After watching the Springboks fail yet again to negate spoil tactics it is clear that their tactics is still not up to par.
The list of matches against expected weaker teams that manage to stop us play at the breakdown is growing by the minute.
Since 2012 we have had the following matches where we had no answer to teams intent on flooding the breakdown with any tactics available to them.
The list now includes, Argentina, Wales, Scotland, Ireland and after tonight Italy.
It seems as if teams are so aware of our inability to read how various referees handle the breakdown, and our inability to adapt that their main focus is now to frustrate our clean ball, slow the match down by any means necessary and the sad fact is they are succeeding.
Here is a list of the matches and the referees involved in these matches.
Argentina vs South Africa Mendoza 2012 - Steve Walsh
South Africa vs Scotland Nelspruit 2013 - Romain Poite
Argentina vs South Africa Mendoza 2013 - Steve Walsh
South Africa vs Wales Nelspruit 2014 - Steve Walsh
Argentina vs South Africa Salta 2014 - Steve Walsh
Ireland vs South Africa Dublin 2014 - Romain Poite
Italy vs South Africa Padova 2014 - Garces.
That suggests to me that there is a pattern, now what is understandable are the two French referees, but what does not make any sense is Steve Walsh, as South African Franchises play under Steve Walsh during the Super XV.
Naas Botha said something very telling in the post match discussion tonight, South Africa does not get the ball wide enough where there are less forwards to contest the ball in the contact areas who can spoil attacking ball and slow it down.
Nick Mallet in specific was not happy with the manner in which the breakdown was officiated, neither was I, but that doesn't solve the issue as to why we cannot adapt to these spoiling tactics.
It is uncanny that teams have managed to irritate, dominate and spoil our breakdown ball especially when you consider we are supposed to be the most physical forward pack in general play in world rugby, or so I am told.
Are we truly that dense that we cannot figure out how to negate these tactics. Are we so dense that even though these teams play on the edge of the breakdown, we are the ones being penalised more often at the breakdown?
Are we that dense that we truly cannot read referees nor adapt to them?
Whatever the case may be, if Meyer and Richie Gray do not select the right players able to negate this issue, or coach our players a way to deal with this issue then we stand no chance of evolving our attacking play.
Talking of attacking play, without WIllie le Roux our attack is toothless and predictable. I fear for us when he gets injured.
The whole issue of our ineptness at the breakdown and on attack lies with our senior players not being able to adapt or run creative backline plays.
I do not know how many players we can blame for this, but it is definitely pathetic that we cannot fix this.
Watching the AUstralian back line attack tonight was an eye opener and made me realise that the only player in their backline that did not attempt an offload the whole evening was Adam Ashley Cooper, every other player managed to offload in contact.
WHat is also quite evident is that our forward runners have no support runners ready to take the offload, tonight a coupe of times our forward attempted to look for the offload but nobody was running off their shoulders in support.
Warthcing Ireland tonight was clear that they actually play the Bok gameplan of 2009, where they do not play from within their own half, they put many Gary Owens up, chase well and put Australia under enormous pressure.
The All Blacks after struggling to put Wales away in the first sixty, scored their first two tries to break the deadlock, from a chip kick and a cross kick.
South Africa has some work to do.
1. Adapt to the referee interpretations at the breakdown.
2. Adapt to what the opposition is doing at the breakdown.
3. If you can't adapt, then push the contact areas wider where there are fewer opposition forwards.
4. Our tactical attacking kicking is non existent.
5. Our midfield does not pass.
6. When their is turnover ball, get the ball wide immediately.
There are probably a number of other things, but these are major areas of concern.


