Hypotheticals...

Forum » Rugby » Hypotheticals...

Oct 04, 2024, 19:11

No rugby. So may as well speculate a little...and talk the proverbial.

The rules: You have to pick a non-conventional side. Your team can be comprised of any type of player. They may utilise any gameplan as long as it remains within the rules. You may pick former or current players, or even composites(of course within reason because everybody would love a Lomu that could step like Cheslin and think like DuPont- be reasonable with the make-up of your player's abilities/size). You can even make up players of your own(again, be reasonable...don't make up players that couldn't actually exist).

The outcome: You have to justify why that side would beat any team in the world today.

Note: this is hypothetical - to be taken with a pinch of salt.

Oct 04, 2024, 19:19

15. Willemse

14. Arendse

13. Kriel

12. DdA

11. Cheslin

10. Sasha

9. Williams/Hendrikse

8. Hanekom

7. PSDT

6. SIYA (C)

5. Mostert

4. Eben

3. Frans

2. Marx

1. Ox


They already beat everyone...Wiese only current Bok I'd replace now...and reluctantly,  but Hanekom is breaking down the door.:angel:...only way to blood new players are off the bench...


And sorry Plum, I didn't misunderstood your request...I'm too lazy to think about it...the scope is too big for my small tired mond.:D



Oct 04, 2024, 19:24

Superman as Flyhalf and the Hulk as Blindeside flanker. On defence I will have the Flash….done my 3 man team will win everything:)

Oct 04, 2024, 19:29

BATMAN must be 10...Superman can be a handy rest of the backline all-in-1...Thor must be @ 8....oh wait...

Oct 04, 2024, 19:33

Ha ha yes we have a thor already, even if he is retired. Interesting in a post match interview with Duane he admits to still doing Contact training together with the Boys ….still showing them a thing or two:)

Oct 04, 2024, 19:46

One of my favorite players of all time...

Oct 04, 2024, 20:00

Now, I'm not saying you totally disobeyed all of the very few rules I put in place for this theory crafting exercise...but for fuck sakes...YOU BROKE EVERY SINGLE RULE I PUT IN PLACE FOR THIS THEORY CRAFTING EXERCISE!

Still funny though ;)

Oct 04, 2024, 20:05

Anyway, I pick Doctor Manhattan and don't need the 14 other players.

He can perceive time non linearly, manipulate matter at a fundamental level and teleport.

Let's stick to the mandate.

Oct 04, 2024, 20:54

Players picked in the period after readmission…..

Cullen

Kolbe

O Driscoll

Nonu

Lomu

Carter

Joost

Beast

Woods

Hayman

Savea

Etzebeth

Matfield

Schalk

Zinzan Brooke




Oct 04, 2024, 21:12

1. Os Du randt

2. Uli Schmit

3. Wilco Louw

4. Eben

5. Franco

6. Cameron Hanekom

7. Pieter Stef

8. Elrigh Louw

9. Fourie Du Preez

10. SFM

11. Pieter Russouw ( Slap Chips)

12. AE

13. Danie Gerber

14. Kolbe

15.Fassi

16. Steenekamp 17. Marx 18. Cobus Vidagie 19. Ruben van Heerden 20. Duane 21.Faf 22.Jaques Fourie 22.carel du plessis

Oct 04, 2024, 21:25

15. Willemse 100kg

14. Kolbe 90kg 100m in 9.6 sec

13. Gerber 105 kg

12. de Allende 110kg

11. Habana 98kg 100m in 9.7 sec

10. Pollard 95kg 98% kicking record

9. Joost 90kg

1. Os 135kg bench press 250kg

2. Marx 120kg

3. Malherbe 140kg bench press 250kg

4. Etzebeth 7ft 140kg

5. RG Snyman 7ft 140kg

6. Joe v Niekerk 105kg

7. PSDT 125kg

8. Bob Skinstad 110kg

16. Bismark 17. Ox 18. Wilco Louw 19. Matfield 20. Kwagga 21. du Preez 22. Jean 23. Arendse

Oct 04, 2024, 22:44

Bok team:

