Scotland vs All Blacks: Player Ratings Highlight

Forum » Rugby » Scotland vs All Blacks: Player Ratings Highlight

Nov 08, 2025, 21:06

In the wake of Scotland's 25-17 defeat to the All Blacks during the Autumn Nations Series at Murrayfield, the performance of the Scottish players was a mixed bag of grit, flair, and missed opportunities. Here’s a breakdown of how each player fared in this intense encounter.

Blair Kinghorn was a beacon of reliability, particularly on the offensive, weaving through All Blacks' defenses and setting up Kyle Steyn for a pivotal try. Despite this, his defensive lapses contributed to all three tries by the opposition, marking his performance with a mix of brilliance and blemish.

Darcy Graham's agility shone on the wings; he nearly scored a well-deserved try but lost control of the ball at a critical moment. His defensive commitment, however, was unmistakable.

Rory Hutchinson struggled to make a significant impact, with missed tackles and a muted offensive presence, reflecting a less-than-stellar day for the center.

"From the outset, our captain Sione Tuipulotu was a dynamic force, testing the All Blacks' defense continuously."

His efforts not only showcased his attacking prowess but also his defensive solidity, earning him high marks for his overall contribution.

Kyle Steyn justified his selection with a solid all-around game, highlighted by a try and commendable bravery in aerial duels. Finn Russell, after a quiet start, grew into the game, his pinpoint goal-kicking pulling the Scots back into contention, though his early defensive work was found wanting.

Ben White showed improvement as the game progressed, exhibiting class in both attack and defense after some early struggles against his All Blacks counterpart.

Jack Dempsey was the embodiment of determination, 'emptying the tank' with powerful carries and relentless defense. Despite his efforts, he was overshadowed by the dynamic Ardie Savea in their head-to-head battle.

Gregor Brown and Matt Fagerson put up strong defensive performances, but Fagerson’s impact at the breakdown was not enough to turn the tide against the formidable New Zealand side.

The front row, led by Pierre Schoeman, held firm in scrums and made their presence felt with ball in hand, though the replacements struggled to maintain the momentum later in the game.

Ewan Ashman and Scott Cummings put in commendable shifts, with Ashman crossing for a try and Cummings anchoring the lineout and defense during their time on the field.

Ultimately, the reinforcements introduced by Gregor Townsend could not capitalize on the foundation laid earlier, and the All Blacks regained control to seal the victory. This game was a testament to Scotland’s resilience but also highlighted areas needing refinement if they are to overcome top-tier teams like New Zealand.

 
You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top