In a clash that reignited the fiery rivalry from the 2023 Rugby World Cup quarter-final, the Springboks faced a significant setback when Lood de Jager received a full red card for a dangerous tackle on Thomas Ramos during the first half at Stade de France. The game was tightly poised with France leading, thanks to quick scoring and dynamic play, but the red card threw the South African game plan into disarray.
Former Springbok flanker Schalk Burger openly criticized the decision on SuperSport's halftime show. "It’s just a rugby incident," he argued, pointing out the physical dynamics at play during the incident. "Look, his knee is touching the ground, the straight, permanent red is where I get confused. It is a ‘high level of danger’, but not dangerous enough to send Ramos for a HIA," he added, echoing Siya Kolisi's in-game remarks to referee Angus Gardner.
"Straight red? I can’t agree with that."
The controversial tackle occurred after Cobus Reinach's electrifying solo try had narrowed the scoreline to 14-13. Ramos, tackled by Reinach, was already going down when De Jager made contact, his shoulder connecting with Ramos' head. Referee Angus Gardner, after consulting with TMO Ian Tempest and without further review from the Foul Play Review Officer, issued the red card, leaving the Springboks to contend with 14 men.
Burger highlighted the mechanics of the tackle, noting De Jager's position. "And what got him was the tucked left shoulder. Ramos is down, and you’ve got to feel for Lood. You look at it in real time, that tackle happens 90 times a weekend. And if you slow it down, it’s just that left shoulder where he tucked," he explained. Burger emphasized the natural instinct to tuck the shoulder in such close-contact situations.
The decision had immediate tactical implications for the Springboks. Head coach Rassie Erasmus was compelled to pull Siya Kolisi, marking his 100th test match, to bring in lineout specialist Ruan Nortje, significantly altering the team's structure and strategy for the remainder of the match.
This red card decision not only sparked debate over the officiating but also highlighted the razor-thin margins that often decide the outcomes in high-stakes international rugby.
2,193 posts
In a clash that reignited the fiery rivalry from the 2023 Rugby World Cup quarter-final, the Springboks faced a significant setback when Lood de Jager received a full red card for a dangerous tackle on Thomas Ramos during the first half at Stade de France. The game was tightly poised with France leading, thanks to quick scoring and dynamic play, but the red card threw the South African game plan into disarray.
Former Springbok flanker Schalk Burger openly criticized the decision on SuperSport's halftime show. "It’s just a rugby incident," he argued, pointing out the physical dynamics at play during the incident. "Look, his knee is touching the ground, the straight, permanent red is where I get confused. It is a ‘high level of danger’, but not dangerous enough to send Ramos for a HIA," he added, echoing Siya Kolisi's in-game remarks to referee Angus Gardner.
"Straight red? I can’t agree with that."
The controversial tackle occurred after Cobus Reinach's electrifying solo try had narrowed the scoreline to 14-13. Ramos, tackled by Reinach, was already going down when De Jager made contact, his shoulder connecting with Ramos' head. Referee Angus Gardner, after consulting with TMO Ian Tempest and without further review from the Foul Play Review Officer, issued the red card, leaving the Springboks to contend with 14 men.
Burger highlighted the mechanics of the tackle, noting De Jager's position. "And what got him was the tucked left shoulder. Ramos is down, and you’ve got to feel for Lood. You look at it in real time, that tackle happens 90 times a weekend. And if you slow it down, it’s just that left shoulder where he tucked," he explained. Burger emphasized the natural instinct to tuck the shoulder in such close-contact situations.
The decision had immediate tactical implications for the Springboks. Head coach Rassie Erasmus was compelled to pull Siya Kolisi, marking his 100th test match, to bring in lineout specialist Ruan Nortje, significantly altering the team's structure and strategy for the remainder of the match.
This red card decision not only sparked debate over the officiating but also highlighted the razor-thin margins that often decide the outcomes in high-stakes international rugby.