Amidst a backdrop of turmoil following a disastrous Six Nations campaign, England rugby legend Courtney Lawes has come out swinging against the Rugby Football Union (RFU), arguing that they are not fully equipping head coach Steve Borthwick to thrive. England's recent performance saw them slump to a dismal fifth place, continuing a trend of underachievement given the resources at their disposal.
Lawes, who has earned over a hundred caps for England, voiced his frustrations in a column for The Times. "That is not a great return, and I think that we have got our priorities all wrong," he lamented, pointing to a skewed focus towards the World Cup and long-term objectives at the expense of immediate competitions like the Six Nations. According to Lawes, the structure of English rugby does not maximize their chances of success in key tournaments.
The introduction of central contracts was a step forward but Lawes believes it's not enough. "Steve Borthwick has more influence over his core group of 25 players than any previous head coach but he cannot control how much they play or in what position," he stated. This lack of control, he argues, hampers England's ability to prepare players for the rigors of Test match rugby throughout the year.
"If you want to succeed at international level, then the head coach needs to have more say in what the players are doing, like Andy Farrell has with Ireland."
Comparatively, France under Fabien Galthie has managed to harness the synergy of key players from clubs like Toulouse and Bordeaux Bègles, leading to back-to-back Six Nations titles. Lawes highlighted the cohesion in the French squad, which contrasts sharply with the patchwork nature of the England team, recently comprised of players from seven different clubs.
The policy of not selecting players based overseas is another thorn in England's side, with Lawes emphatically criticizing the RFU's stance. "You can’t tell me that England wouldn’t have a better chance of winning a Six Nations title — or even the World Cup in 2027 if you insist on looking that far ahead — with a squad featuring Kyle Sinckler, Jack Willis, Tom Willis and David Ribbans," he argued.
As England rugby faces what Lawes calls an "ugly post-mortem", the debate over how best to manage national team affairs, balancing club and country, continues to stir passionate discussions and existential questions about the future direction of English rugby.
2,100 posts
Amidst a backdrop of turmoil following a disastrous Six Nations campaign, England rugby legend Courtney Lawes has come out swinging against the Rugby Football Union (RFU), arguing that they are not fully equipping head coach Steve Borthwick to thrive. England's recent performance saw them slump to a dismal fifth place, continuing a trend of underachievement given the resources at their disposal.
Lawes, who has earned over a hundred caps for England, voiced his frustrations in a column for The Times. "That is not a great return, and I think that we have got our priorities all wrong," he lamented, pointing to a skewed focus towards the World Cup and long-term objectives at the expense of immediate competitions like the Six Nations. According to Lawes, the structure of English rugby does not maximize their chances of success in key tournaments.
The introduction of central contracts was a step forward but Lawes believes it's not enough. "Steve Borthwick has more influence over his core group of 25 players than any previous head coach but he cannot control how much they play or in what position," he stated. This lack of control, he argues, hampers England's ability to prepare players for the rigors of Test match rugby throughout the year.
"If you want to succeed at international level, then the head coach needs to have more say in what the players are doing, like Andy Farrell has with Ireland."
Comparatively, France under Fabien Galthie has managed to harness the synergy of key players from clubs like Toulouse and Bordeaux Bègles, leading to back-to-back Six Nations titles. Lawes highlighted the cohesion in the French squad, which contrasts sharply with the patchwork nature of the England team, recently comprised of players from seven different clubs.
The policy of not selecting players based overseas is another thorn in England's side, with Lawes emphatically criticizing the RFU's stance. "You can’t tell me that England wouldn’t have a better chance of winning a Six Nations title — or even the World Cup in 2027 if you insist on looking that far ahead — with a squad featuring Kyle Sinckler, Jack Willis, Tom Willis and David Ribbans," he argued.
As England rugby faces what Lawes calls an "ugly post-mortem", the debate over how best to manage national team affairs, balancing club and country, continues to stir passionate discussions and existential questions about the future direction of English rugby.