PAPakie
Captain17,321 posts
17 Aug 2014, 21:29#2
Didn't you discuss all these views and disagreements on other threads already? But okay, I'll bite. After some thought I'd rate the following players differently than Mozart:
Willie - 7 (5) He was peppered with high balls and handled all but two very well in torrid conditions. His kicking and decision making was a mixed bag.
De Allende - 5 (3) A few good carries, routine catching and passing, suspect tackling and defensive positioning. And yes, I did see him slap the ball away from the Argies after the chargedown. Good alertness, but that should be routine at test level.
Bakkies - 5 (6) Got involved, but not with any great effect.
Coetzee - 6 (5) Coetzee tackled well, but had little impact otherwise.
Morne - 3 (5) Didn't do much right and looked indecisive.
Apart from that he was pretty accurate. Jean was rated a 5 with the comment "nothing either way". That's not "rated highly".
Not sure why you feel the need to constantly start new threads specifically discussing Mozart's views, and then tossing in some exaggerations to boot. And you really shouldn't accuse others of bias. Three fingers pointing back at you and all that. I'm already waiting for you to slip in a mention of how bad Francois Steyn is in this thread too.
MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
17 Aug 2014, 21:50#3
Actually I could live with most of those changes....I thought Morne was a bit better, and I doubt he was expecting Willie's tapped mark. As for Clevermike he seems to be angry and irrational much of the time...and he is given to these grandstanding threads that " call me out". It's a bit like fighting a madman, it's hard to keep some decorum when your opponent has none. Still what else does the poor old codger have in his life.
CLclevermike
Coach57,555 posts
CLclevermikeCoach57,555 posts
17 Aug 2014, 21:58#4
MozartI am the rational one - your ratings were totally irrational and that is a fact. I think you were caught out again and now the personal attacks blossom all over again.