FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  My team of the Rugby Championship

My team of the Rugby Championship

Started by Shezza7 REPLIES96 VIEWS· 05 Oct 2014, 15:47
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
SH
ShezzaPro2,471 posts
05 Oct 2014, 15:47
#1
05 Oct 2014, 15:47#1

15. Israel Dag g - Lack lustre performances throughout the RC from this position with Folau and Le Roux dramatic drop in form compared to last year. Dagg has been the best of a bad bunch with his kicking rising above the others. Folau is the runner up. 


14. Cornal Hendricks - I'm not his biggest fan but he scored the most tries from his position, Ben Smith is a close second.


13. Jan Serfontein - Best defensive center of the RC really stood out in the last match against New Zealand in attack and with a massive work rate in both tests again the All Blacks. His opposite on the day, Conrad Smith, comes second.


12. Ma'a Nonu - Although he missed the last 2 matches he was the best 12 on attack and was the smartest also. He outplayed De Villiers in Wellington. De Villiers a second.


11. Julian Savea - Self explanatory. Habana a second for his work rate even though his attack has been sub standard. Manuel Montero also needs to be recognised for a good tournament. 


10. Handre Pollard - Again self explanatory. Aaron Cruden was the runner up but there's a huge margin between him and Pollard going by just this RC. 


9. Aaron Smith - Best throughout the tournament but Francois Hougaard could've easily taken this from him had he started for the Boks from the beginning judging from his last 2 games. 


8. Duane Vermeulen - Best 8 in the world and possibly depending on his EOYT and IRB player of the year contender. Kieran Read outplayed all his opponents bar Vermeulen this year. 


7. Michael Hooper - Scored the second most tries this year along with Cornal Hendricks (3) and he's a loose forward. Great work rate and a constant pest at the break down. McCaw a second and also scored the same amount of tries as Hooper and Hendricks.


6. Marcel Coetzee - Changed the game for the Boks against Argentina and started ever since. Another work horse who won his battle at the breakdown with Vermeulen against every opponent, conceded some harsh penalties at Ellis park but still the best of them all. I don't have a second best for this position, feel free to suggest names.


5. Sam Whitelock - Played havoc against the Boks at Ellis park and owned the lineouts in every game he played. Tomas Lavinini a second


4. Brodie Retallick - As much as I hate to admit that he's been the best lock on show, he can mix it up with the forwards and shows some deft touches for such a big guy. Etzebeth a second even in the shadow of the form of 2013 he's in, only because there's no other candidate. 


3. Ramiro Herrera - Argentinian scrum ruled this RC. Owen Franks comes second


2. Augustin Creevy - Lead the Argies well, scrummed well and threw well into the lineouts. Strauss a second. 


1. Marcos Ayerza - Argentinian scrum ruled. Beast comes second.


MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
05 Oct 2014, 17:23
#2
05 Oct 2014, 17:23#2

 Not a bad effort. These are my changes: 

 

 

Willie at 15, not at his best always but made crucial contributions.

 

Ben Smith on the wing....Hendricks had to be backed up defensively time and again yesterday.

 

Kuridrani was the dominant 13

 

Fernandez Lobbe in place of Coetzee

 

 

CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
05 Oct 2014, 17:28
#3
05 Oct 2014, 17:28#3
 I differ from you in the case of a very few players and will state my reservations:-
Hendriks -  he looked very good  in attacking lay - but there are serious reservations about his defense.   I would rather think that Adam Ashley Cooper should be the 14.  
Nonu -  I would favour Fekitoa at 12  - he did more in the two games he played there than Nonu did in all his games and I am not very impressed with De Villiers this year.   The latter showed serious defensive lapses.
For the rest I am fairly happy.  Please note that the Aussies and AB's play the nuiumber 7 as openside flanl - and since Coetzee played most of his games on the blindside I am perfrectly happy with that selection.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
05 Oct 2014, 17:28
#4
05 Oct 2014, 17:28#4
 I differ from you in the case of a very few players and will state my reservations:-
Hendriks -  he looked very good  in attacking lay - but there are serious reservations about his defense.   I would rather think that Adam Ashley Cooper should be the 14.  
Nonu -  I would favour Fekitoa at 12  - he did more in the two games he played there than Nonu did in all his games and I am not very impressed with De Villiers this year.   The latter showed serious defensive lapses.
For the rest I am fairly happy.  Please note that the Aussies and AB's play the nuiumber 7 as openside flanl - and since Coetzee played most of his games on the blindside I am perfrectly happy with that selection.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
05 Oct 2014, 20:16
#5
05 Oct 2014, 20:16#5
Agreed with Moz - Ben Smith ahead of Hendricks who has defensive issues.
Kuridrani was the best 13
Agreed with Coetzee he was better than Lobbe. 
Beast ahead of Ayerza
SH
ShezzaPro2,471 posts
05 Oct 2014, 21:05
#6
05 Oct 2014, 21:05#6
 Kuridrani missed the first two matches against New Zealand so I picked Serfontein who has had to put up with De Villiers jumping out of the line all the time.
I know we play the openside at 6, Coetzee played both positions this RC and there was no way I wasn't including Hooper so he got Coetzee got chosen by me to play Blindside. 



SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
05 Oct 2014, 21:11
#7
05 Oct 2014, 21:11#7
 Would be happy with Jan out of position at 13 he has been very good.
Time to move him to 12 now and rid the Boks of old m an Jean
SH
ShezzaPro2,471 posts
05 Oct 2014, 21:17
#8
05 Oct 2014, 21:17#8
 Whilst I agree with you it won't happen until after the RWC, Jean is Meyer's captain.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news