A Joubert

Kolbe

M Joubert

JDV

Habana

Pollard

Joost

Beast

Marx 

Malherbe

Vermeulen

Etzebeth

Matfield

Schalk 

Skinstad

Oct 04, 2024, 23:29

Gerber was our top 13 followed by Am in my books - Fourie, Joubert, Jessie and Mulder up there but I can’t place them

At a push - Fourie, Mulder, Joubert then Jessie

Oct 05, 2024, 06:53

For some odd reason Gerber played inside center with a 13 on his back...started a lot of games at inside...go check.

Oct 05, 2024, 08:35

Mr Penguin at 9.

Oct 05, 2024, 09:39

15 German Shepherd, 14 Greyhound, 13 Doberman Pinscher, 12 Rhodesian Ridgeback, 11 Whippet, 10 Standard Poodle, 9 Jack Russell; 8 Rottweiller, 7 Boerboel, 6 Labrador, 5 Irish Wolfhound, 4 Great Dane, 3 English Bulldog, 2 Bull Terrier, 1 Staffordshire Terrier.

Oct 05, 2024, 09:43

"14. Kolbe 90kg 100m in 9.6 sec"


Link please.

Oct 05, 2024, 10:06

Great Springbok names:

15 Bunny Reid, 14 Boetie McHardy, 13 Flappie Lochner, 12 Spanner Forbes, 11 Percy Twentyman-Jones, 10 Long George Devenish, 9 Popeye Strydom, 8 Saturday Knight, 7 Pinkie Daneel, 6 Ebbo Bastard, 5 Fairy Heatlie, 4 Salty du Randt Moaner van Heerden,  3 Koei Brink Mof Myburgh, 2 Piston van Wyk, 1 Bingo Burger.

Oct 05, 2024, 10:20

Mof Myburgh  Moaner van Heerden   bomb squad?

Oct 05, 2024, 10:23

Yes, good ones! Both definitely at least bomb squad. Maybe even starters.

Oct 05, 2024, 14:39

I think I love Percy Twentyman-Jones :D

Oct 05, 2024, 15:04

I like Saturday Knight best . . . and you have to wonder how Long George Devenish (a halfback) got his name!

Oct 05, 2024, 15:39

Basie van Wyk. Mannetjies Roux. Uli (pronounced Olie)  Schmidt…to back up Piston van Wyk. 

And Dogue de Bordeaux at 8th man, Rottweiler  moves to 6 and Labrador to the bench,

Oct 05, 2024, 15:47

"Labrador to the bench"


Nope. There's not a better fetcher than a Labrador . . . other than my French Bulldog Billy of course.

Oct 05, 2024, 15:55

I don’t think Dave would like your props….much too small for modern rugby, lightweight pretenders. 


Oct 05, 2024, 16:04

"Nope. There's not a better fetcher than a Labrador . . . other than my French Bulldog Billy of course."

Golden Retriever...puts up hand...paw...and Malinois for fullback.

Oct 05, 2024, 16:05

Let’s not forget the modern names Beast Mtawarira  and Ox Niche

Oct 05, 2024, 16:20

Ox is even more destructive than Beast...

Oct 05, 2024, 18:39

A bomb squad for your team, Rooi...

16. Doggo Argentino 17. Anatolian Shepherd 18. Cane Corso 19. Kangal Shepherd 20. Phila Brasileiro 21. Alaskan Malamute 22. Akita 23. Newfie

8-0 split...

Or you could just bring the Akita and leave everyone else at home.

Oct 06, 2024, 07:43

here's that bomb squad...


Bombsquad

Oct 06, 2024, 08:27

ccl

Oct 06, 2024, 18:51

NCWYTSSTFU ;)

Oct 06, 2024, 18:51

NCWYTSSTFU ;)

 
You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top