FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Did players Meyer got on Board during and since the EOUT really strengthened the Springboks.

Did players Meyer got on Board during and since the EOUT really strengthened the Springboks.

Started by clevermike3 REPLIES105 VIEWS· 10 Sept 2014, 01:08
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
10 Sept 2014, 01:08
#1
10 Sept 2014, 01:08#1

Meyer had a few hangers-on who has lost steam - but on the whole the team was performing fairly well.   However in the case of the EOYT he brought in Bakkies Botha and Jacque Fourie from outside the then squad.   Since them his latest addition has been Victor Matfield.


Elsewhere I looked at the reuslts last year and the comparative results this year.   There has been a marked degree of poorer performances this year compared to last year.


Lets be quie frank the so-called senior players have not made nay ifference whatsoever, matter of fact the impression gained is they have weakened the team structure.


Plays like rolling mauls went out of the window with players like Bakkies and Matfield in the mix.  Fouri proved to be a good defender - when and itf his slow sppeed allows him to get atthe player - but was useless in attacking play.   


In essence some of the hangers-on has also lost steam.   This was particularly notuiceable in the over 30 players and was particularly strong in some players - who lost their perofrmance qqualities.   Even De Villiers this year was markedly poorer in performance than he was last year.


Of the hangers on - three players performed particularly poorly - namely Morne  Steyn, Ruan Pienaar and Gurthro  Steenkamp.    Can they at their age recover their mojo - very, very unlikely.   Morne always was an iffy flyhalf - but since his move to  France he has been disgstingly poor.   Gurthro seems to eb out of contention afte a bad series of failures.   Ruan Pienaar has lost it completely and is slower with a poorer service than he used to have.   


I would not have any problems if players like Matfield and Bakkies Botha made a difference to team performance - but the performances this year is with one exception markedly poorer than it used to eb last year. 


Incidentally - the one exception is the test against the Sctots - where none of the oldies made a serious contribution to the team.


So what can we expect from the so-called golden oldies?  It has been proven that we will go bakwards with them in contention.  



FO
ForeverArizonaClub Pro580 posts
10 Sept 2014, 01:21
#2
10 Sept 2014, 01:21#2
I would have liked to see a lot more experimentation in the EOYT's but Meyer is more concerned about his winning percentage then development(as it looks).But the thing is he is to inconsistent with his selections and the troughs off the momentum.JW had JDV and J Fourie as a midfield combo.We have had how many with Meyer???Not in any position other then Willie's is there consistency.Every other week its a new wing or centre pairing or flyhalf.Or a lock combination.There is a serious dynamics problem in this team and the setup.I don't see them winning much in the near future.No to be pessimistic.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
10 Sept 2014, 02:06
#3
10 Sept 2014, 02:06#3
 FA
I agree with you here - instead of consistency we see a constant changing of the guard - new players get one or two chances and is then changed again.  You cannot properly assess players with only one or two games to show whether they belong.   
The players Meyer plays consistently in some cases flop badly and there is nothing done about those.  My problem is with players like our half  back pair and our locks.  They disappoint week after week and nothing is done about them. 
Under the circumstanes the constant changes in some positions contribute to erratic team performances - but others are just past their age of optimumm performance and there are too many of those should have ben replaced or never have been in the squad in the first instance. 
FO
ForeverArizonaClub Pro580 posts
10 Sept 2014, 02:27
#4
10 Sept 2014, 02:27#4
His biggest problem is his erratic selections.... Poor selection choice coupled with inconsistency gives us the bad rugby we see played by the Boks.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news