12 Nov 2018, 12:54#1
I chose 1995 because that was when the game became professional. I have also made it a 23 instead of 15, so that some of the stalemates between players like Habana and Lomu can be avoided. Here is a taster followed by my list.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWUSKkfGdjQ
1. Os Du Rand2. Keith Wood3. Karl Hayman 4. Brodie Retallic k5. Victor Matfield6. George Smith7. Richie McCaw8. Zinzan Brooke9. Fourie Du Preez10. Dan Carter11. Jonah Lomu12. Tana Umaga13. Brian O Driscoll 14. Doug Howlett 15. Andre Joubert
16. Gethin Jenkins17. Sean Fitzpatrick18. John Eales19. Thierry Dusautoir20. Joost VD Westhuizen21. Stirling Mortlock22. Bryan Habana23. Cristian Cullen
Make your list....and lets haggle!
12 Nov 2018, 13:03#2
I have noticed after reviewing my own list that I only have one player who is currently representing his country. I'm not going to change my list now, but do bear in mind what we will say of players that are currently playing, in ten years time. Players like Reid, Etzebeth, Barrett, (Nonu), Pocock, Folau etc etc etc, would surely feature in such a conversation.
13 Nov 2018, 09:04#5
Can you imagine trying to defend against that center pairing? Especially with finishers like Lomu and Howlett outside them and Carter directing them all?
RORooinek
Captain18,117 posts
RORooinekCaptain18,117 posts
13 Nov 2018, 11:43#7
Agree,there's no right or wrong teams here . . . although I'm certain there is at least one geriatric and ignorant old fool who'll have something to say about selections he doesn't agree with . . . but here's mine:
15 Christian Cullen14 Rupeni Caucaunibuca13 Brian O'Driscoll12 Frank Bunce11 Jonah Lomu10 Dan Carter9 Joost van der Westhuizen8 Zinzan Brooke7 Andre Venter6 Richie McCaw5 John Eales4 Martin Johnson3 Phil Vickery2 Sean Fitzpatrick1 Os du Randt
16 Keith Wood17 Tony Woodcock18 Olo Brown19 Victor Matfield20 Michael Jones21 George Gregan22 Jonny Wilkinson23 Andre Joubert
Please note I only considered players whose careers are over.