Why I've Changed My Mind on Evan Roos

Forum » Rugby » Why I've Changed My Mind on Evan Roos

Oct 20, 2025, 14:23

If you've been following the United Rugby Championship (URC) like I have, you know the Stormers have been putting on quite a show this season. Evan Roos completely flipped my opinion: Evan Roos. I'll admit it—I never used to like him. Maybe it was his style back in the day, or perhaps I was just biased from early impressions and maybe some shitty press articles about him. But after watching him rack up three Man of the Match (MoM) performances in quick succession, I've done a full 180. His work rate, dedication in the tight play, aggression, and blistering speed have won me over. More than that, I now firmly believe Evan Roos deserves a spot in the Springbok squad. Before MPower and Mike throw stones at me, let me break it down for you—why I've changed my mind and why he's ready for the green and gold.


From Skeptic to Fan: What Turned Me Around


Let's start with the basics. He has always been a talent on paper. But for me, it took seeing him in action consistently to appreciate his growth. Those three MoM awards? They weren't flukes. In recent URC matches, Roos has been everywhere on the field, turning games with his sheer presence.


First off, his work rate is off the charts. Hedoesn't shy away from the dirty work like he used to in past seasons... and maybe that was one of his biggest downfalls. Whether it's carrying the ball into contact multiple times per game or making tackle after tackle, he's relentless. I remember one match where he seemed to be involved in every ruck, every maul—it's like he has an extra gear that keeps him going when others fade. That kind of endurance isn't just impressive; it's the kind of thing that wins championships.


He seems to thrive in the close-quarters battles where games are often decided. His ability to secure possession at the breakdown, support his teammates in scrums, and drive through defenses in the forwards is top-tier. I've seen him burrow into piles of bodies and emerge with the ball, time and again. It's not flashy, but it's effective, and it's exactly what the Stormers need to dominate in the URC.


But what really sealed the deal for me? His aggression and speed. Roos plays with a fire that's infectious—he's not afraid to throw his weight around, but he does it smartly, channeling that energy into explosive runs and bone-crunching tackles. Pair that with his surprising speed for a big fella, and you've got a player who can break lines and create opportunities out of nothing. Watching him accelerate through gaps or chase down wingers has been a highlight of the season. It's this combination that made me rethink my stance: Roos isn't just a brute; he's a complete athlete who's evolved his game.


We are world champions, and the squad is stacked with talent like Jasper Wiese and emerging stars. But Roos brings something unique that could elevate the team even further. Here's why I think he belongs in that elite group:


1. Rassie loves players who can adapt, and Roos fits the bill. He can slot in at No. 8 or even openside or blindside flank, offering depth and flexibility. With injuries and rotations always a factor in international rugby, having a guy like Roos—who's proven he can perform under pressure in the URC—would be a smart addition.


2. South African rugby is built on power, but Roos adds finesse. His aggression aligns perfectly with the Boks' "bomb squad" mentality, where forwards come off the bench to dominate the second half. Imagine him linking up with the likes of Siya Kolisi or Pieter-Steph du Toit—his speed could open up space for the backs, while his tight play ensures the forwards maintain control.


3. Those three MoM awards aren't just personal accolades; they're evidence of his ability to shine in high-stakes games. The URC is no slouch—it's competitive, physical rugby against top teams from Europe and South Africa. If Roos can excel there, he's ready for Test matches. Plus, he's already had some Bok exposure in the past.


4. Beyond stats, Roos has shown maturity. He's bounced back from setbacks, like injuries or form dips, and come out stronger. That dedication and work ethic could inspire the younger players in the Bok setup. In a team that's all about unity and resilience, Roos embodies the Springbok spirit.


Of course, selection isn't up to fans like me—it's down to coaches like Rassie Erasmus. But based on what I've seen, ignoring Roos would be a missed opportunity. He's not just good; he's Springbok material.


Changing your mind on a player isn't easy, especially when you've been vocal about your dislikes in the past (guilty as charged). But Evan Roos has earned my respect through pure performance. His work rate, tight-play dedication, aggression, and speed have transformed him from a player I overlooked to one I can't wait to watch. If the Springboks are looking to build on their legacy, Roos deserves a shot. What do you think?

Have you changed your mind on any players lately?

Oct 20, 2025, 14:34

Good on you Chip


Roos has always been a class above but for some unknown reason, he does not fit into Rassie’s team environment.


