Who are your favourite rugby players?
Favourite rugby players
Bismarck
Jacques Engelbrecht,
Etzebeth
Anscombe
Mike Phillips
My favourites based on real performance are -
Habana, Le Roux, De Villiers, Etzebeth, Bismarck/Strauss and Labuschagne - the latter statistically and factually proven to be by far the best loosie in Super 15 this year of all competing teams.
All Blacks : Carter, Ben Smith, Cane
British Lions : Halfpenny
Current
Etzebeth
Habana
JDV
Dagg
Read
Nonu
Past
Lomu
Michael Jones
Francois pienaar
James Small
Cullen
Andre Joubert
John Eales
Willie o
Siya Kolisi
Jebb Sinclair
Habana
DTH Van de Merwe
Jeff Hassler
NZ
all the All Blacks, but especially McCaw and brodie retallick,
ardie savea, sam christie, marty banks.
SA
vermeulen, lady elizabeth, deon fourie, lappies labuschange, jj englebrechett
england
chris robshaw, manusamoa tulagi, geoff parling
ireland
sean obrien, jonathan sexton
wales
toby faletau, jamie roberts, george north, leigh halfpenny
scotland
stuart hogg, sean maitland
italy
sergio parisse
france
thierry dussatoir
australia
israel folau
argentina
ole cruz, juan lobbe
Sasue
Come now - are you favouring Tomas - beca use he signed a contract with the Chiefs?
Mine . . .
SABismarck du Plessis, Beast Mtawarira, Jean Deysel, Jaco Kriel, Jacques Engelbrecht, Patrick Lambie, Jan Serfontein, JP Pietersen, Gio Aplon.
NZKieran Read, Aaron Smith, Rene Ranger, Ben Smith, Charles Piutau.
AusKyle Godwin, Israel Folau.
ArgentinaJuan Figallo, Tomas Lavanini, Juan Manuel Leguizamon, Juan Martin Hernandez.
Wales
Gethin Jenkons, Sam Warburton, Mike Phillips, Jamie Roberts, George North, Leigh Halfpenny.
EnglandTom Croft, Owen Farrell, Manu Tuilagi, Ben Foden.
FranceNicolas Mas, Louis Picamoles, Wesley Fofana.
ScotlandEuan Murray, Richie Gray, Rory Lamont.
IrelandSean O'Brien
ItalySergio Parisse
All time favouritesHenry Honiball, Andre Venter, Craig Davidson, Andre Joubert, Jan Ellis, Tommy Bedford, Hennie Muller, Danie Craven, Christian Cullen, Frank Bunce, Ian Kirkpatrick, Sean Fitzpatrick, Colin Meads, Tim Horan, Hugo Porta, Gareth Edwards, Barry John, JPR Williams, Fran Cotton, Serge Blanco, Patrice Lagisquet, Fergus Slattery, Rupeni Caucaunibuca.
Rooi
Amongst your all-time favourites - not also Hugo Porta - definitely one of mine.
Dagg, Savea, Read, Carter, Retalick, Ranger
Cooper, Beale, O'Connor, Faloua
Foden, Croft, Tuilagi, Youngs
Picamoles, Rougerie
North, Davies, Cuthbert
Gray
Lobber, Bosch
Parisse
I considered Michael Jones as well as other great AB loosies like Graeme Mourie, Kevin Eveleigh and Josh Kronfeld. They're all great players but not among my personal favourites. If I was going to include them in a list of all-time greats I'd have to add the likes of Jan Boland Coetzee, Jean Pierre Rives and Rob Louw. I've just remembered Jan Ellis! He's one of the all-time greats I'd include who is also one of my favourites. I'm editing him in along with Meads.
Francois Hougaard would have made my list before the Oscar Pistorius murder but he lost the plot after that and just doesn' t look the same player.
Agreed on JP, we need him back playing for the Boks......I thought his contract allowed him to play at some point?
Yes how can one leave out Danie Gerber...perhaps outside Frank Bunce the greatest ever.
