29 Sept 2013, 15:49#3
I hear they will also be looking at Dr Jannie's eye gouge on Moore as well. I didn't realise he was an Opthalmologist. Maybe he was just upholding his Hypocritic oath to do no harm, although I hope he has a licence for (not so) private practise. Moore will probably be invoiced at a later date. I also wonder if Bismarck is employed to (knock out) anaesthetise his patients before he treats them in their family practise.
Hakwa as usual asking the hard questions that people think but dare not speak.
29 Sept 2013, 17:17#4
The eye gouge was way worse,he had time to think about it ,walk over ,wait for the opportunity then reach over and rake his eyes .If you get caught doing that your career should be done there and then as there is no defence or justification especially the way this was done .It disgusts me on so many levels but people still seem to think its ok or should be left on the field ,uhh no its got nothing to do with playing good hard rugby ,its just utter filth.Would like to see him interviewed and asked about it after viewing the replay and see what he says .
29 Sept 2013, 19:01#5
All off the ball issues really should be cut out. Aus also tried hard to instigate their own level as well. Flip deserves a ban. But then again we have seen pretty shoddy after game citings and dealings. MaNonu should have seen more of the inside of a citing commission room for his repeated shoulder charges, but as Hansen has pointed out, he only does it because he carries a shoulder injury. Flip Van De merwe has let the Boks down, Jannie needs a break to get his head together and maNonu needs to get that injury sorted out. poor petal !
Flashdakota
Club Pro805 posts
FlashdakotaClub Pro805 posts
29 Sept 2013, 19:08#6
Question:
What was the difference between Bismarcks elbow to the neck and Flips elbow?
Much of the same to me.... yet Bissie didn't get a red card for what he did.
29 Sept 2013, 19:22#10
It was a habit they picked up off Liam Messam.
Flashdakota
Club Pro805 posts
FlashdakotaClub Pro805 posts
29 Sept 2013, 19:51#13
Greyling's incident was a joke. That deserved in my opinion, a year or 2 out of the game with 0 pay.
Only intent there was to hurt.
He should have got a jail term for that.
Non the less.
If u keen to debate the issue regarding the other 2 , I'm all open.
Shot
Flash
Flashdakota
Club Pro805 posts
FlashdakotaClub Pro805 posts
29 Sept 2013, 20:13#15
If you look at the Boks since Heyneke Meyer took over, the only real idiot was Greyling...
ANd Meyer went public in saying that he won't tolerate crap like that. To his credit, we have never seen Greyling in the Bok squad again.
There is a real and well documented effort by Meyer, where is doing his best to clean up any off the ball nonsense.
Due to the nature of the game, there will always be some touch and go incidents, which need to be looked at and treated appropriately.
But to look at it from a neutral standpoint, there has been a big improvement of the Boks.
If you look at the SXV on the whole, I think the off the ball stuff has been pretty equal all round.
Brycy, do u live in SA or in NZ? Or somewhere else? Just asking.
Flashdakota
Club Pro805 posts
FlashdakotaClub Pro805 posts
29 Sept 2013, 20:40#17
LOL
Difficult to argue with that statement.
Now also ppears to also be home to the worst ref in RWC history.
Flashdakota
Club Pro805 posts
FlashdakotaClub Pro805 posts
29 Sept 2013, 21:31#19
Didnt know the AB's played SA in a 1976 RWC?
read previous comment closely my friend.
Regarding Watto, I'm not saying he was fabulous...
But at least he blew more hot than cold.
29 Sept 2013, 21:39#20
Why cherry pick world cups when there is so much more history between us that you choose to ignore. That's SA Blinkers Syndrome you got i think.
29 Sept 2013, 22:08#21
Just like Andrew Hore's punch on the Welsh player last year? Wow, typical hypocrisy by a Kiwi, get you heads out of your arse and realise this is a contact sport.
MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
29 Sept 2013, 22:13#22
Bismarcks elbow was a yellow, just like Flip. But because he already had a yellow it became a red....the problem was the first yellow
BEBeeno1
Captain40,032 posts
BEBeeno1Captain40,032 posts
30 Sept 2013, 00:05#23
Brycy is it a full moon in kiwi land - I am imaging ou brycy sitting on a dustbin some where and baying at the moon. The oak is on meltdown mode.Seldom has one seen such drama queens as wee mcaaw and messam. Nonu is the guy who should be banned - a serial dirty player.
30 Sept 2013, 00:09#24
Children, school is over for the day . Now run along and don't annoy the teacher.
30 Sept 2013, 00:38#25
and practise your homework
30 Sept 2013, 05:36#27
Heres one I just made up .What do you call a bunch of wallies supporters standing on XXXX hill ?A thicket !
30 Sept 2013, 06:04#31
Forget all about Nonu's shoulder charge on De Villiers at Eden park have we? Any other time and that would've been a red.
30 Sept 2013, 06:46#33
Nope ,said it many a time nonus shoulder charge was a dickhead move and deserved carding ,you guys admit nothing tho .
JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
30 Sept 2013, 09:57#34
Foul play is foul play no matter the colour of the jersey
Eye gouging has to be punished to the max. To me it is one of the worst forms of dirty play.
30 Sept 2013, 10:30#35
Well the only card I'm against is Bismark's first, Jannie should get suspended and I honestly think it would help in the short and long term as his backup is Coenie Oosthuizen, who may not be a better scrummager but can only get better and is twice the player on the park.
I don't like it when Brycy and Hakwa make out that South Africa 'have someone's ear on the IRB board' but in retrospect New Zealand are often the lucky ones that get away with a lot. I'm not saying this is the reason why we lose to you, it's not our performance on the day is the reason.
