Sacha out of RC

So he was not one of the rested he has a knee injury that requires surgery

Apparently he will only be out for 4 to 6 weeks and available for the end of year tour

Resting a youngster never made sense - but we now have clarity

Bad news, he has become everyone's favourite player. He is going for surgery, but it is not clear what the injury is. 

Rassie Erasmus has revealed that Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu has suffered a knee injury that will keep the young playmaker out of the Rugby Championship finale against Argentina.

Feinberg-Mngomezulu did not travel with the 28-player Springbok squad to Argentina for the penultimate round of the tournament, after playing in all four Rugby Championship games against the Wallabies and All Blacks.

Sacha will only be ready for the end-of-year tour with a knee injury,” Erasmus said. “He injured his knee before the first Test against the All Blacks.

“He played through it. I asked him during the next week why he was limping and he said he injured his knee last week.

“I actually really wanted to pull him out of the team because he was limping. That’s what we need the players to understand, you must be honest about injuries. Sacha is lucky we won both of those Test matches.

“He is having the operation now. I’m not exactly sure what is wrong with his knee, but he will be ready in around four to six weeks.”

He played injured (sustained before the game) with a bomb squad of 2 backline players against the All Blacks in the first test, Rassie seems upset

Maybe Erasmus got it wrong.    Shaca played most of the first test when he started and was on the bench and played at least 35 minutes since Pollard was replaced by Shaca early in the second half.    During the match afer a tackle Shasa limped slightly for a few steps and he carried on like  everything was fine. He completed  the match  - what was clear that after that Shaca missed two kicks at goal.

It must have been after the second test that  problem was really identified,    In matches pain does not felt until the cooling down afer the mach.    If he became aware of he knee problem befoe the second test Shaca would not  have been on the bench for the second AB test.   

Shaca probably had he opeation already so effectively  Erasmus would  have become aware of it and sent him to the specialsts for immediate treatment.    Probably the problem is with the knee-cap - in itself not a major problem, so he will be missing only the Argentine tests and some URC matches in Ocotber 2024.

       .                

Rassie's words when Bongi was injured in the RWC final was to get him off the field if he's not 100% as they can't afford to play with a liability. I can imagine that he's upset, especially because  a star player like Sacha probably aggravated that injury by playing through it.

So in the week after the first AB win while Sacha was training, Rassie noticed the limp and asked SFM. He replied he is injured.

So why allow him to keep on training and play in the second AB test?? Rassie should be upset with himself and no one else.

I do not think Rassie would have played him if he was aware of he injrury caried by Shaca.   Erasmus s very roective of the players and if eh kne about Shaca carrying an injury would never have allowed him to play,.

So ou think you BS spreading is true.   Ther was no injury indication as to Shaca n teh frst test  and if Erasmus knew there was a problem before the second test he would not have played him.  

The frst ime there were any real signs of injury was in the second test - but Sacha was not treated for anything.   I seem that Shazca started limping after the second test that he has a problem and  in fact showed it.

Stop talking unproved shit on site please.  

Here directly from Erasmus: " He injured his knee before the first Test against the All Blacks.

“He played through it. I asked him during the next week why he was limping and he said he injured his knee last week.

“I actually really wanted to pull him out of the team because he was limping. " - But Rassie didn’t pull him out of the team.

He kept on playing in the second test and now the injury is more serious, and needs a operation.

Therefore Rassie can only be cross with himself. He was aware of the injury and still played him in the second Test. Check your spelling and level of BS Spreading Uncle C !

You make BS deductions - you idiotic twit.   Keep it up we already know what we expect from you being the rugby village idiot.

Explain why it is BS deductions, when the story is straight from Erasmus on how it happened?? Honestly get a grip Uncle Mike.

Read he following report on the injury issue from MSN  - maybe it would gt though your hink skull as to what realy happened:-

 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu has undoubtedly been the breakthrough star for the Springboks this year, featuring prominently at flyhalf as Rassie Erasmus has fully backed the talented youngster.

