Owen Doyle, the former director of referees at the IRFU, has come out swinging against the officiating in Wales' recent Six Nations clashes against Scotland and Ireland. Doyle's scathing critique highlights what he perceives as unfair treatment towards the Welsh team, particularly in their dire loss to Ireland, a game that marked their 13th consecutive defeat in the tournament.
In a column for the Irish Times, Doyle dissected the contentious moments that tilted the scales against Wales. He pointed out a critical incident in the Scotland match where "Scotland’s late winning try followed a blatant illegal maul entry by their number eight, Matt Fagerson. He drove into the maul in front of the try scorer, George Turner, and contributed immensely to splitting open the Welsh defence." This oversight by assistant referee Karl Dickson and the silence from TMO Ian Tempest allowed the Scots to snatch victory, leaving Wales to rue what might have been.
Doyle didn't mince words about Dickson’s performance in the Ireland match either, suggesting that Welsh fans would prefer not to see him officiating their games anytime soon. The inconsistencies were glaring, especially when compared to the treatment of Irish infringements.
"Go compare, as the saying goes,"
Doyle remarked, highlighting the disparity in penalty decisions.
The former referee also questioned the legality of Jack Conan’s try for Ireland, suspecting an obstruction by Rónan Kelleher that went uncalled. "During any 80 minutes of test rugby, the majority of the referee’s job is relatively straightforward. It’s only when the chips are really down that they’re called upon to sort out the difficult, the tight, the knife-edge issues," Doyle explained.
Despite the controversial officiating, Wales' head coach Steve Tandy refrained from blaming the referees outright. Post-match, Tandy emphasized his team's efforts to foster a disciplined reputation, noting the skewed penalty count in their matches. "We only conceded seven with 280 tackles," Tandy pointed out, underlining the herculean defensive effort his team put up.
"We are building more of a reputation in and around that penalty count,"
he stated, acknowledging the need for continuous improvement.
The article also highlighted the resilience and tactical nuances of the Welsh side, despite the setbacks, suggesting a fierce determination to turn their fortunes around in future fixtures.
2,100 posts
Owen Doyle, the former director of referees at the IRFU, has come out swinging against the officiating in Wales' recent Six Nations clashes against Scotland and Ireland. Doyle's scathing critique highlights what he perceives as unfair treatment towards the Welsh team, particularly in their dire loss to Ireland, a game that marked their 13th consecutive defeat in the tournament.
In a column for the Irish Times, Doyle dissected the contentious moments that tilted the scales against Wales. He pointed out a critical incident in the Scotland match where "Scotland’s late winning try followed a blatant illegal maul entry by their number eight, Matt Fagerson. He drove into the maul in front of the try scorer, George Turner, and contributed immensely to splitting open the Welsh defence." This oversight by assistant referee Karl Dickson and the silence from TMO Ian Tempest allowed the Scots to snatch victory, leaving Wales to rue what might have been.
Doyle didn't mince words about Dickson’s performance in the Ireland match either, suggesting that Welsh fans would prefer not to see him officiating their games anytime soon. The inconsistencies were glaring, especially when compared to the treatment of Irish infringements.
"Go compare, as the saying goes,"
Doyle remarked, highlighting the disparity in penalty decisions.The former referee also questioned the legality of Jack Conan’s try for Ireland, suspecting an obstruction by Rónan Kelleher that went uncalled. "During any 80 minutes of test rugby, the majority of the referee’s job is relatively straightforward. It’s only when the chips are really down that they’re called upon to sort out the difficult, the tight, the knife-edge issues," Doyle explained.
Despite the controversial officiating, Wales' head coach Steve Tandy refrained from blaming the referees outright. Post-match, Tandy emphasized his team's efforts to foster a disciplined reputation, noting the skewed penalty count in their matches. "We only conceded seven with 280 tackles," Tandy pointed out, underlining the herculean defensive effort his team put up.
"We are building more of a reputation in and around that penalty count,"
he stated, acknowledging the need for continuous improvement.The article also highlighted the resilience and tactical nuances of the Welsh side, despite the setbacks, suggesting a fierce determination to turn their fortunes around in future fixtures.