs to step in," Donald emphasized. He pointed out the crucial role of Tonga and Samoa in the rugby world, stressing the necessity for their continued participation in global competitions.
Jeff Wilson, another stalwart of New Zealand rugby, argued that the financial burden should not fall solely on New Zealand Rugby. He criticized the drift of Moana Pasifika’s operational focus, which led to its identity as a de facto sixth New Zealand team rather than a genuine representative of Pacific rugby. "Everyone almost accepts that this has become a sixth New Zealand team," Wilson observed, advocating for a return to the original vision of creating a pathway for Pacific Island players.
Wilson further highlighted the broader implications of this financial crisis, pointing out the economic strains faced by all New Zealand Super Rugby teams. "It’s a tough one, though, because when you’re talking about resourcing, all of the New Zealand Rugby teams are going to lose money this year. All of them. No one is going to make any money right now. Everyone’s under financial pressure," he stated. This underscores the need for a collective approach involving SANZAAR and World Rugby in addition to NZ Rugby.
The plight of Moana Pasifika serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges faced in expanding rugby’s footprint while maintaining financial and operational viability. It calls for a concerted effort from all stakeholders to ensure the survival and success of such initiatives, which are vital for the sport's growth and the representation of underrepresented regions on the world stage.
349 posts
The recent announcement of Moana Pasifika's potential disbandment at the end of the Super Rugby Pacific season has ignited a fervent dialogue about the sustainability and support structures necessary for rugby teams in the Pacific. The crisis comes after the team's financial backers declared an inability to continue funding beyond the current season, leaving players and staff in precarious positions and sparking calls for intervention from rugby's governing bodies.
Mils Muliaina, former All Blacks full-back, expressed his dismay on the Sky Sport’s Breakdown show, highlighting the foundational flaws that beset Moana Pasifika from the outset. "It’s obviously really gut-wrenching that Moana Pasifika are gone," Muliaina remarked. He questioned the initial setup, noting, "It was set up with a lot of emotion; there needed to be a team. Was it set up properly? Possibly not."
"What does it look like now for Moana Pasifika, and do they need to be saved? I still think there’s got to be a discussion around the investment that New Zealand and possibly even World Rugby need to put into that,"
Stephen Donald, echoing Muliaina’s sentiments, advocated for a robust investment strategy from World Rugby, particularly in light of the expanded Rugby World Cup format which now features a round of 16. "Without doubt, they need to be saved, but from a bigger picture point of view, World Rugby needs to step in," Donald emphasized. He pointed out the crucial role of Tonga and Samoa in the rugby world, stressing the necessity for their continued participation in global competitions.
Jeff Wilson, another stalwart of New Zealand rugby, argued that the financial burden should not fall solely on New Zealand Rugby. He criticized the drift of Moana Pasifika’s operational focus, which led to its identity as a de facto sixth New Zealand team rather than a genuine representative of Pacific rugby. "Everyone almost accepts that this has become a sixth New Zealand team," Wilson observed, advocating for a return to the original vision of creating a pathway for Pacific Island players.
Wilson further highlighted the broader implications of this financial crisis, pointing out the economic strains faced by all New Zealand Super Rugby teams. "It’s a tough one, though, because when you’re talking about resourcing, all of the New Zealand Rugby teams are going to lose money this year. All of them. No one is going to make any money right now. Everyone’s under financial pressure," he stated. This underscores the need for a collective approach involving SANZAAR and World Rugby in addition to NZ Rugby.
The plight of Moana Pasifika serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges faced in expanding rugby’s footprint while maintaining financial and operational viability. It calls for a concerted effort from all stakeholders to ensure the survival and success of such initiatives, which are vital for the sport's growth and the representation of underrepresented regions on the world stage.