Boks ratings ... Planetrugby & NZHerald

Forum » Rugby » Boks ratings ... Planetrugby & NZHerald

Sep 13, 2025, 23:33

Springboks player ratings: ‘Perfect’ Damian Willemse and Bomb Squad as Cheslin Kolbe’s all-timer halted by ‘thuggish act’

Jared Wright 11 hours ago

20



Springboks Damian Willemse and Cheslin Kolbe in action against the All Blacks

Springboks Damian Willemse and Cheslin Kolbe in action against the All Blacks

Following a famous 43-10 Springboks victory over the All Blacks, here is how we rated Rassie Erasmus’ charges in the Rugby Championship win at Sky Stadium in Wellington.

Springboks player ratings v All Blacks

15 Aphelele Fassi: Forced off injured before half-time and seen with a boot on his foot on the touchline, a gutting injury for the full-back. He started the game rather well, dealing with the All Blacks’ high bomb adequately and had some good impacts in attack too. 6

14 Cheslin Kolbe: A thuggish no-arms tackle ended what was shaping up to be an all-time performance from the Springboks flyer, who was sensationally denied a try by Jordie Barrett. He then gave away a penalty but went about turning the tide and replicated his 2018 try at this same ground, his first for the Boks, picking off Billy Proctor’s pass outside his 22 and cantered away untouched to score a marvellous try. His finish early in the second half was not as box-office but by no means less impressive. Again, he was lively, effective and caused all kinds of havoc for the All Blacks before Tupou Vaa’i ended his night with an illegal tackle. 8

13 Canan Moodie: A few missed tackles, but he did shoot up and force errors from the All Blacks. He aided the attack well, running sharp lines, distributing well and on the whole, made good decisions. A real asset under the high ball with the tricky midfield bombs that the Boks profited on later in the game. 7

12 Damian Willemse: Forced to shift to full-back following the injury to Fassi after a starring start in the midfield. While Damian de Allende powers through defenders, Willemse’s close-contact skills are insane, and he flexed to great effect and was able to regularly find the weak shoulder. He continued to shine from full-back and produced promising moments, and outside of a handful of errors, it was an incredible performance from the double World Cup winner who looks to have rediscovered his form. He thundered the ball to the ground, an emphatic statement that he is back. Considering the magnitude of the result, his shifting around the backline and his overall influence, a perfect. 10

11 Ethan Hooker: The occasion of earning his first start against South Africa’s fiercest rivals did not get to the 22-year-old who produced a confident, competent and powerful performance, in his less favoured position no less. He competed superbly in the air and more than held his own. Stephen Donald had ‘never heard’ of Hooker before today’s game but the ex-All Black better play catch-up; this is not the last time we will see the youngster at this level. 7

10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu: Wasted a penalty with a horrible kick. He did have good moments in his short stint before being forced off injured, a real shame for the rising star. 5

9 Cobus Reinach: A somewhat surprising selection call and while it wasn’t the best of starts from the experienced scrum-half, he grew into the game. His kicking got better and better, and so did his attacking play, brilliantly sending Siya Kolisi through a gap. His passing was accurate and his service was speedy to cut open the All Blacks as the game went on. 7

Superb Springboks avenge Eden Park handing the All Blacks their biggest defeat EVER

Planet Rugby player ratings key 10 - Career defining performance 9 - Outright blockbuster effort 8 - Significantly influenced the result of the game 7 - Committed and effective outing 6 - Flashes of brilliance outside of executing fundamentals 5 - Fulfilling the role required by position (base level) 4 - Poor execution of fundamentals 3 - Costly errors and/or discipline in the game 2 - Poor performance that directly impacted the result 1 - Grossly ineffective throughout 0 - Should have carried water instead

the forwards

8 Jasper Wiese: A hulking performance from the powerhouse forward who thundered into the All Blacks’ defensive wall like a cement trucks with failed breaks. He managed to stay on the right side of the referee’s whistle for the most part in what was an impressive 80 minutes upon his return from suspension. 8


7 Pieter-Steph du Toit: His usual busy self around the park, and was far more potent in the wider channels. He was a real force at the lineout, whether that’d be on South Africa’s throw or New Zealand’s, and he superbly plucked the cross-kick out of the air and managed to get the pass away to assist Kwagga Smith’s try. Wasn’t quite at his best last week, but today, he absolutely was. 8

6 Siya Kolisi (c): Like Du Toit, he benefited from being in the wider channels, while the Springboks skipper was excellent at the breakdown. His break was nothing short of brilliant, while he was also strong defensively. 7

5 Ruan Nortje: A brilliant lineout steal swung the momentum squarely into South Africa’s favour and proved to be the moment that really sealed the result as Willemse danced his way to the try line. Relentless work-rate yet again. If he hadn’t already done so before today, he has cemented his place in the Springboks squad long-term. 8

4 Lood de Jager: Lasted just nine minutes before he was forced off the pitch. The lock really has a tough time with injuries. 5

3 Thomas du Toit: Pinged at scrum time early on but did start to get the upper hand in the set-piece and was strong in the carries yet again. 6

POPULAR ON PLANET RUGBY

Premiership Team of the Week: England star sends latest Test reminder while prodigy delivers 'unbelievable' performance

Premiership Team of the Week: England star sends latest Test reminder while prodigy delivers 'unbelievable' performance

Opinion: Teen sensation 'restores New Zealand rugby pride' as Black Ferns overcome Bok Women's 'heft and muscle'

Opinion: Teen sensation 'restores New Zealand rugby pride' as Black Ferns overcome Bok Women's 'heft and muscle'


Siya Kolisi hails coaches for giving Springboks 'freedom' in All Blacks' drubbing

Siya Kolisi hails coaches for giving Springboks 'freedom' in All Blacks' drubbing

Join the conversation

Have your say.Tackle the debate and engage in the comments.

