JP off to Japan
Not ideal but better than loosing JP entirely. Why cant they do something similar re Bekker then?
Beeno
It is a pity Pietersen is going - and I wish him all the best.
However, I am not happy to see him playing in the relative minor June tests and then have to play rookies or near rookies in the Championship tests. I would rather that they forgt about Pietersen inthe June tests and get the possible Championship contenders on the Park. in June.
We have seen players going to France and coming back in rather poor physical condition and also getting injured more easily since the dietary and training regimes are less strenuous in the countries they go to. The end up coming back - like Grant - gets injured and cannot play for long periods.
For that reason I think it wise not to select players playing overseas and the only players so selected must really be absolutely crucial and not detrimental to local players performances.
Big loss - but unfortunately due to huge financial offers made to players and the exchange rate. Howevr, their selection for SA teams should certainly be handled with great care and limited to the most essential cases only..
I would pick them. Du Toit is calling the lineouts fo rthe sharks and getting some experience there.
we could have a very different tight five.
How about this for a possible WC side.
Coenie, Strauss (capt), Malherbe, Etzebeth and Du Toit. This is a young tight five with huge promise.
Loosies, Vermuelen, Louw and Elstadt/Labbers
Reinach, Goosen/Lmabie,
Serfontein, JJ,
JP, Van der Heever and a recovered Frans or Willie Le roux.
Resrves - Kitshoff, Bissie (He could start) Bekker, Arno Botha
Groom, Lambie, Allende Taute
What is great is that you could play that side right now. Give them a couple of years together, manage them carefully re workload, get in a decent backline coach and they should win the 2015 WC.
I get the feeling we could peak at the right time Bok be? Can we do the right things, make the right decisions now and build on a solid foundation. Meyer I am trusting is a builder. Bit conservative but tends over time to get it right. Here is hoping!
yet another bok great leaves our shores. the madness will only leave us with no depth come the RWC. as we have seen with kanko the jap league is not up the high standards and players conditioning is not priorty.
@beeno meyers one eyed views has cost him in the past and from what i have seen at the training run one can expect the same old crud that we have seen last year. his reckless selection policies and loyalitys for overseas based players like pienaar and louw has caused this massive exodus in my view. he has set the standard and we are suffering for it.
we do have talent but that means nothing if that talent is not retained in your local systems. the rate we are going at our unions will be constantly be building and will never have a mature team.
on your team list i like the names but the likes of van der heever, kitshoff, allende, has done nothing to warant selection so maybe your WP blinkers are on again :P
selectiing young forwards has never been a problem but the backkline is the cancer that we need to treat in the country. ball recycling speed of the forwards, breakdown skillsets and off the ball running and decision making should be the biggest priorty for meyer.
There was a massive exodus long before Meyer selected Pienaar and Francois Louw.
not ot the extend that we are seeing right now let be honest !!!
the age of the players are younger. the likes of bakkies and co was already at there end of the careers but one cannot have this current situation.


