Former Test referee Nigel Owens has weighed in on the critical officiating decisions from the first Test match between the British and Irish Lions and the Wallabies, a game that saw Andy Farrell's squad take a 1-0 series lead with a 27-19 win in Brisbane. Amidst the high-stakes drama, several calls by the officials became focal points for discussion.
Owens dissected each significant decision, starting with Huw Jones' disallowed try due to a double movement. He expressed surprise at the controversy it stirred.
"It was a good decision and a pretty straightforward one,"
Owens remarked, clarifying that a tackler must release the ball carrier once the tackle is completed, opposing the notion that Jones should continue because he was released immediately.
Another major decision involved Tom Curry, who was not yellow-carded for a mid-air tackle on Tom Lynagh. Owens supported the referee's judgment, distinguishing between mistiming and intentional foul play.
"Curry here gets his timing wrong but it's not deemed to be a dangerous action. Penalty only the correct decision."
The 'Battle of Ballymore' also brought contentious moments, notably Tadhg Furlong's clearout on Len Ikitau, which some argued warranted a sin-bin. Owens backed the referee's call, suggesting that the actions were legal and the contact incidental. He even hinted that a penalty might have been too harsh, stating,
"Well refereed, well managed and the correct outcome as well."
Late in the game, Joseph Suaalii's disallowed try due to failing to release the ball sparked debate. Owens agreed with the decision, explaining the difference in Suaalii's situation compared to Jones'. He pointed out that Suaalii was slightly unfortunate as his teammates influenced the play's outcome.
Ben Earl's tackle on Suaalii was another contentious issue, with some spectators claiming it was a no-arms hit. Owens believed there was an attempt to wrap, which aligns with the need for player safety through lower tackles.
Owens concluded that overall, Ben O’Keeffe and his team of officials had a commendable performance, navigating the high-pressure environment effectively and making the right calls on key decisions.
2,199 posts
Former Test referee Nigel Owens has weighed in on the critical officiating decisions from the first Test match between the British and Irish Lions and the Wallabies, a game that saw Andy Farrell's squad take a 1-0 series lead with a 27-19 win in Brisbane. Amidst the high-stakes drama, several calls by the officials became focal points for discussion.
Owens dissected each significant decision, starting with Huw Jones' disallowed try due to a double movement. He expressed surprise at the controversy it stirred.
"It was a good decision and a pretty straightforward one,"
Owens remarked, clarifying that a tackler must release the ball carrier once the tackle is completed, opposing the notion that Jones should continue because he was released immediately.Another major decision involved Tom Curry, who was not yellow-carded for a mid-air tackle on Tom Lynagh. Owens supported the referee's judgment, distinguishing between mistiming and intentional foul play.
"Curry here gets his timing wrong but it's not deemed to be a dangerous action. Penalty only the correct decision."
The 'Battle of Ballymore' also brought contentious moments, notably Tadhg Furlong's clearout on Len Ikitau, which some argued warranted a sin-bin. Owens backed the referee's call, suggesting that the actions were legal and the contact incidental. He even hinted that a penalty might have been too harsh, stating,
"Well refereed, well managed and the correct outcome as well."
Late in the game, Joseph Suaalii's disallowed try due to failing to release the ball sparked debate. Owens agreed with the decision, explaining the difference in Suaalii's situation compared to Jones'. He pointed out that Suaalii was slightly unfortunate as his teammates influenced the play's outcome.
Ben Earl's tackle on Suaalii was another contentious issue, with some spectators claiming it was a no-arms hit. Owens believed there was an attempt to wrap, which aligns with the need for player safety through lower tackles.
Owens concluded that overall, Ben O’Keeffe and his team of officials had a commendable performance, navigating the high-pressure environment effectively and making the right calls on key decisions.