As the dust settles on yet another stinging defeat for the All Blacks, rugby icon Justin Marshall is throwing down the gauntlet, challenging head coach Scott Robertson to shake up his strategic playbook. With the Springboks and England revolutionizing the use of substitutes in recent Rugby World Cups, Marshall is baffled by New Zealand's adherence to a more traditional bench structure.
South Africa's innovative approach to their squad composition, notably their bold 6-2 or even 7-1 forwards-to-backs ratio on the bench, has reaped considerable success, capturing back-to-back World Cup titles. This tactic was emulated by England in their recent 33-19 triumph over the All Blacks, a strategy that visibly altered the game's dynamics and intensity.
"For f*** sake, why do we not want to be innovative and go, 'righto we’re going to go 6-2 or 7-1?'"
Marshall expressed his frustration on the GBRANZ podcast, criticizing the All Blacks' reluctance to adopt a similar strategy. "When England with their ‘Pom Squad’ did what they did, the game dynamic changed. They got real energy out of that, whereas we still put them on in dribs and drabs," he noted. Marshall highlighted the strategic deployment of England's substitutes, which he believes contributed significantly to their elevated energy levels and overall game impact.
Meanwhile, Andy Powell, former Wales and Lions number eight, also weighed in during the podcast, lauding the depth and quality of the England team. "Pollock, Curry, Genge, Stuart, they’re massive names who should be starting. It shows the strength that England have got, it’s probably the best England squad they’ve had since the 2003 World Cup – unbelievable players," Powell remarked.
The conversation also touched on the potential for the All Blacks to leverage their versatile players more effectively. Marshall argued for the benefits of having players who can operate across multiple positions, citing Ardie Savea as a prime example of versatility who could fill various roles in a pinch. "We can emulate that but we don’t want to. We want to carry that extra back reserve and I don’t understand why when we’re supposed to have these players that can play across the backline," he added.
This ongoing debate underscores a broader conversation about innovation in rugby tactics, as teams like South Africa and England continue to challenge conventional wisdom, leaving fans and legends alike questioning if the All Blacks will adapt or continue to uphold tradition.
2,193 posts
As the dust settles on yet another stinging defeat for the All Blacks, rugby icon Justin Marshall is throwing down the gauntlet, challenging head coach Scott Robertson to shake up his strategic playbook. With the Springboks and England revolutionizing the use of substitutes in recent Rugby World Cups, Marshall is baffled by New Zealand's adherence to a more traditional bench structure.
South Africa's innovative approach to their squad composition, notably their bold 6-2 or even 7-1 forwards-to-backs ratio on the bench, has reaped considerable success, capturing back-to-back World Cup titles. This tactic was emulated by England in their recent 33-19 triumph over the All Blacks, a strategy that visibly altered the game's dynamics and intensity.
"For f*** sake, why do we not want to be innovative and go, 'righto we’re going to go 6-2 or 7-1?'"
Marshall expressed his frustration on the GBRANZ podcast, criticizing the All Blacks' reluctance to adopt a similar strategy. "When England with their ‘Pom Squad’ did what they did, the game dynamic changed. They got real energy out of that, whereas we still put them on in dribs and drabs," he noted. Marshall highlighted the strategic deployment of England's substitutes, which he believes contributed significantly to their elevated energy levels and overall game impact.
Meanwhile, Andy Powell, former Wales and Lions number eight, also weighed in during the podcast, lauding the depth and quality of the England team. "Pollock, Curry, Genge, Stuart, they’re massive names who should be starting. It shows the strength that England have got, it’s probably the best England squad they’ve had since the 2003 World Cup – unbelievable players," Powell remarked.
The conversation also touched on the potential for the All Blacks to leverage their versatile players more effectively. Marshall argued for the benefits of having players who can operate across multiple positions, citing Ardie Savea as a prime example of versatility who could fill various roles in a pinch. "We can emulate that but we don’t want to. We want to carry that extra back reserve and I don’t understand why when we’re supposed to have these players that can play across the backline," he added.
This ongoing debate underscores a broader conversation about innovation in rugby tactics, as teams like South Africa and England continue to challenge conventional wisdom, leaving fans and legends alike questioning if the All Blacks will adapt or continue to uphold tradition.