But still 10 x behind Mallet and White.
White, first year in charged won the tri-nations. Team took a dip in the 3rd year leading up to the World Cup, but made the fatal mistake following Tim Noakes advice on giving players extended rest, which meant the likes of Du Preez, Matfield etc were left behind. Outcome, boks won the World Cup convincingly, however, for his trouble got booted. That very same team with a rubbish coached managed to claim the lions series and beat the All Blacks 3 times in one year. When White left SA rugby it was in a better state. De Villiers did the complete Opposite.
Mallet, early days of professional rugby, but went on a 17 run winning streak, played amazing attacking rugby and probably one of the greatest in between World Cup team. Made the mistake to pick Bobby Skinstad over Teichman. Got booted for making comments about ticket prices.
Meyer started off well, but started to flirt with expansive rugby, I did criticise him, but we were really competitive but after the De Villiers era. De Villiers didn't bring any young players through. Probably the main reason why Frans Steyn packed his bags. All Meyer had was to work with his old Bulls Stars and try to bring through younger talent like Pollard and Kriel. He fielded a mix of very old and very young players. His only sin was that he pre determined who would play when and for how long. Became too robotic and predictable. Unfortunately the writing was on the wall when we lost to Argentina for the first time at home and then the WC Japan disaster when he took 5 injured players to the World Cup who weren't really fit. He tried to bring back Jacques Fourie and Fourie Du Preez barely made it. Not to mention Oupa Matfield.
Coetzee, don't even get me started with him. But we have had a lot of bad coaches and a couple of good ones.
I think Jake White percentage win ratio would be higher had he not brought in younger players and risked certain games for experience in view of the World Cup. He nearly lost his job, got flown out to SA in a middle of a tour to explain to the board why he wasn't winning. But look at the quality players that came from him. I don't like his media presence, he is not perfect but can he spot and develop talent. I'm really happy he is staying for another 5 years at the bulls. Just hope that he doesn't chase the next international contract and keep bringing talent through in SA. Good for us.
As for Rassie, brilliant tactician, not strategist. Knows how to tweak struggling teams to deliver. But, he has never stayed in a position for more than 2 years before moving on. Maybe at the Stormers as Director of Rugby. Same can be said for the boks, 2 years in the top job and then just give the reigns to the Physio. Not a smart move.
Hell, I would even opt for Deon Davids over the Physio. At least Davids won some games in Super Rugby with the Queens and a very poor player base. That said, he had the likes of Am and Mpimpi as very young players. So who knows, maybe Davids could be our next coach.
But that said, being a national coach requires so much more than just between those 4 lines.
I think if we could bring a brain trust together of Mallet, Swys, White and Rassie we would be unstoppable. But our coaches have big egos and don't work well with others. Even the Physio as defensive coach, can't believe I say this by Neill Powel / Stick for break down skills we would be bloody awesome.