In the fiery clash between Ireland and South Africa, two contentious tackles stirred debate and scrutiny—neither of which saw the offenders receiving yellow cards, despite the dangerous nature of the plays. Former elite referee Nigel Owens weighed in, suggesting that the officials missed the mark on these calls during the Dublin showdown.
The first incident involved Springboks fly-half Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, who delivered a high tackle on Irish winger Tommy O’Brien. Pieter-Steph du Toit first halted O’Brien, setting the stage for Feinberg-Mngomezulu to crash into him, making contact with the head. The on-field review led by referee Matthew Carley concluded without a yellow card—a decision Owens openly criticized.
"I would have given a yellow card for that because he certainly goes in with no attempt to wrap with the shoulder,"
Owens remarked, implying that the lack of an early card perhaps set a lenient tone for the match.
Likewise, the tackle by O’Brien on Canan Moodie later in the half also escaped a yellow card. O’Brien, absorbing the impact, clashed heads with Moodie, yet only received a penalty. Owens dissected this decision, pointing out the insufficient drop in height and passive nature of the tackle that still resulted in head contact.
"Even though you’re absorbing it, you are still at fault because you haven’t made the effort to get lower,"
he explained, advocating that such incidents should typically warrant a yellow card.
Owens, alongside former Wales and Lions centre Jamie Roberts on World Rugby’s Whistle Watch show, discussed the implications of passive and active collisions in tackles. They debated the nuances of player safety and the responsibilities of tacklers and ball carriers alike. This conversation underscored the ongoing challenges officials face in enforcing tackle laws, and the need for players to adapt their techniques to ensure safer gameplay.
Owens ended on a note urging coaches and players to practice safer tackling techniques to reduce the referees' burden and enhance player safety. "Get your tackles lower. You take everything out of the official’s hands then," he advised, signaling a call for urgent change in player behavior on the field.
2,193 posts
In the fiery clash between Ireland and South Africa, two contentious tackles stirred debate and scrutiny—neither of which saw the offenders receiving yellow cards, despite the dangerous nature of the plays. Former elite referee Nigel Owens weighed in, suggesting that the officials missed the mark on these calls during the Dublin showdown.
The first incident involved Springboks fly-half Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, who delivered a high tackle on Irish winger Tommy O’Brien. Pieter-Steph du Toit first halted O’Brien, setting the stage for Feinberg-Mngomezulu to crash into him, making contact with the head. The on-field review led by referee Matthew Carley concluded without a yellow card—a decision Owens openly criticized.
"I would have given a yellow card for that because he certainly goes in with no attempt to wrap with the shoulder,"
Owens remarked, implying that the lack of an early card perhaps set a lenient tone for the match.Likewise, the tackle by O’Brien on Canan Moodie later in the half also escaped a yellow card. O’Brien, absorbing the impact, clashed heads with Moodie, yet only received a penalty. Owens dissected this decision, pointing out the insufficient drop in height and passive nature of the tackle that still resulted in head contact.
"Even though you’re absorbing it, you are still at fault because you haven’t made the effort to get lower,"
he explained, advocating that such incidents should typically warrant a yellow card.Owens, alongside former Wales and Lions centre Jamie Roberts on World Rugby’s Whistle Watch show, discussed the implications of passive and active collisions in tackles. They debated the nuances of player safety and the responsibilities of tacklers and ball carriers alike. This conversation underscored the ongoing challenges officials face in enforcing tackle laws, and the need for players to adapt their techniques to ensure safer gameplay.
Owens ended on a note urging coaches and players to practice safer tackling techniques to reduce the referees' burden and enhance player safety. "Get your tackles lower. You take everything out of the official’s hands then," he advised, signaling a call for urgent change in player behavior on the field.