Former All Blacks skipper Kieran Read has come out swinging against New Zealand Rugby (NZR) following the announcement that standout fly-half Richie Mo’unga will be sidelined for the initial fixtures of the All Blacks' tour in South Africa. Despite Mo’unga's return to New Zealand after a stint in Japan with Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo and securing an 18-month contract with NZR, he is mandated to play for Canterbury in the domestic league prior to rejoining the national team. This rule will see him miss out on what many consider the apex of rugby competition — the opening Tests against the reigning world champion Springboks.
This decision has not sat well with Read, who voiced his discontent on The Agenda podcast, criticizing the inflexibility of NZR’s policies.
“It would be a travesty if you’re running out in the first Test against South Africa and Richie Mo’unga is playing here for Canterbury. It would make no sense. It’d be ridiculous,”
Read argued. He believes that exceptional players like Mo’unga should not be withheld from playing at the highest level due to procedural formalities.
NZR's chief, Steve Lancaster, admitted that the organization deliberated internally about Mo’unga’s situation but chose not to pursue an exemption from its board. This decision has sparked debate about the consistency of NZR's selection criteria, particularly since exceptions have been made in the past. Players like Matt Todd in 2018 and more recently Georgia Ponsonby have been allowed to bypass similar restrictions.
Read suggests that the rules be adaptable to accommodate key players, especially when the team's performance could benefit significantly.
“They made the rules, so they can change the rules. Play them in the team that they deserve to be in and if the coach wants to pick them, that’s where they should be,”
Read emphasized, indicating that new All Blacks coach Dave Rennie might favor having Mo’unga available.
As the debate continues, the situation underscores the ongoing tension between maintaining traditional selection policies and adapting to the dynamic nature of modern rugby. This case not only impacts Mo’unga and the All Blacks' immediate prospects but also poses broader questions about the flexibility and fairness of rugby administration in New Zealand.
2,100 posts
Former All Blacks skipper Kieran Read has come out swinging against New Zealand Rugby (NZR) following the announcement that standout fly-half Richie Mo’unga will be sidelined for the initial fixtures of the All Blacks' tour in South Africa. Despite Mo’unga's return to New Zealand after a stint in Japan with Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo and securing an 18-month contract with NZR, he is mandated to play for Canterbury in the domestic league prior to rejoining the national team. This rule will see him miss out on what many consider the apex of rugby competition — the opening Tests against the reigning world champion Springboks.
This decision has not sat well with Read, who voiced his discontent on The Agenda podcast, criticizing the inflexibility of NZR’s policies.
“It would be a travesty if you’re running out in the first Test against South Africa and Richie Mo’unga is playing here for Canterbury. It would make no sense. It’d be ridiculous,”
Read argued. He believes that exceptional players like Mo’unga should not be withheld from playing at the highest level due to procedural formalities.NZR's chief, Steve Lancaster, admitted that the organization deliberated internally about Mo’unga’s situation but chose not to pursue an exemption from its board. This decision has sparked debate about the consistency of NZR's selection criteria, particularly since exceptions have been made in the past. Players like Matt Todd in 2018 and more recently Georgia Ponsonby have been allowed to bypass similar restrictions.
Read suggests that the rules be adaptable to accommodate key players, especially when the team's performance could benefit significantly.
“They made the rules, so they can change the rules. Play them in the team that they deserve to be in and if the coach wants to pick them, that’s where they should be,”
Read emphasized, indicating that new All Blacks coach Dave Rennie might favor having Mo’unga available.As the debate continues, the situation underscores the ongoing tension between maintaining traditional selection policies and adapting to the dynamic nature of modern rugby. This case not only impacts Mo’unga and the All Blacks' immediate prospects but also poses broader questions about the flexibility and fairness of rugby administration in New Zealand.