Read All 20 Comments

2 Malcolm Marx: Some lineout failings remain but not nearly as bad as seven days ago. Excellent around the park on both sides of the ball which is stock-standard for the classy front-rower. 7

1 Ox Nche: Continued to dominate Tyrel Lomax in the scrums as he did last week and was surprisingly removed shortly after half time. Solid as ever from the loosehead. 7

Replacements: Erasmus was questioned for his decision to select a five-three split on the bench, but that decision was more than vindicated with three backs forced off in the first half and fourth early in the second. Manie Libbok put in a masterful 70-minute shift, inspiring the historic victory as the Springboks thrashed the All Blacks. Similarly, RG Snyman was outrageous as to was Grant Williams who featured at scrum-half and wing, making a clutch try-saving tackle on try-scoring machine Will Jordan. Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Wilco Louw were superb as too was hooker Marnus van der Merwe, while Andre Esterhuizen was destructive. Considering all the injuries, the Boks could have imploded but instead, they produced a classic Bomb Squad shift and exploded, powering South Africa to a famous victory. 10

READ MORE: All Blacks v Springboks, AS IT HAPPENED: How the stunning Rugby Championship clash unfolded

Features Damian Willemse

Latest from the

network

Wallabies v Los Pumas: Five takeaways as Argentina prove their 'elite' status while Joe Schmidt rues discipline 'imbalance'

Wallabies v Los Pumas: Five takeaways as Argentina prove their


Sep 13, 2025, 23:38

All Blacks v Springboks: How the Springboks rated in the Wellington test


Cameron McMillan

Deputy Head of Sport·NZ Herald·





Current Time 0:00

/

Duration 0:00

Loaded: 0






How the Springboks rated in their record win over the All Blacks in Wellington.

15 Aphelele Fassi - 7

Made an impact right from the start after winning the opening kickoff. Had a couple of strong runs but was hit and miss under the high ball. Turned the ball over... with a knock-on in own half and then left the field just before halftime. Looked threatening on attack.

14 Cheslin Kolbe - 7

Mixed night despite scoring a double. Lost early high ball followed by a turnover. Also spilled ball over the line from Jordie Barrett tackle. Penalised for a high tackle. But a brilliant intercept try and another good finish for his second.

13 Canan Moodie - 7

Switched from wing to the midfield replacing Jesse Kriel and certainly worth another go. Was an extra attacking option but also proved his worth in defense as the Boks leading tackler. Did lose four turnovers.

12 Damian Willemse - 10


In for Damian de Allende and made the most of the start. Pinged for not rolling away. Won a turnover and disrupted Jordan from setting up a scoring chance. Scored crucial third try. Denied Jordan try again with a great tackle. Finished with 90 metres carried, beat six defenders. Superb.

11 Ethan Hooker - 8

A few strong runs down the lefthand side in the first half. Won high kick off Billy Proctor. Great run from deep inside his own half, proved to be a huge turning point.

10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu - 5

Earned a start over Handre Pollard. Early mistake by missing touch with a chance for an attacking lineout. One attacking run and a good chip which almost setup a Kolbe try. Went off after 18 minutes with a failed HIA. A shame as would have been great to see more of him during these two tests.

9 Cobus Reinach - 8

Oldest on the field and the wise head put in some kind of shift. Left briefly for an HIA but came back and played the rest of the test. Commanded the Boks forwards and was reliable on the box kicks.

8 Jasper Wiese - 10


Best on the field in a huge showing after a four week ban. Led the test with 14 carries and also made eight tackles. A constant threat for the full 80.

7 Pieter-Steph du Toit - 8

Big effort in the last quarter. Six carries. Had a try assist to Smith which all-but secured the victory.

6 Siya Kolisi (c) - 7

Back to the side of the scrum. Huge run in lead-up to second Kolbe try. A decent outing but interesting to note the side sparked once he left the field.

5 Ruan Nortje - 9

Another massive 80 minutes. Gave the All Blacks line troubles late including huge lineout steal which led to third Boks try.

4 Lood de Jager - 5

Off after only nine minutes. Made a few tackles but not enough time to make an impression.

3 Thomas du Toit - 6

Part of a strong scrum in the opening 40, although he was pinged for a penalty at scrum time. One of the top tacklers in the time he was on the field.

2 Malcolm Marx - 6

Not his best showing. Overthrow on early attacking lineout. Had a knock-on. But the scrum was impressive. Made six tackles. Shown up by his replacement.

1 Ox Nche - 7

Made some strong runs, four in total, and was a key part of a Boks scrum that looked to dominate in the first half.

Who was your man of the match in Wellington?

250913AllBlacksSpringboks_053

Damian Willemse

Cobus Reinach

Jasper Wiese

Ruan Nortje

Other

Votes 5,916

Powered by

Reserves

Marnus van der Merwe - 8

Jan-Hendrik Wessels - 8

Wilco Louw - 8

RG Snyman - 9

Kwagga Smith - 8

Grant Williams - 8

Manie Libbok - 8

Andre Esterhuizen - 8






 
You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top