Dave
It would be in teresting to see what Erasmus and Browne come up with. You are probably right about the loosies - especially
Du Toit and Roos as playes that have the ball sense and skills to participate in backline attacks.
Dave
It would be in teresting to see what Erasmus and Browne come up with. You are probably right about the loosies - especially
Du Toit and Roos as playes that have the ball sense and skills to participate in backline attacks.
Tell me how you can pick dumb Lood over a Ruben van heerden on the bench??!! and yet again Dud the ball killer at 12?? Same old Shit, different Day!!
Roos is not an incumbent. He has hardly any test exposure…..he needs to show he can do it at the next level. But he does have the ability to run with the ball….something our ball carrier Dud Toit sorely lacks. He also helps out with Dud Toit’s woeful inability on the ground. I hope he makes it.
No more Lomp….a never has been.
And in the backs there is zero chance the incumbent side can execute a switch to a ball in hand game plan. Why? Because there there is road block….cul de sac at 12. Put Dud in space and he will veer into the first defender he can find.
And please don’t tell us how Dud was in 67 world teams McCaw was in many more and you don’t rate him.
The other thought that comes to mind is how old this team is in the forwards. Eluckmiss has zero starters he introduced. That leaves us with a complete revamp before WC 2027.
Listen here Mpower given how fucking rugby ignorant you are any take on a player I take with a pinch of salt
No Moz Roos is not the incumbent but our incumbent has retired - Roos is by far the next best
It’s not the job of a lock turned blindside to compete on the ground - geez I thought you knew your rugby
DA is the best 12 in the game damn right he starts
Stop dodging the Question…seriously how can you pick lood and not the Ruben you been so impressed with? His form, his age , everything counts in his favour….what happened to picking the young inform players for a change? This is the same 1 point thriller team. Not even a heathly mix of new inform players….dud is a dead end…..picking this team is not progress.
Because Lood is a class act a proven test star and is not done yet - simple really
Like Matfield said - Lood is the best 5 lock in the game
RG is better but Lood is one of the best
Ruben v Heerden is the future, his turn comes soon
Picking this team is spot on - it’s a WC winning side that happens to be number 1 in the game
Get a fucking grip
No you need to get a grip…as you want to place our hope on has beens like Lood….he is not in that form at the moment and most probably never again. This incumbent team is not a progressive move to ensure future depth… some of those incumbents should be there yes, but the rest should be the inform players that were picked…the sooner you throw them in the action, the better for them and the team in a whole. Simple really.
Ruben ahead of lood any day for me...can RG play 4 when Eben retires?
27,948 posts
My incumbent side would be:
15. Willemse
14. Kolbe
13. Am
12. de Allende
11. Arendse
10. Pollard
9. Faf
1. Kitshoff
2. Marx
3. Malherbe
4. Etzebeth
5. RG Snyman
6. Kolisi
7. PSDT
8. Roos
16. Bongi 17. Ox 18. Wilco Louw 19. Lood 20. Kwagga 21. Williams 22. Libbok 23. Esterhuizen
Next best side:
15. Gelant
14. Nkosi
13. Moodie
12. David Kriel
11. Fassi
10. Masuku
9. Papier
1. Gerhard Steenkamp
2. Dweba
3. Thomas du Toit
4. Jenkins
5. Ruben v Heerden
6. Emmanuel Tsituka
7. Elrigh Louw
8. Hanekom
16. Grobelaar 17. Mchunu 18. Sadie 19. Ruan Vermaak 20. JL du Preez 21. Nohamba 22. Sacha 23. Henco v Wyk