Final verdict on the Currie Cup
I think we need to make a distinction here. A more adventurous attacking game by the South African sides would not be the same as their New Zealand counterparts. The game is approached much differently in New Zealand. The Mitre 10 is more useful for them than the Currie Cup is to us as a stepping stone to Super Rugby.
This was a good Curry Cup final.
I was there in 97, had a drink with Gary Pagel and Dirk Hanekom in the Players Pub ahead of the match. They just returned from injuries and played much earlier for one of the lower tier teams.
Free State very nearly won that match.
My advice, if you're not enjoying the Currie Cup , find another sport to watch . . . except in Moffie's case, we're running out of sports he knows anything about. Maybe rhythmic gymnastics or ping pong?
if you're not enjoying the Currie Cuo
Crash goes the spell check fiend rooitwitterBUG. Hahahahahahahahaha it was inevitable!
Cant comment as i have no t as yet watched the final which i taped.
Face facts rooitwit specializes in shooting himself in both hooves!
Beenz, a Donkey is a noble steed.
Draad a donkey is fine but a jackass is not!. Ou rooitwvtterbug is a jackass of the two legged version!
Must say one will seldom encounter a finer unintended comic than rooitwit.
I think we are talking about a Satyr now.
Are you and the other Currie Cup bashers suggesting we do away with our domestic competition completely and rather focus on Super Rugby? Would you prefer the CC to be replaced by the Super Rugby conference?
Personally I think Super Rugby has become boring since they completely screwed up the format with these conferences and people can argue back and forth about the quality of the rugby, but whether the quality of players is better or worse, I enjoyed watching a lot of exciting Currie Cup games this year more than I enjoyed watching the majority of Super Rugby games.
I do agree that maybe the Currie Cup should use smaller stadiums and I like the idea that the Lions had a few season ago where they play their Currie Cup games at various club venues (like Pirates, UJ, Roodepoort etc.) but I wouldn't consider scrapping the Currie Cup. We still need some kind of bridge between school/club rugby and test rugby . . . unless you think going from school or club straight into international competitions like Super Rugby or test rugby is a good idea?
As for the supposed low quality of the Currie Cup, well, it makes no claims to being test quality and if watching the top end of rugby is all that's important to you then go ahead and boycott the CC or campaign for it to be scrapped. Me, I'm the kind of person who watches club and school rugby whenever I get the chance so the Currie Cup is already of a very high quality as far as I'm concerned and I find it very enjoyable to watch.
Long story short, the problem with the Currie Cup, is the ridiculously long Super Rugby season.
We need to either embrace this Super Rugby conference format and effectively turn our conference into our Currie Cup where we are represented by our existing CC franchises (with a promotion/relegation scenario as well as a draft system) or else we need to cut back on Super Rugby, enter fewer teams that are an amalgamation of our existing CC franchises and make sure it ends before the June internationals.
Nope Rooi
We simnply need to do away with SR and play in NH competitions.
Better money, new oppositon, less player drain, keeps NH based payers in the mix for selection and will be much easier to watch form a time of day perspective.
And also...this is a big one...no competitions decided by jet lag! Players need one rest day after travel and are good to go.
Jsut generally playing against a larger mix of countries will be much nicer. Currently it's crap Oz teams and godly Kiwi teams. Hardly any games are tough to call.
From a fans perspective, for me, playing in the NH leagues ticks a lot of positive boxes.
Not great for Aussies and Kiwis admittedly, but for us South Africans it's pretty close to perfect.
Yeah, it's odd.
But if that's the only downside then i'll take it. The season now ends in Novemeber and kicks off again in Feb...so it's not such a huge adjustment anyway.
Temperatures, now that i think of it...going from one weekend in frosty Europe to a highveld summer game, will probably replace jet lag as being a concerning external factor that might influence games.
I'm not adverse to seeing a three minute water break halfway through each half either.
Still, not difficult to beat travelling halfway laterally around the world for a game.
Any other cons you can think of?
"Just to add, Plum, I don't have any problem with the time of day of Super Rugby games. It's actually one of the big attractions . . . waking up on a Saturday morning and having wall to wall rugby games starting around 8 or 9am right through to 7pm.
Not great for Aussies and Kiwis admittedly, but for us South Africans it's pretty close to perfect."
I'm still young enough for 10am to be an early call on a Saturday
Your "time of day" pro is actually a big con for me.
Yes, I do have some other cons but the summer/winter thing is the biggie for me. It's a fundamental flaw in your proposal and I can't really get past it.
I also think your jet-lag issue is blown out of proportion. I've flown south to north and south again as well as west to east and west return and they're equally tiring. I know east-west you lose or gain more hours but you should be able to adjust your sleep patterns beforehand.
Finally, as a self-respecting South African rugby supporter, as much as I like to beat English, French and Irish teams, it's the Kiwi teams I want to beat more than anyone else. No getting away from that.
Fair points.
There's also the DSTV vs Sky aspect of this.
Right now, rugby is keeping DSTV going.
Not sure if you know, but for one season of an origianl series, DSTV or Mnet spend in the region of R350 to R550 million. That's for one series of some shitty show.
What they spend on rugby for what they get in return is a cash cow if ever there was one. Both in revenue and in minutes/hours of entertainment it's a winner all the way.
are you little chaps claiming you've won this argument because I typed "cuo" instead of "cup"?
Yes rooitwi t of course i have won the argument because i warned you many times that your spell check fiend activities would come back to bite you when you made a mistake and they did. Bwahahahahahahahahhaahha - its like taking candy from a baby!
Finally, as a self-respecting South African rugby supporter, as much as I like to beat English, French and Irish teams, it's the Kiwi teams I want to beat more than anyone else. No getting away from that.
Somebody has hacked rooitwi ts account!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