We are not privy to why he is not a personality fit, for his exclusion has nothing to do with his merit as a player


If you can’t crack a Bok squad after three MOM awards in quick succession then you know it’s down to something other than rugby which is really, really sad


Let’s just hope that at some point soon this status quo changes as I’d hate to see Roos at 30 having only won a handful of test caps


Jasper Wiese is good at what he does - is power player - Roos is that and more, he is the complete athlete - speed, power, skill and aggression


Plays the power game well but equally the attacking and linking game - something we don’t get from Jasper


For me it’s a no brainer - Roos would be my starting Bok 8 right now

Oct 20, 2025, 14:47

Van Staaden...couldn't stand him, but he did well this season for the Bokke...Jasper Wiese too...didn't like him too much last season, but he was great for thr Bokke this year.

Oct 20, 2025, 15:09

Roos Is a talented player, but clearly Dr Lucky doesn’t rate him and that’s been very consistent. Watching him on Saturday he looks much the same player, trying to impress with his physicality. In that regard he is a distant second to Wiese. He needs to play a Skinstad/ Big Joe type role, where he could be excellent. But it seems Lucky doesn’t value that from an eighth man, probably because he was always second fiddle to Skinstad.

Oct 20, 2025, 15:16

I don't see why Roos can't be a part of the mix. Agree with Chips that Roos has a lot of utility. He can carry, hunt and link. He also has speed and a big tank.


The chat from Rassie to Roos would have been that he should keep performing and making a difference. Roos has done that. Though, I'm not sure who received money to give him MOTM this weekend after what Sacha did.


As was said on another thread, he's trying to play like Wiese but he's not Wiese. If anything he should be playing more like Hanekom - has the pace and handling for it. Ironically, he's probably slightly more powerful and quicker than Hanekom, but Rassie was gearing up to give Hanekom a long old run this year.


The rumours are probably true and Roos' exclusion is not due to a "rugby reason".


Oct 20, 2025, 15:17

lol Snap!

Oct 20, 2025, 15:18

Second fiddle to Skinstad?

Skinstad played at 8 most of the time.

Rassie played 6.


Please explain.


Roos has won 3 MoM awards out of 4. He's clearly impressing some people.

Wahat are YOUR thoughts on him Moz?

Oct 20, 2025, 15:22

Roos is quite a good linking player, but not a brute 8th man. He is still trying to be something he’s clearly not.


Still runs like a berserker at the opposition, but just don’t get the same penetration as a Jasper Wiese.


He should focus more on a linking role and fetching possibly….play him at 6 and see what happens….


Oct 20, 2025, 15:25

"Still runs like a berserker at the opposition"


Such a paradox because while I see it as a weakness in his game, I really enjoy that he's 100% kill mode all the time. Even in the most mundane of situations, the man's face is blood red and people have to calm him down. I dunno, there's something enduring about it.



Oct 20, 2025, 15:27

Slightly disagree M.

He links very well and also has the strength to break advantage lines time and again.

ive watched the Stormers closely this year... I think they have what it takes to go all the way.

In doing so, i've kept a very close eye on Roos. He has a lot of power to match his link play.

I think he is ripe for the picking now.


In saying that, I also don't know what his personality is like. Is he a trouble maker? Is he like that piece of shit Watson?

I dont know enough about him to comment.

Oct 20, 2025, 15:36

Oh what utter shit, Roos’s physicality is right up there with the best. I’d give Wiese the slight edge in physicality but very slight.


Roos trumps Wiese in every other attacking aspect by some distance


Roos is the better 8, always has been as is Hanekom. I rate Wiese, but these two are better


Rassie not picking Roos is not rugby related - only a fucking idiot what not see that and we have a few old idiots on board here

Oct 20, 2025, 15:37

Well, I have seen a interview with him after his shoulder Surgery.


Can’t remember clearly, think it was with JDV or Schalk, he seems to be a really nice guy. Well spoken.

Oct 20, 2025, 15:43

Yes he is a nice lad but his father seems to be the problem


Is very outspoken and opinionated about his son - to the point it has pissed off WP and now the Boks


That is the rumour from a good few months back

Oct 20, 2025, 16:00

David, I also heard this... do you have any verified reports?

Again, sounds like a Luke Watson saga all over again where daddy fucks things up for son.


Yes he is a nice lad but his father seems to be the problem


Is very outspoken and opinionated about his son - to the point it has pissed off WP and now the Boks

Oct 20, 2025, 16:03

No I’m not sure where it comes from - my mates back home told me about it a few months ago


But I trust Rassie is bigger than that - he is not Jake White

Oct 20, 2025, 16:45

Jake was right, Watson wasn’t test material….that was proven under PdV who gave him every chance. Roos has far better physical credentials, but he hasn’t found his game plan yet. Wiese has, Hanekom has…and their styles suit the team. So they are ahead in the DrLucky plan.


