FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Is South African improving at last?

Is South African improving at last?

Started by clevermike2 REPLIES403 VIEWS· 07 May 2018, 22:43
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
07 May 2018, 22:43
#1
07 May 2018, 22:43#1

For many years I  supported the Springbok team and our Super Rugby Franchise, I hated to see how the teams managed to slaughter the game of rugby.   The whole process basically worked as follows:-

*     I hated to see the forwards battling bravely and when they manaaged to get the ball back it was handed back to the opposing team by aimless and inaccurate kicking .   For me it seemed that our players hated it to have ball possession.

*      We had coaches who claimed that SA backline players were incompetent in ball skills and could not  be used as backline attacking  and even coaches  who was totally ignorant as to backline coaching     In essence they believed in 10- man rugby and showed no real interest in development of backline players other than in defense.

*     Although it was frequently mentioned to the contrary, the coaches had no game plans which were  consistently applied.    

*     Since 2008 the coaches did not believe in team renewal  and in essence that attitude persisted until 2015 when the bottom fell out.    Those experienced players could  in the main  not adjust their limited ball skills and become   better players.

*      To hide their personal incompetence coaches spread the runour that they want SA teans to play “traditional  SA Rugby” and this was taken up by some of their supporters,   But what is traditional SA Rugby?   It did not exist prior to 1990 and became a “caichword” since then.   What it really meant was a predictable case of kicking and playing 10-man rugby,         

Changes made by some coaches

The first signs that things were changing was when the Sharks in 2012  started playing more comprehensive rugby and they ended up as one of the top 6 teams in Super Rugby.    Getting into the play-offs  of the Super Rugby series,    The idea was to use the backline as an attacking means  and in the play-offs they beat the Reds  comprehensively  in  Brisbane and then had to travel back to Cape Town to play and beat the Stormers ibn Caoe Town and then off to Waikato to play the Chiefs in the finals where they lost thegame.  

Being used to the rubbish dished up the public was surprised  when in 2013 the Cheetahs  changed course and suddenly started  beating teams  left right and center.  They were playing with thir limited resources in manpower - yet they beat or drew with teams like the Highlanders and  Crusaders.    The Cheetahs backline that year scored  more tries than the whole teams of other SA franchises did,   Fact is that year the Cheetahs backline scored more tries than the backlines of other SA Super Rugby franchises combined.     The idea was to use the loosies and even other forwards  to assist the backline in attacking by means of the ball-in-hand  play.

The third team that really expanded on the initial steps of the Sharks and the Free State  was the Lions and the whole process  paid  off for them in 2016 and 2017 when the reach the finals of he Super Series.

The problem was that Meyer because of ignorance did not like what the Lions produced and  in the end he would not select any Lions players – at that stage the top team in SA  - for the  2015 WC Squad    However to blame him alone is not realistic - he realized that it would be impossible to get the senior players to be able to be part of such a form of rugby.  

What happened  on  Saturday

The mess  got worse in 2017 and 2018 and it looked  as if things were getting worse instead of improving

  So it was an eye-opener for me and perhaps thousands  of others –to see how three teams on Saturday three SA teams playing a brand of rugby that was unthinkable  as little as three years ago.

The Lions who was the leaders of the new brand of rugby fir years had a failure on Saturday in t he relevant regard.    The lapse is hopefully not replicated in future.   

It gave me a strong believe that rugby in SA is improving at last





sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,255 posts
08 May 2018, 02:22
#2
08 May 2018, 02:22#2
There has certainly been some improvement. The dolts like Alister Coetzee and Noel Marias- have been dumped, so some improvement was certain.

The Sharks vs Stormers match this weekend was good rugby. Best match between 2 SA sides for a while. 
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
08 May 2018, 05:46
#3
08 May 2018, 05:46#3

SB

The example of the Sharks was the case where the Sharks in 2014 under White lost the Round Robin game against the Highlanders 30-15 and this time they beat the same team 38-12.  That game was butchered by Frans Steyn who kicked the ball back straight to the Highlanders even in the case of possession turnover by the forwards.   It was unbelievable BS by both the coach and the half-backs.

Don't leave out Meyer - he was a total incompetent when it came to playing comprehensive rugby /   

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news