Feinberg-Mngomezulu did not travel with the Springbok squad to Argentina for this weekend’s Rugby Championship Test, though, and Erasmus has revealed that he in fact suffered a knee injury before the first match against the All Blacks.

The 22-year-old went on to start at Ellis Park before coming off the bench in the second game in Cape Town against New Zealand, but it did seem that he was somewhat hampered by the knee injury – particularly when it came to his goal-kicking.

Erasmus has now revealed that Feinberg-Mngomezulu had not been fully transparent about the injury, and warned about the dangers of this.

“Sacha will only be ready for the end-of-year tour with a knee injury,” Erasmus said. “He injured his knee before the first Test against the All Blacks.

“He played through it. I asked him during the next week why he was limping and he said he injured his knee last week.

“I actually really wanted to pull him out of the team because he was limping. That’s what we need the players to understand, you must be honest about injuries. Sacha is lucky we won both of those Test matches.

Apparently Easmus only foud out the injury after the Second test in Cape Town.  So stop spreading BS on siie.

Once again the tedious Clever spreads insults and is then presented the facts by M. Does he apologize? No the disgusting old fool just insults him again.

Apologize moron and while you are about it, apologize for your ignorant call and insults about the lineout captain,

I’m in two minds about Sacha’s non communication. On the one hand he owed his coach a heads up that he was not 100%. On the other hand I love the fact that he wanted to compete. This kid never came onto the field as a newbie, he took charge. Our youngsters tend to be too respectful, Sacha took on the Irish with total confidence and he wanted a full crack at the ABs. That’s a good thing.

Read the article I posted shitbrain.

Thee caling of line-outs is not anymore from the line-ou iself - but ported to ethrower by the scrumme or a prop and nobody really know what appened dung discussion of he issue befoe t message is delivered to te thrower - so I have not anyhng o apologiz for.   e had shit line-ou callers in 2015 and th caller was Matfield.    Even if the caller is the number 5 lck - he is not the captain of anything, 

    .

Once again I quote Rassie Erasmus, who presumably knows whether he is using a lineout captain:

‘ “It was just overthrown by the hooker and sometimes they didn’t even go up so that’s a timing issue,” the Bok boss explained.

“We have to understand that a guy like Ruan Nortje is early in his career and it was only his second game against New Zealand.

“Last week, we had Pieter-Steph help him call the lineout but this week it was solely on him, so he will have learnt a lot and the All Blacks did their homework and contested well.”

Ag shame, kid still has a lot to prove. Had some good flashes and cameos, long road for him. Just hope the hype settles around him now. If any of the pretenders want to de-throne Pollard, they need to show nerves of steal. Can the come on in knock out games and convert all of their kicks, rock solid on defence and last all game. organise their backline and make great kicks 

Sasha has a long road ahead of him. 

Manie's bubble has already burst in the World Cup quarter finals and he is on the down. I thought Rassie would start with him but it clearly shows he has no trust in him

Manie is not bad in general play, but unless he can shape up his tackling and his goal kicking, he is not really a serious option. Missed 5 of his 10 tackles in that quarter.

"Manie is not bad in general play, but unless he can shape up his tackling and his goal kicking, he is not really a serious option."

Agree. Time to give Siya Masuku a shot.

Ja, don't forget that Marie also coughs the ball up a lot in contact. He is a confidence player and when it goes wrong, it really goes wrong for him. Reminds a bit Elton that had all the creative play but couldn't tackle and when he got tackled, threw the ball away. 

I like Sasha, but he was just called out playing with injuries. He should be careful or he will be chucked out really quickly. I wonder if Rassie will drop him or if he will stick with him. 

That to me is a huge breach of trust, how can you play a game against the all blacks, knowing you injured. 

Manie is a class player

KC

Shasa is a oungster who wants to play for the Springboks at all costs.   He probably got a lecture from Trump about the dangers attached to hide injuries and will learn from that decision of his.  I do  think he learned from what happened and it will not happen again.

What  did see from Shasa is that despite the injury he performed better than Pollard did in both the tests.

In reality Pollard has already been dethroned  and he is going to be around for helping and mentoring the younger players but he is unlikely to be in the 2027 WC squad,