Roos could be an important cog in Brown ball, but will we play Brown ball against Ireland and France?

Oct 20, 2025, 17:16

Wrong Watson was easily test material, you don’t win Super rugby player of the year being an average player


Luke was an outstanding rugby player. He was a better openside than Schalk ever was


Schalk was too big for openside - was more suited to 7 or 8


Luke was good over the ball and an awesome linking 6


Luke’s off field politics and not his rugby unfortunately ultimately defined him


Jake has always been a shit player manager - there was no way he could cope with the issues Luke brought - a better player manager like Rassie might have done a far better job of getting Luke the player on side

Oct 20, 2025, 17:21

As for Dr Lucky’s lack of interest in Roos, it could be game plan, but one would think with Brown ball being touted he’d at least be in the squad. So -perhaps Lucky isn’t convinced this is the way to go.


It’s possible it could be irritation with him because of his old man. This view could be held by the coaches or even the senior players like Dud, Eben and Kolisi. Maybe the team is not receptive to his presence. That was certainly the case with Watson.


But perhaps Lucky simply doesn’t buy into the Skinstad type of 8th man, which Roos has the potential to be. Lucky played his last game for the Boks in 2001 against France at 6, Krige was at 7 and Vos at 8.


In the next game against Italy Venter came in for Krige and Vos was moved to 6 to replace Lucky, to make way for, you guessed it, Skinstad at 8. That became the loose forward choice for the rest of 2001. And Skinstad became captain!


With Vos dropping away, there was a chance for Lucky to come back, but no Big Joe, another Roos type was picked at 6. Lucky departed the international stage at the young age of 28.


It’s possible there is a personal element here, it happens in sport.



Oct 20, 2025, 17:45

Whatever it is, it’s very sad to see, as on merit and current form there is no more deserving a player than Roos to be a Bok right now


I can’t recall a more wasted talent ever - the game is not up yet for Roos as he is on standby but it’s simply not good enough and is part of why I question Rassie at times

Oct 20, 2025, 17:51

By the way, good post Chip, well reasoned and logical.

Oct 20, 2025, 22:19

Roos should be in the squad. Rassie could have dropped Klein or Mostert. We don't in my opinion need so many locks, plus DuToit can easily play lock plus you have guys on stand bye.

All in all its a strong squad.

Oct 22, 2025, 07:16

Well, Rassie dislikes Roos so much that even after Roos has been with the Boks, been on standby, has caps, and starts the URC with a bunch of MOTM performances, he is still ignored.


We've departed to Europe on a longer than normal EOYT, during which we'll play both Ireland and France, after we've shown that we are a far better team when we don't play 10 man rugby, but Rassie has only picked one proper 8 in the squad...Wiese.


Now, doesn't that make you wonder?


Why was Roos on stand-by at the start of the year?


Why, after Trokkie and Dups were both injured, did Rassie fail to pluck Roos from stand-by status and into the squad, instead plying Siya at 8...which didn't work?


Every single event that should cause Roos to be selected has occurred, from injuries to Roos's performances.


It's easy, Rassie doesn't like Roos and no amount of hard work or performance is gonna make Rassie humble himself and pick him.


...and because he doesn't like Roos he believes it's his prerogative to mess him around eternally.


I think it's scummy to block a boy's career when he's done everything he needs to and more, simply because you have some vendetta with him and/or his family.


Actions of a small man.





Oct 22, 2025, 07:50

'Actions of a small and Arrogant man'

Oct 22, 2025, 12:05

You lot of moaners never cease to criticize Rassie picks. He is always wrong about something

BUT look at his incredible record. Obviously he knows things you lot don't know. I venture to say he knows a huge amount you ignorant lot don't know.

You are too wrapped up in RDS to realize the more you rant on about Rassie being a fool, malignant selector etc etc the dafter you appear. Bwahahahahaha.

Yes I think Roos should have been included. But do I know all Rassie knows. Of course not. Your lack of respect for this outstanding Bok coach reflects more on YOU than Rassie.



Oct 22, 2025, 12:09

Mampara power Rassie was a great Bok flanker and s today the leading coach in the World.

What have you pets9nalmyvachieved to stack up against Rassie in terms of playing rugby and coaching. What gives you the right to call him a small and arrogant man. Do tell!

You on the other hand are a hapless mampara. The evidence is all over this board. Hahahahahaha.

Oct 22, 2025, 13:41

pets9nalmyvachieved?

Oct 22, 2025, 14:03

Ha ha ha !!

Oct 22, 2025, 14:08

Yes, Beeno, we know. Tell us more...

 
You need to Log in to reply.
Back to top