Justin Marshall is throwing the gauntlet down at the feet of Scott Robertson, accusing the New Zealand coach of sticking too rigidly to outdated tactics. While the rugby world evolves, Marshall blasts the All Blacks’ bench strategy, or lack thereof, especially in light of their recent thumping by England, which ended in a 33-19 defeat. While other nations are beefing up their benches with forward-heavy reinforcements, New Zealand clings to the traditional 5-3 split.
On the GBRANZ podcast, Marshall let loose his frustration,
"For f**k sake, why do we not want to be innovative and go 6–2 or 7–1?"
He pointed out how England’s strategic injection of five fresh players changed the game's complexion, adding a burst of energy that the All Blacks couldn’t match with their staggered substitutions.
The strategy of loading the bench with forwards has led to consecutive World Cup victories for the Springboks and has been swiftly adopted by other top rugby nations like England and France. Marshall believes New Zealand has the talent to adopt a similar strategy but lacks the boldness to shift away from the norm. “We can emulate that but we don’t want to. We want to carry that extra back reserve and I don’t understand why,” he lamented.
Highlighting the versatility of players like Ardie Savea, Marshall suggests that New Zealand has the resources to be flexible under pressure. “If we got really in the s**t, you could put Ardie in the midfield, you could put him on the wing, and he would do a good job of it.”
Former Wales and Lions No 8 Andy Powell chimed in with high praise for England’s depth, proclaiming their bench “the best England squad since 2003.” Despite this, New Zealand’s reluctance to adapt their strategy continues to puzzle Marshall.
"Are we feeling like South Africa are getting it wrong when they do it? England are getting it wrong when they do it?"
As international rivals enhance their game plans, the pressure mounts for New Zealand to reconsider their approach or risk falling further behind. Marshall’s outspoken critique highlights a critical crossroads for the All Blacks: innovate or remain stagnant.
2,193 posts
Justin Marshall is throwing the gauntlet down at the feet of Scott Robertson, accusing the New Zealand coach of sticking too rigidly to outdated tactics. While the rugby world evolves, Marshall blasts the All Blacks’ bench strategy, or lack thereof, especially in light of their recent thumping by England, which ended in a 33-19 defeat. While other nations are beefing up their benches with forward-heavy reinforcements, New Zealand clings to the traditional 5-3 split.
On the GBRANZ podcast, Marshall let loose his frustration,
"For f**k sake, why do we not want to be innovative and go 6–2 or 7–1?"
He pointed out how England’s strategic injection of five fresh players changed the game's complexion, adding a burst of energy that the All Blacks couldn’t match with their staggered substitutions.The strategy of loading the bench with forwards has led to consecutive World Cup victories for the Springboks and has been swiftly adopted by other top rugby nations like England and France. Marshall believes New Zealand has the talent to adopt a similar strategy but lacks the boldness to shift away from the norm. “We can emulate that but we don’t want to. We want to carry that extra back reserve and I don’t understand why,” he lamented.
Highlighting the versatility of players like Ardie Savea, Marshall suggests that New Zealand has the resources to be flexible under pressure. “If we got really in the s**t, you could put Ardie in the midfield, you could put him on the wing, and he would do a good job of it.”
Former Wales and Lions No 8 Andy Powell chimed in with high praise for England’s depth, proclaiming their bench “the best England squad since 2003.” Despite this, New Zealand’s reluctance to adapt their strategy continues to puzzle Marshall.
"Are we feeling like South Africa are getting it wrong when they do it? England are getting it wrong when they do it?"
As international rivals enhance their game plans, the pressure mounts for New Zealand to reconsider their approach or risk falling further behind. Marshall’s outspoken critique highlights a critical crossroads for the All Blacks: innovate or remain stagnant.