Whether you like it or not, the 2014 Super Rugby season, in particular, has been one ruled by referees – and they will again play their role in the competition semi-finals.
The on-field officiating duties have been bifurcated between Glen Jackson and Jaco Peyper respectively, both seasoned officials with very different styles and judicial approaches to the game. Consequently, as much as the four sides competing on the weekend will have to play their opponent, they will also have to play the referee.
This is most significant for game two under the guidance of Peyper. The Waratahs and Brumbies will have to be clinical at the breakdown and, in particular, the set piece. Peyper has averaged 19 scrum resets per game this season – and appears content to award penalties and resets alike.
This could be significant in the latter stages of the game as clock management becomes an issue.
The South African-born referee is also noted as a frequent ‘momentum shifter’ – and does use his regulatory power to alter a game’s dynamic from one side to another. Such refereeing intervention prompted Lions’ head coach Johan Ackermann to ask for clarity on certain questionable calls during the side’s loss to the Sharks in Durban.
Wallabies fans may also remember a ‘no try’ call and Ma’a Nonu shoulder charge that went unpunished in the sides 15th consecutive loss to the All Blacks. Waratahs supporters who follow referees closely may be nervous after hearing that Peyper has been appointed to officiate the second semi-final – the side has an unfavourable record with him on the field.
Moreover, with noted whistle-blower Craig Joubert acting as assistant referee, the officiating body could materially influence the all-Australian semi-final.
Conversely, Glen Jackson, a Saracens centurion and Barbarian, who will be refereeing the Crusaders vs. Sharks game is widely regarded to favour the attacking side, in doing so, erring on the side of positive rugby.
This will benefit contrasting aspects for both sides. After the Sharks set-piece annihilation of the Highlanders the Sharks will favour their scrum and will look to be afforded concession on the basis of positive, attacking set piece play. If they play to their game, this could be worth quite a bit if the Crusaders concede penalties in their 45 metre zone.
Contrastingly, the Crusaders backs will benefit from the attacking game the Jackson likes to govern. Ultimately, as Jackson is less inclined to throw his weight around the opening semi-final in New Zealand should be dictated by the players, rather than the men in pink.
The Super Rugby finals thus far have been an incredible spectacle – hopefully, that form continues.