Favourite today are Israel Dagg, Bryan Habana, Jean De Villiers, Patrick Lambie, Willie Le Roux, Eben Etzebeth, Ritchie Mc Caw, Dan Carter, Bismarck Du Plessis, Beast, Halfpenny, Thierry Dusatoir, Read, Rory Kockott, Mamuka Gorgodze (Montepellier/Georgia) and Parrisse.
Past is Philippe Sella, Andre Joubert, Serge Blanco, Gavin Hastings, Danie Gerber, Keith Oxlee, Tommy Bedford, Frik Du Preez, Joost Van Der Westhuizen, Henry Honiball, Thierry Le Croix, Mighty Mouse Mc Laughlin, JPR Williams, Hugo Porta, Gareth Edwards, Gordon Brown, John Eales, Campo, Georgie Gregan, Morne Du Plessis, Boland Coetzee, Rob Louw,Os Du Randt, Wilson Whineray, Sean Fitzpatrick, Uli Schmidt, Colin Meads, Don Clarke, Frank Bunce, Zin zan Brooke, Christian Cullen, Jeff Wilson and Rokocoko.
Yes how can one leave out Danie Gerber...perhaps outside Frank Bunce the greatest ever.
Favourite today are Israel Dagg, Bryan Habana, Jean De Villiers, Patrick Lambie, Willie Le Roux, Eben Etzebeth, Ritchie Mc Caw, Dan Carter, Bismarck Du Plessis, Beast, Halfpenny, Thierry Dusatoir, Read, Rory Kockott, Mamuka Gorgodze (Montepellier/Georgia) and Parrisse.
Past is Philippe Sella, Andre Joubert, Serge Blanco, Gavin Hastings, Danie Gerber, Keith Oxlee, Tommy Bedford, Frik Du Preez, Joost Van Der Westhuizen, Henry Honiball, Thierry Le Croix, Mighty Mouse Mc Laughlin, JPR Williams, Hugo Porta, Gareth Edwards, Gordon Brown, John Eales, Campo, Georgie Gregan, Morne Du Plessis, Boland Coetzee, Rob Louw,Os Du Randt, Wilson Whineray, Sean Fitzpatrick, Uli Schmidt, Colin Meads, Don Clarke, Frank Bunce, Zin zan Brooke, Christian Cullen, Jeff Wilson and Rokocoko.
These are just players that flash through the grey matter...a good and interesting post by my colleagues...one thing I really love about rugby (or any other sport for that matter) is to dig up the archives...provided we do not suffer from altzhiemers (sic) it's a rather lovely past...I know it is a sentimentalist subject, but like me and so many others like Ol' Maaik (and so is Mozzie) but rugby archives are interesting today....I always loved rugby...never really good at it but I was priviledged to go to school in my youth that bred great rugby players ( 2 WC winning Flyhalfs) and played rugby at the same school amongst those who became exceptional. I humbly say, what a priviledge...a school that tutored nice people and good citizens...taught us that vanity and pride is a useless pursuit in life unless it has unselfish motives...based on comradeship of the strife...the Boer War...we had boys at this school that were Dutch and English and were friends wayback in the start of 1900...because of political differences their lives were torn apart...the English against the Boers.
When they left to do their duty they agreed to identify each other by wearing a red band around their clothing or uniform...simply because a college boy does not shoot another...makes a mockery of war doesn't it??
Sorry off topic...but it's amazing how one's mind drifts sometimes.
Rooinek
Going back a bit - I think you left out Jannie Engelbrecht. He was regarded at the time as the greatest wing ever - and in the tour to New Zealand he was so good that a Maori family named a son after him. When he was Springbok Manager on a visit to New Zealand he spent some time with the family.
I saw him scoring two tries with a broken collar bone in a CC final in Pretoria that decided the match in favour of the WP.
Tim Horan, Larkham, Lomu, Zinzane, Cullen, Jeff Wilson, Kirwin, Marshall, Dawson, Wilkinson, O'Driscoll, Keith Wood, Nordiquay and a host of others


