FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Critique of ABs players

Critique of ABs players

Started by hakwa11 REPLIES211 VIEWS· 13 Sept 2014, 14:02
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
HA
hakwaPro4,146 posts
13 Sept 2014, 14:02
#1
13 Sept 2014, 14:02#1

Cruden I thought had a pretty ordinary day. He missed finding touch in a long arm penality. He missed a penalty and a conversion and one of his kickoffs went out on the full.


Dagg kicked out over the dead ball line once to be brought back for a scrum. He exit kicks seemed to be very short. Was there much swirl at the stadium?


Aaron smith should have dived in afew times to rescue the scrum when it was in trouble.


Liatua was very ordinary. He let the Boks score from a set piece - sure the front Bok runners provided a screen to block out the view of the coming runner but that should be instinct by now.


Everytime one of the forwards made a break, there was no one in support - VERY STRANGE - How many penalty turnovers did we have?


Man of the match for me were Richie McCaw and Retallick

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
13 Sept 2014, 14:26
#2
13 Sept 2014, 14:26#2
ABs had an off day, even the haka did  not look convincing. Kev is too nice to lead the haka. We won a game in which we played maybe 10% below our normal standards. A win is a win. This game should revitalise the ABs. They had to deal with some injuries & still pulled together a win. Ben Smith played well, Coles was good & of course Richie and Reid. 
HA
hakwaPro4,146 posts
13 Sept 2014, 15:04
#3
13 Sept 2014, 15:04#3
 I agree with you JW - Kev is definitely too nice to lead the haka. I can see now how much work Whitlock does that is not seen - it is only when he is absent that you see it because we are so used to it being done without having to mention it
AJ
Arthur JohnPro1,748 posts
13 Sept 2014, 21:42
#4
13 Sept 2014, 21:42#4
 Read is the most underrated player in rugby.
Just wish he was a Saffer though.

RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
13 Sept 2014, 21:46
#5
13 Sept 2014, 21:46#5
"Cruden I thought had a pretty ordinary day."
Cruden I thought has had a pretty ordinary day career.

Fixed!

BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
13 Sept 2014, 22:03
#6
13 Sept 2014, 22:03#6
 "We won a game in which we played maybe 10% below our normal standards"
HAHAHHAHAHAHAHA you have to love how arrogant these oaks are.By the way JW luck is what won the game for you. Sorry to burst your bubble.The Boks were at about 70% - read the comments abo ut various Bok players

AB
ABasquefanPro2,549 posts
13 Sept 2014, 22:08
#7
13 Sept 2014, 22:08#7
 @hakwa,

"I can see now how much work Whitlock does that is not seen - it is only when he is absent that you see it"

you spot on, mate.
Whitelock has been sorely missed even when Thrush has made a correct job. But Whitelock is in another level, where only Retallick and Etzebeth (not since returned from injury) could match him.
His lineouts' guidance and wokload all over the park has no possible replacement.

When is his return expected?
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
13 Sept 2014, 22:38
#8
13 Sept 2014, 22:38#8
Beeno: ABs went out of there way to re-motivate the Boks & this is the appreciation we get ? Aren't you all feeling better now? 
MO
moolaaPro2,380 posts
14 Sept 2014, 00:46
#9
14 Sept 2014, 00:46#9
Luatua not in the same class as Messam or Kaino. Even with so many 1st team regulars out, this ABs team still finds a way to win. Psychologically destroying for Meyer and his team. 
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
14 Sept 2014, 00:51
#10
14 Sept 2014, 00:51#10
Whitelock & Messam were projected to be back in time for the dead rubber Bledisloe cup test on October 18.
AB
ABasquefanPro2,549 posts
14 Sept 2014, 01:30
#11
14 Sept 2014, 01:30#11
 thanks, JW
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
14 Sept 2014, 06:14
#12
14 Sept 2014, 06:14#12
BP I think the SANZAR site has a section on injuries .And too true about Whitelock he was the main injury worry for me ,Kaino Messam needed to enforce things a wee bit eh ?
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news