Former Test referee Mathieu Raynal has thrown a hefty punch in the debate over Super Rugby Pacific’s 2026 law amendments. Despite claims from Super Rugby that these law "innovations" have the "emphatic support of clubs, match officials and stakeholders," Raynal is not alone in his criticism. The alterations, which involve penalty tries, rucks, quick taps, and the role of the TMO, have stirred significant controversy outside the New Zealand and Australia circuits.
Jaco Peyper, another former Test referee from South Africa who now advises on laws for the Springboks, voiced his reservations on the Rassie+ podcast, alongside assistant coach Felix Jones. "The intention here is to keep the game dynamic," said Peyper, doubting the new rules aiming to speed up the game. He detailed potential unintended consequences:
"Our championship works… That means that they’re not going to have the quick tap option, they’re probably going to wait to organize their team and kick an up and under. So, there are a lot of people calling for less kicks. With this, we are most likely going to add kicks, unless the free kick is given to the team that has possession."
Now the head of the high-performance unit for refereeing at the French Rugby Federation (FFR), Raynal argues that these changes diverge from the preferences of the northern hemisphere, which cherishes its rugby traditions of mauls, scrums, and strategic play. Speaking on Sud Radio, Raynal underscored a fundamental disconnect: "They [the southern hemisphere] want more passing, more tries, less time spent in mauls and scrums, whereas we [the northern hemisphere] defend these specific elements and are against directions being set by the southern hemisphere."
Raynal further highlighted the stark contrast in spectator attendance, "Our championship [the Top 14] works. Our stadiums are full, rugby is more watched than football in the country. We don’t want to follow directions coming from countries where stadiums are empty, where they are trying to recreate spectacle and bring people back to stadiums at any cost, even if it means sacrificing fairness and the principle of player safety."
This biting critique gained further visibility when David Wessels, SA Rugby's general manager for high performance, translated Raynal’s comments for social media. This translation caught the eye of Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus, who retweeted it, amplifying the dissent against Super Rugby's new law experiments.
2,100 posts
Former Test referee Mathieu Raynal has thrown a hefty punch in the debate over Super Rugby Pacific’s 2026 law amendments. Despite claims from Super Rugby that these law "innovations" have the "emphatic support of clubs, match officials and stakeholders," Raynal is not alone in his criticism. The alterations, which involve penalty tries, rucks, quick taps, and the role of the TMO, have stirred significant controversy outside the New Zealand and Australia circuits.
Jaco Peyper, another former Test referee from South Africa who now advises on laws for the Springboks, voiced his reservations on the Rassie+ podcast, alongside assistant coach Felix Jones. "The intention here is to keep the game dynamic," said Peyper, doubting the new rules aiming to speed up the game. He detailed potential unintended consequences:
"Our championship works… That means that they’re not going to have the quick tap option, they’re probably going to wait to organize their team and kick an up and under. So, there are a lot of people calling for less kicks. With this, we are most likely going to add kicks, unless the free kick is given to the team that has possession."
Now the head of the high-performance unit for refereeing at the French Rugby Federation (FFR), Raynal argues that these changes diverge from the preferences of the northern hemisphere, which cherishes its rugby traditions of mauls, scrums, and strategic play. Speaking on Sud Radio, Raynal underscored a fundamental disconnect: "They [the southern hemisphere] want more passing, more tries, less time spent in mauls and scrums, whereas we [the northern hemisphere] defend these specific elements and are against directions being set by the southern hemisphere."
Raynal further highlighted the stark contrast in spectator attendance, "Our championship [the Top 14] works. Our stadiums are full, rugby is more watched than football in the country. We don’t want to follow directions coming from countries where stadiums are empty, where they are trying to recreate spectacle and bring people back to stadiums at any cost, even if it means sacrificing fairness and the principle of player safety."
This biting critique gained further visibility when David Wessels, SA Rugby's general manager for high performance, translated Raynal’s comments for social media. This translation caught the eye of Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus, who retweeted it, amplifying the dissent against Super Rugby's new law experiments.