Confusion reigned in the dying minutes of a heated clash between Northampton Saints and Sale Sharks, yet the officials nailed their decision on a contentious try by Henry Pollock. Despite former England back Austin Healey's disbelief aired on TNT Sports, the lawbook backed up the call, keeping the Saints atop the PREM Rugby standings with a decisive 43-29 win over Sale.
In the 77th minute chaos ensued as Sale's Arron Reed attempted to keep the ball in play, setting the stage for a frantic sequence. Northampton’s Tommy Freeman pursued the bobbling ball, which Ernst Van Rhyn failed to secure, and made a critical in-field kick while stepping out of bounds. This move found Pollock, who dashed to the try line, sparking debates over the legality of the score. Healey, bewildered, remarked during the live broadcast,
"It’s a really good kick. Is he on the field when he kicks it, though? I’m not sure. Is Freeman’s right foot down when he puts boot to ball? But there is no question about Pollock’s gas and pace."
Referee Anthony Woodthorpe and the TMO reviewed the play, deeming Freeman’s action legal since he hadn't taken possession of the ball before kicking it back into play. "No, it’s play-on. The ball is in the field of play, he is not in possession of the ball… I’m happy, play on," Woodthorpe confidently declared. Healey, still puzzled, responded,
"It’s out! What? He is in possession when he touches it."
Woodthorpe’s decision was firmly rooted in World Rugby’s Law 18. Specifically, law 18.2.d clarifies that a player out of bounds can legally interact with the ball without taking it into touch, provided they don't hold it and it hasn’t crossed the plane of touch. Freeman's kick met these criteria, making the try valid—a nuanced ruling that left fans and former players like Andy Powell scratching their heads on social media.
The Saints now look forward to their next challenge against Leicester Tigers in the PREM Rugby Cup, while stars like Freeman and Pollock gear up for the Six Nations. This match not only underscored the complexities of rugby's laws but also highlighted the officials' sharp acumen in applying them under pressure.
2,193 posts
Confusion reigned in the dying minutes of a heated clash between Northampton Saints and Sale Sharks, yet the officials nailed their decision on a contentious try by Henry Pollock. Despite former England back Austin Healey's disbelief aired on TNT Sports, the lawbook backed up the call, keeping the Saints atop the PREM Rugby standings with a decisive 43-29 win over Sale.
In the 77th minute chaos ensued as Sale's Arron Reed attempted to keep the ball in play, setting the stage for a frantic sequence. Northampton’s Tommy Freeman pursued the bobbling ball, which Ernst Van Rhyn failed to secure, and made a critical in-field kick while stepping out of bounds. This move found Pollock, who dashed to the try line, sparking debates over the legality of the score. Healey, bewildered, remarked during the live broadcast,
"It’s a really good kick. Is he on the field when he kicks it, though? I’m not sure. Is Freeman’s right foot down when he puts boot to ball? But there is no question about Pollock’s gas and pace."
Referee Anthony Woodthorpe and the TMO reviewed the play, deeming Freeman’s action legal since he hadn't taken possession of the ball before kicking it back into play. "No, it’s play-on. The ball is in the field of play, he is not in possession of the ball… I’m happy, play on," Woodthorpe confidently declared. Healey, still puzzled, responded,
"It’s out! What? He is in possession when he touches it."
Woodthorpe’s decision was firmly rooted in World Rugby’s Law 18. Specifically, law 18.2.d clarifies that a player out of bounds can legally interact with the ball without taking it into touch, provided they don't hold it and it hasn’t crossed the plane of touch. Freeman's kick met these criteria, making the try valid—a nuanced ruling that left fans and former players like Andy Powell scratching their heads on social media.
The Saints now look forward to their next challenge against Leicester Tigers in the PREM Rugby Cup, while stars like Freeman and Pollock gear up for the Six Nations. This match not only underscored the complexities of rugby's laws but also highlighted the officials' sharp acumen in applying them under pressure.