As the dust settles on a riveting Six Nations Championship, former Test referee Nigel Owens weighs in, suggesting the game's laws don't need an overhaul but a tweak here and there. With World Rugby holding firm at the Shape of the Game conference, it appears the structure of rugby laws is here to stay, backed by the spectacle of this year's tournament.
Diving into the fray with his seasoned perspective, Owens shared his thoughts in his column after a weekend of thrilling victories for Scotland, Ireland, and Italy.
"It was the Six Nations at its very, very best, where there was excitement, upsets and everything you want."
This, according to Owens, is a testament to the adequacy of the current rugby laws when applied with a focus on the essence of the game rather than the minutiae.
However, Owens did express concern over the scrum dynamics, which have been a point of contention, particularly from the southern hemisphere. Contrary to calls for law changes, Owens believes the solution lies not in rewriting the rulebook but in its enforcement. "The scrum needs to be officiated better and stronger. Players need to be more positive in the scrum because we’re still seeing some games where sides can be very negative, resulting in collapses, resets and standing up," he noted, calling for a crackdown on negative tactics and a reward system for strong, legal scrummaging.
Amidst his broad approval of the status quo, Owens pinpointed one specific area for adjustment — the 'held-up' law. The recent shift in this law now rewards the defense, a move Owens argues should be reevaluated to favor attacking play.
"I think you should promote the attack, not the defence. What the current rule does is reward the defence, and players now just chuck their bodies on the ground close to the goal line."
This change, he argues, not only dulls the excitement but potentially increases the danger with more players opting for 'speed bump' tackles without proper wrapping.
With World Rugby confirming a 'universal agreement' at the summit, it appears that significant law changes are off the table for now. However, Owens' insight provides a valuable perspective on how minor tweaks, rather than overhauls, could enhance the game while preserving its integrity and excitement. As rugby continues to evolve, the balance between tradition and innovation remains a delicate dance.
2,100 posts
As the dust settles on a riveting Six Nations Championship, former Test referee Nigel Owens weighs in, suggesting the game's laws don't need an overhaul but a tweak here and there. With World Rugby holding firm at the Shape of the Game conference, it appears the structure of rugby laws is here to stay, backed by the spectacle of this year's tournament.
Diving into the fray with his seasoned perspective, Owens shared his thoughts in his column after a weekend of thrilling victories for Scotland, Ireland, and Italy.
"It was the Six Nations at its very, very best, where there was excitement, upsets and everything you want."
This, according to Owens, is a testament to the adequacy of the current rugby laws when applied with a focus on the essence of the game rather than the minutiae.However, Owens did express concern over the scrum dynamics, which have been a point of contention, particularly from the southern hemisphere. Contrary to calls for law changes, Owens believes the solution lies not in rewriting the rulebook but in its enforcement. "The scrum needs to be officiated better and stronger. Players need to be more positive in the scrum because we’re still seeing some games where sides can be very negative, resulting in collapses, resets and standing up," he noted, calling for a crackdown on negative tactics and a reward system for strong, legal scrummaging.
Amidst his broad approval of the status quo, Owens pinpointed one specific area for adjustment — the 'held-up' law. The recent shift in this law now rewards the defense, a move Owens argues should be reevaluated to favor attacking play.
"I think you should promote the attack, not the defence. What the current rule does is reward the defence, and players now just chuck their bodies on the ground close to the goal line."
This change, he argues, not only dulls the excitement but potentially increases the danger with more players opting for 'speed bump' tackles without proper wrapping.With World Rugby confirming a 'universal agreement' at the summit, it appears that significant law changes are off the table for now. However, Owens' insight provides a valuable perspective on how minor tweaks, rather than overhauls, could enhance the game while preserving its integrity and excitement. As rugby continues to evolve, the balance between tradition and innovation remains a delicate dance.