SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
22 Mar 2022, 18:52#1
Madosh Tambwe the Bulls wing - what a player
Evan Roos - the next big thing in Bok rugby - the obvious choice to replace Vermeulen
Elrigh Louw - brute force that makes an impression. Good to have in the squad as an 8 or 7
Both Louw and Roos are far better than Wiese
Vincent Tshituka, the Lions blindside
Add these guys to the broader Bok squad of:
Willie, Fassi , Gelant, Mapimpi, Kolbe, Nkosi, Am, Kriel, de Allende, Willemse, Pollard, Jantjies, Faf, Reinach, Jantjies, Hendrikse, Ox, Kitshoff, Nyakane, Malherbe, Thomas du Toit, Wilco Louw, Koch, Marx, Mbonambi, Dweba, Etzebeth, Lood, RG Snyman, Moerat, Kolisi, Kwagga, v Staaden, PSDT, Dan du Preez, JL du Preez and Vermeulen
I’d ditch Frans Steyn, Mostert, Wiese and Orie
I’d recall Esterhuizen, JVR, Serfontein, Papier, Jason Jenkins and Goosen
22 Mar 2022, 22:27#3
Jordan Hendrikse is impressive but so is Chamberlain and Libbok...Goosen is a good player but a bit injury prone and Jantjies maybe not the right choice especially with all the talent that is playing well....pollard can guide them into action....rest of the Squad is good but would keep mostert. Wilco is a must.
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
22 Mar 2022, 22:43#4
Goosen and Jantjies are definitely Bok material and agreed on Hendrikse at 10.
Be happy to include him in the squad - looks the real deal
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
23 Mar 2022, 00:58#6
Serfontein has been the best 12 in French rugby for the past two seasons
If you had actually watched any provincial rugby of late you would know that Papier has been outstanding
Jenkins is soooooo much better than powder puff Mostert, in fact most SA locks are better
Goosen playing for your buddy Jake was simply brilliant until he got injured playing on artificial surfaces like RG did
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
23 Mar 2022, 10:48#8
Serfontein left early so shot himself in the foot. He was part of Rassie’s plans pre WC but got injured
Papier has been brilliant, looks to be our best attacking 9 right now - but you ignorantly comment on a player you have not seen play - that’s typical hilarious nonsense
Mostert is part of the system it’s what keeps him in the squad. Rassie soon realised he was not that great when Lood replaced him as a starter. Unfortunately for us RG got injured so we had to stick with useless Mostert on the bench. We lost PSDT at 7 and Mostert was given a go - he was so fucking useless there he was replaced by small Kwagga playing out of position.
Rassie is a rugby genius but I can’t expect him to get everything right - at least he is smart enough to recognise the fact that Mostert is not good enough to start and that when Eben, Lood and RG are fit, he won’t even make the bench. I look forward to that day as Mostert is a physical liability
23 Mar 2022, 11:58#9
Mostert is physical liability and kwagga is not? Why oh why, if Mostert is so useless, does he get picked before both Du Preez brothers? Say what you like, but time and time again mostert is there playing his Hart out for the Boks, staying fit without injury and bringing his contribution. Stable, mobile and tough as nails, he is up to date, a more consistent bok player than Pieter, lood and snyman.....that is why his nickname is “ sous” he is always there.....the proof is in the pudding, no denying that. :)
23 Mar 2022, 14:23#11
Yes you right Draad “Mostert Sous’ which is mostly always lekker as a add on to your meats and such :)
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
23 Mar 2022, 17:37#12
Geez M power dont be stupid. Kwagga is a small openside and Mostert is a useless lock. I don’t expect physicality from an openside I do a Bok lock.
Mostert has zero physicality, makes no impact carrying the ball in traffic, is useless in clear outs - evidenced by not being able to clear out the 18 year old Georgian fullback.
Anyone who rates him that highly is rugby ignorant. They see all the heart and energy but miss the fact that all of that amounts to zero productivity
Mostert is shit
The du Preez twins are loose forwards so are not competing with Mostert at lock - catch a wake up man
23 Mar 2022, 18:04#13
Jean and Dan du preez can and has played lock before.....and it’s quite naive saying that a flanker should not be physical?? It’s almost like saying that a tight head prop does not have to anchor the scrum....does not really make sense.....Anycase Dave it’s just my opinion and I am learning as I go along.....I like Mostert and look past the energy level and still see his worth....it does have to count in his favour that the guy is consistently there without injury....wouldn’t you agree?
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
23 Mar 2022, 18:32#14
What the fuck has a tighthead prop got to do with it.
I’m saying that a lock needs to be very physical, he is a tightforward.
An openside has to be physical yes but not nearly as much as a lock so you comparing Mostert and Kwagga makes zero sense
JL du Preez has filled in at lock at club level but is certainly not competing with Mostert for the lock spot. He is not in the equation
Nope I give Mostert zero credit as he is shit. I can’t stand light weight test locks that run around bashing into players and bouncing backwards or not being able to clear out a kid at fullback.
Mostert would not make my Bok squad of 100 players and I mean that sincerely
