Amidst swirling rumors of a rift and heated debates about the future direction of rugby, France has emerged from World Rugby’s Shape of the Game conference proclaiming satisfaction. The summit, a gathering of rugby’s elite in London, became the battleground for the sport’s evolving ethos, with France staunchly defending its traditional rugby values.
Mathieu Raynal, head of referees for the French Rugby Federation, represented France and voiced concern over proposals led by Australia and New Zealand to lessen the scrum's impact. These include a new amendment preventing scrums after a free-kick and trials in Super Rugby Pacific that might further diminish this classic set-piece. Raynal argued for a balance, advocating for the game's traditional fabric while being open to evolution. "We leave satisfied that we were listened to, heard, and supported in our vision for the overall well-being of our sport," Raynal stated, appreciating the forum’s collaborative spirit.
"Bringing together more than 200 people from all the world’s federations to find common ground is a real strength for the future of rugby,"
Despite initial reports of a divide at the conference, with France and South Africa pitted against Australia and New Zealand, the discussions concluded on a note of unity. Raynal emphasized the collective will to enhance the game's dynamism without compromising player safety or the integrity of play.
The conference also highlighted the contrasting styles of rugby championed in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres. While the Southern competitions seek to accelerate the game, attracting new audiences, Raynal pointed out that France’s domestic approach, particularly in the Top 14, remains highly successful and attritional, cautioning against unnecessary changes.
"Every time we propose a rule in the future, it will have to adhere to one of the fundamental principles of our sport, which is safety, fairness, or the continuity of the game,"
Raynal stressed the importance of a balanced approach to any future rule changes, ensuring they are backed by data and broad consensus. In a parting shot, he highlighted the need for World Rugby’s rule adaptations to respect the principle of fairness, giving equal weight to defensive strategies alongside offensive play.
By the end of the Shape of the Game conference, it seemed the rifts were more about divergent views on how best to proceed with rugby's evolution rather than irreconcilable differences, setting the stage for future debates on this ever-evolving sport.
2,100 posts
Amidst swirling rumors of a rift and heated debates about the future direction of rugby, France has emerged from World Rugby’s Shape of the Game conference proclaiming satisfaction. The summit, a gathering of rugby’s elite in London, became the battleground for the sport’s evolving ethos, with France staunchly defending its traditional rugby values.
Mathieu Raynal, head of referees for the French Rugby Federation, represented France and voiced concern over proposals led by Australia and New Zealand to lessen the scrum's impact. These include a new amendment preventing scrums after a free-kick and trials in Super Rugby Pacific that might further diminish this classic set-piece. Raynal argued for a balance, advocating for the game's traditional fabric while being open to evolution. "We leave satisfied that we were listened to, heard, and supported in our vision for the overall well-being of our sport," Raynal stated, appreciating the forum’s collaborative spirit.
"Bringing together more than 200 people from all the world’s federations to find common ground is a real strength for the future of rugby,"
Despite initial reports of a divide at the conference, with France and South Africa pitted against Australia and New Zealand, the discussions concluded on a note of unity. Raynal emphasized the collective will to enhance the game's dynamism without compromising player safety or the integrity of play.
The conference also highlighted the contrasting styles of rugby championed in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres. While the Southern competitions seek to accelerate the game, attracting new audiences, Raynal pointed out that France’s domestic approach, particularly in the Top 14, remains highly successful and attritional, cautioning against unnecessary changes.
"Every time we propose a rule in the future, it will have to adhere to one of the fundamental principles of our sport, which is safety, fairness, or the continuity of the game,"
Raynal stressed the importance of a balanced approach to any future rule changes, ensuring they are backed by data and broad consensus. In a parting shot, he highlighted the need for World Rugby’s rule adaptations to respect the principle of fairness, giving equal weight to defensive strategies alongside offensive play.
By the end of the Shape of the Game conference, it seemed the rifts were more about divergent views on how best to proceed with rugby's evolution rather than irreconcilable differences, setting the stage for future debates on this ever-evolving sport.