FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Damian McKenzie is New Zealand's best version of Beauden Barrett; by PAUL CULLY

Damian McKenzie is New Zealand's best version of Beauden Barrett; by PAUL CULLY

Started by Just_win6 REPLIES1,010 VIEWS· 01 Apr 2018, 00:27
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
01 Apr 2018, 00:27
#1
01 Apr 2018, 00:27#1

OPINION: In the 30th minute of the Hurricanes-Highlanders game Beauden Barrett got himself in the exact position the Rebels will want him on Friday night - running laterally, his whole body turned to face the sideline.

 

It's an old issue with the playmaker. If he's not taking on the defence square he's not as much of a threat as he could be.

 

And so it proved. Under pressure from Lima Sopoaga he hurled a pass to no-one and was forced to kick on the next phase. Then when he collected Tevita Li's clearance he tried to make a break but was bundled into touch in possession.

 

Beauden Barrett has mixed moments of individual brilliance with some ordinary play in 2018.

 

It isn't quite happening for Barrett this year as it didn't in 2017.

 

It is more than just a casual observation - take a look at the statistics.

 

There is a plethora of stats providers but they all paint a similar picture, especially when you go a bit deeper.

 

According to Fox Sports, Barrett has carried the ball 22 times for a total of 198 metres.

Damian McKenzie is starting to put others into gaps as well as torment defenders with his pace.

 

By way of comparison, Chiefs No 10 Damian McKenzie has 31 carries and 312m.

 

That's similar, but where it gets interesting is in line breaks, line-break assists and tackle busts.

 

Barrett has one line break, two line-break assists and seven tackle busts.

 

 

McKenzie has four line breaks, eight line-break assists and 19 tackle busts.

 

McKenzie has played slightly more minutes, and two 60-70 minutes stints at No 15, but even with that in mitigation I would even challenge Wellingtonians to argue that Barrett has been the more influential.

 

Instead, it is McKenzie who is currently New Zealand's best version of Barrett - that pacey, dangerous No 10 who can spark things from backfield but, crucially, can also set others up from the playmaker position. 

 

Richie Mo'unga is still the pick of classic No 10s in New Zealand. He can 'fix' defenders with his hands and eyes and then beat them with his feet like no other in the country. It was mesmerising to see him toy with South African sevens specialist Seabelo Senatla against the Stormers in Christchurch, creating the room for Codie Taylor to score the try.

 

But McKenzie's conversion to No 10 has been good. In fact, if he were a golfer he would be nicely under par on the front nine.

 

His progress has been easy to chart but Barrett remains more enigmatic.

 

I still love watching him. In 2016 he managed something remarkable: he was simultaneously the world's best No 10 and No 15. But I fear today he is neither.

 

Magnificently, probably without due credit, he has turned his goalkicking around. And perhaps I am out of step with the times and just need to love a No 10 who can pick a ball off his feet and run 50m to score.

 

But a part of me says that is not part of the core game I want Barrett to excel in.

 

I would like to see a string of games that say, 'yes 2016 might not be repeated but I have progressed my game in other ways'.

 

That is not yet apparent: reservations still linger over his passing and ability to operate when space gets tighter. 

 

Barrett will get an examination against the Rebels on Friday night. They will try to rush Barrett just as they overwhelmed the Brumbies with line speed in round four, and just as the Highlanders will try to pressure McKenzie in Hamilton in the earlier Friday game.

 

It is an evening set up for Barrett to show that he is the dominant No 10 in New Zealand, the undisputed champ. Roll on Friday, then.

 

To enter, simply join the Rugby Stuff Facebook group, or head to the page if you're already a member. In the comments field of the giveaway post pick the score for the Hurricanes v Rebels match this Friday night.

 

The closest score prediction will win the prize. Entry cut-off is 9.40pm on Friday.

 

 - Stuff


JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
01 Apr 2018, 00:32
#2
01 Apr 2018, 00:32#2

A ridiculous article in that Barrett is by far the better 10 even if he hits some performance lulls during super rugby. What is interesting is that McKenzie is seen to be doing pretty well, to me he is still finding his feet at 10.


Also interesting is how well Richie Moúnga is perceived. If McKenzie and Moúnga continue to develop NZ will be in good shape at 10 at the national level. 

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
01 Apr 2018, 02:25
#3
01 Apr 2018, 02:25#3
Mckenzie didn't look that great on Friday....two kick charge downs, poor kicks up the middle......tenuous controlof the game. But he is a great runner. Trouble is Barrett and Ben Smith are still better specialists at 10 and 15.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
01 Apr 2018, 03:43
#4
01 Apr 2018, 03:43#4

The above article can at best be described as Mozartian usage of distorted presentation and usage of stats – in other words utter BS.

I was not impressed  by McKenzie’s  performance at flyhalf - he may be  a flyhalf in the Jantjies mode and judged against Jantjies he is top class, but so is a dozen other flyhalfs.   There is no way he can be regarded as better than or on par with Barrett    


BR
BrycyPro4,671 posts
01 Apr 2018, 06:19
#5
01 Apr 2018, 06:19#5

...pointless really saying this player is better than that player when they all have their own unique skill sets...although McKenzie did get one up over Barret last year if i remember rightly when the Chiefs beat the Canes twice...

..very hard to deny the infectious positive go forward energy that McKenzie brings with his game though but he's still young and so you'll get a few rookie mistakes...

..but i think some BBarret /Canes fans and Richie Mo'unga /Crusty fans feel a bit threatened and can get very defensive when people start speaking effusively of McKenzie...hence a lot of derogatory comments in the NZ columns whenever DMac's name is mentioned...

3K
3ku1Pro2,580 posts
01 Apr 2018, 09:26
#6
01 Apr 2018, 09:26#6

The article is stupid anyway. He wrote it before Friday nights game. And Barrett was outstanding. i thought he was better then Damian. Damian was more hot and cold. Just not consistent enough for me atm. Chiefs beat canes twice last year. But Damian was at fullback then. Barrett is the best flyhalf in world rugby. 

BR
BrycyPro4,671 posts
01 Apr 2018, 09:45
#7
01 Apr 2018, 09:45#7

...3ku i think Cruden was injured last year so DMac may have been the 10 in the second half anyway when we played the Canes in Wellington ...

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news