FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  AB players ratings

AB players ratings

Started by ABasquefan3 REPLIES152 VIEWS· 13 Nov 2016, 14:54
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
AB
ABasquefanPro2,549 posts
13 Nov 2016, 14:54
#1
13 Nov 2016, 14:54#1
from the different ratings published, the most accurate IMO is:

Damian McKenzie 8
Huge involvement and stepped into pivot role, without finding much clear air. Not needed in defence.

Israel Dagg 8
Played a big part in establishing the dominance as playmaker and fine angled run for try.

Malakai Fekitoa 6
Same old story. Vigorous and some big runs but lacked the nice touches and vision.

Anton Lienert-Brown 9
His deft touches a highlight of 2016. The work for Dagg try and pass to Naholo stand out.

Waisake Naholo 8
Made loads of running without a signature moment. Too good for this lot though.

Aaron Cruden 6
Strangely disappointing considering the scoreline.

Inaccurate. Only one memorable run.

Tawera Kerr-Barlow 8
He's no Perenara or Smith. but this was a good performance by most standards.

Steven Luatua 7
Still lacks that imposing power. Decent enough, but a few hiccups including pass for Italian try.

Sam Cane 8
Powerful all round game - lots of runs and short passes. Led from the front.

Elliot Dixon 7
Solid effort highlighted by the flourish in creating the Luatua try.

Scott Barrett 7
Retallick-type short passing skills particularly for Faumuina and Crockett tries. Lineout steal.

Patrick Tuipulotu 8
Got the Ireland disaster out of the system. Powerful surges and a lineout steal.

Charlie Faumuina 9
Smashing game from the human wall. Plenty of ball running and scrum dominant.

Codie Taylor 7
Energetic for sure but a couple of things went wrong and lineout misfires in second half.

Wyatt Crockett 9
Most skilful prop in test rugby? Wonderful moments including rare try and setting up Fekitoa.


Reserves

Liam Coltman (Taylor, 65m) 5
Test debut. Nothing of note.

Joe Moody (Crockett, 71m) 5
Chicago villain had uneventful cameo.

Ofa Tu'ungafasi (Faumuina, 56m) 6
Moderate - couldn't match Faumuina's impact.

Brodie Retallick (Barrett, 54m) 6
Good blowout after break but lost too much ball.

Matt Todd (Tuipulotu, 60m) 7
Excellent quarter. Made early break. Charged confidently into game, reflecting growing status.

Aaron Smith (Kerr-Barlow, 51m) 7
More like the old Smith. Confidence boost, including top break from lineout.

Lima Sopoaga (Cruden, 60m) 7
Outshone Cruden...sharp breaks lovely cross kick for Naholo. Poor chase on Boni though.

Rieko Ioane (Dagg, 51m) 7
Start of a great career, surely. Hunted for work. Fine try finish between two defenders.


NZ Herald


AB
ABasquefanPro2,549 posts
13 Nov 2016, 14:58
#2
13 Nov 2016, 14:58#2
 I would have given a 9 to israel Dagg also,.... the time he was on the field he was the playmaker of the team (Cruden was a bit absent in this sense) helped by ALB who again was outstanding and is the finding of the season

yes, Crockett is the most skilful prop in test rugby and the best ball carrier, reads the game as a backline player and no other prop runs the angles he runs
BR
BrycyPro4,671 posts
13 Nov 2016, 16:53
#3
13 Nov 2016, 16:53#3
 Funny how Sopoaga that missed the tackle of the only try scored by Italy played better than Cruden when he also missed his kick and Cruden kicked seven from seven ,,,ratings are a complete joke...was a masterclass by Cruden who makes it look so effortless the way he orchestrates the play....and he should start ahead of Barret against Ireland if we want to win..
CR
CrusadersfanPro3,099 posts
13 Nov 2016, 21:15
#4
13 Nov 2016, 21:15#4
 I am not sold on D McKenzie, I would say capable at best but if he is a long term prospect he has a way to go. I would have rated a 7 at the most and his attack never had me on the edge of my seat in anticipation especially against a very weak opposition.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news