FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  AB and Bok rankings by NZ Herald

AB and Bok rankings by NZ Herald

Started by Just_win6 REPLIES797 VIEWS· 16 Sept 2017, 20:08
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
16 Sept 2017, 20:08
#1
16 Sept 2017, 20:08#1

Who shone and who struggled in the All Blacks' big win over the Springboks?

 

All Blacks

15. Damian McKenzie - 6

50th min wipers kick perfect to get territory and set lineout 5m from line. Still vulnerable at times under the high ball.

 

14. Nehe Milner-Skudder - 8

Slick finishing, especially his receipt of the B.Barrett backflip, the key in breaking Springbok resolve.

 

13. Ryan Crotty - 8

Effortless direction of his side's fortunes out wide. Wins Smokin' Joe Stanley prize for pristine distribution.

 

12. Sonny Bill Williams - 6

Backstage role with effective passing and defence. Has the red card from the Lions series numbed his flair?

 

11. Rieko Ioane - 8

Telepathic with A.Smith to score 1st try when he got the jump on Rhule. Human skeleton key on attack.

 

10. Beauden Barrett - 9

Audacity of 21st min Harlem Globetrotter backflip 1st on highlights reel. Unleashed full repertoire of skills.

 

9. Aaron Smith - 8

20/20 vision to set Ioane free with a chip kick in 18th min from quick tap. Enthusiastic sniping aided team momentum.

 

8. Kieran Read - 7

Quality lineout recovery in 40th min. Ran and offloaded effectively, to ensure a record score against The Old Foe.

 

7. Sam Cane - 7

Powerful in contact and breakdown grafting ensured his teammates enjoyed the spoils out wide.

 

Related articles:

SPORT | Rugby

Rieko Ioane stars in All Black masterclass

 

16 Sep, 2017 9:28pm

 4 minutes to read

SPORT | Rugby

ABs: Beauden Barrett back to his best

 

16 Sep, 2017 9:28pm

 3 minutes to read

SPORT | Rugby

ABs thrash Springboks by record margin

 

16 Sep, 2017 9:30pm

 3 minutes to read

SPORT | Rugby

Tasman hold off Otago in thriller

 

16 Sep, 2017 6:43pm

 2 minutes to read

6. Liam Squire - 8

Fearless tackling, especially try-saver on Kriel. Looked hungry, like he was ready to skin a rabbit with his teeth.

 

5. Sam Whitelock - 8

Master of the bear hug tackle and handy in lineout. Pinched a beauty with a tap off Boks' throw in 28th min

 

4. Brodie Retallick - 8

Gleeful look on chops when gifted 37th min try. Raised clenched fist in joy, before customary emotional grip resumed.

 

3. Nepo Laulala - 6

Difficult early stanzas in the scrum but provided plenty of physicality in the tight as the hosts racked up 1st half points.

 

2. Dane Coles - 7

Threw with gutterboard champion-accuracy for the most part. Produced the odd piece of finesse in broken play.

 

1. Kane Hames - 5

Let down by his scrummaging as Dreyer put him in a hyperbaric chamber of pressure. Crockett on in 43rd min.

 

Reserves

16. Codie Taylor - 7

17. Wyatt Crockett - 8

18. Ofa Tu'ungafasi - 7

19. Scott Barrett - 8

20. Ardie Savea - 6

21. TJ Perenara - 6

22. Lima Sopoaga - 7

23. Anton Lienert-Brown - 8

 

Springboks

15. Andries Coetzee - 6

Kick-chase accuracy struggled but attacking running, passing and aerial work sound in the circumstances.

 

14. Raymond Rhule - 3

Found out of position and turning like the interisland ferry in 18th min as Ioane scored. Picked off like lint in 37th.

 

13. Jesse Kriel - 6

Runs like a torpedo but had few opportunities to launch. Feisty in defence, but difficult when chasing black shadows.

 

12. Jan Serfontein - 6

Robust contribution in all facets. Abrasive, but no chance with ABs in routing mood as ball kept moving through hands.

 

11. Courtnall Skosan - 5

Earnest but dizzy chase of the B.Barrett/Milner-Skudder show. AWOL when S.Barrett skipped across.

 

10. Elton Jantjies - 5

Could not create the required opportunities. Demoralising when ABs pounced against early flow

 

9. Francois Hougaard - 6

ABs counter-attacks meant he struggled to offer astute direction. Handy passing to set up runners in channel.

 

8. Uzair Cassiem - 5

Offered brawn and bulk but fast-twitch fibres could use a rev-up to drive past gain line. Looked exhausted

 

7. Jean-Luc du Preez - 6

Hard running, but assignment became impossible against ABs' slick distribution and recycling.

 

6. Siya Kolisi - 6

Tenacious tackling. Drilled Laulala on half hour mark but laboured as black juggernaut rolled into history.

 

5. Franco Mostert - 5

Gave scrum pep but replaced early in 2nd half by de Jager as visitors looked to gain any form of impetus.

 

4. Eben Etzebeth - 6

No lack of personal commitment, but could not inspire teammates. Identifiable by furrowed brow.

 

3. Ruan Dreyer - 7

Punishing scrummager. Put Hames on the braai with a back resembling Table Mountain. Less impact versus Crockett.

 

2. Malcolm Marx - 4

Looked like he was throwing lineouts for distance rather than accuracy. Musical chair jumpers didn't help.

 

1. Tendai Mtawarira - 6

Remains a scrummaging rock and virile lineout lifter but that had little impact against hosts' speed.

 

Reserves:

16. Bongi Mbonambi - 7

17. Steven Kitshoff - 7

18. Trevor Nyakane - 7

19. Lood de Jager - 6

20. Pieter-Steph du Toit - 6

21. Francois Hougaard - N/A

22. Handre Pollard - 5

23. Damian de Allende - N/A

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
16 Sept 2017, 20:14
#2
16 Sept 2017, 20:14#2
 These ratings are a little more generous for the Boks.
McKenzie seemed better than 6 but I can live with it. Rhule was appropriately rated very low. He cost the Boks a lot as he couldn't tackle to save his life - leaked a couple of tries in the firs half.
DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
16 Sept 2017, 22:26
#3
16 Sept 2017, 22:26#3
 Kak ratings for boks.
CE
CeradynePro9,374 posts
16 Sept 2017, 22:33
#4
16 Sept 2017, 22:33#4
There are a few viewpoints that one could take from these ratings. The one is that the NZ Herald has fallen into the same trap that other scribes fell into when they rated the SA team after their wins against France and the Argies. Another one is that they had to award the SA players high ratings in order to justify the high ratings of the ABs. There may be other viewpoints as well, one of which would be the viewpoint that those ratings are indeed spot on. That would, of course, beg the question: "What the hell are the SA supporters and media complaining about?" Only problem with the latter is that it does in no way explain the 57 points that the ABs put on the Boks, nor does it explain the fact that the Boks did not manage to score a single point. Another disaster for Allister Coetzee and his merry men would be if the ABs do not manage to whitewash the Argies by a similar margin, at least once, by the end of the RC.
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
17 Sept 2017, 00:10
#5
17 Sept 2017, 00:10#5
These are embarrassing Bok ratings....Kriel feisty in defence missing nearly half of his tackles....no, nonsense.
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
20 Sept 2017, 00:21
#6
20 Sept 2017, 00:21#6
 q
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
20 Sept 2017, 00:21
#7
20 Sept 2017, 00:21#7
 q
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news