FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  News on Malherbe and more madness

News on Malherbe and more madness

Started by Beeno19 REPLIES161 VIEWS· 25 Aug 2014, 12:28
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
25 Aug 2014, 12:28
#1
25 Aug 2014, 12:28#1

Springbok coach Heyneke Meyer’s hopes of a solid scrum for the rest of the Castle Lager Rugby Championship were dealt a massive blow (Please note Dr Mozzzz) with the news that tighthead Frans Malherbe has been ruled out of rugby for the rest of the year.

Malherbe fractured his ankle in Saturday’s narrow win over Argentina in Salta and has returned home to undergo surgery, possibly as soon as Tuesday.

Team doctor Craig Roberts confirmed the injury on arriving back at OR Tambo airport in Johannesburg and told supersport.com that Malherbe’s season is over.

“Unluckily in the last minute of the game his ankle got caught in a ruck and he twisted it. It kind of got caught in the turf and he ended up fracturing his ankle,” Dr Roberts said.

“We took him to hospital after the game. He had some x-rays there and saw a specialist. He has fractured the bone on the outside of his ankle and he will need surgery on that.

“We made the decision to bring him back to South Africa to have the surgery. He will see a specialist in Cape Town today and in all likelihood will end up having surgery tomorrow.”

The Boks are at least thankful that it was a clean break, meaning that surgery should go well and the recovery time should be shorter, but Dr Roberts said that it would effectively rule him out until the middle of November.

“It depends how well the surgery goes, but we’re looking at three months. Effectively that is the year gone for him. I was putting it into the calendar last night and it takes him into the middle of the end of the year tour, so it is the year for him,” he added.

On the positive side (Ca you beleive thsi oak is being serious!!!!), the Boks are looking forward to welcoming back both lock Victor Matfield and utility forward Willem Alberts when the team reassemble later this week. Both players were heavily missed in the two weeks that the Boks struggled against Los Pumas and should they be able to prove their fitness, they will likely be drafted straight back into the side for the next Rugby Championship game against the Wallabies in Perth.(The loose trio is Coetzee, Vermulen and Louw - please Meyer dont get thsi wrong!!! Also leave wee matfiled out of the match 23!!!!!!!!!!!!! )

“We will get feedback from the Bulls and Sharks today. The feedback I’ve got so far is that they are doing well. Both Victor and Willem have been running nicely. We’re confident that they will be ready for Perth but I’ll need to assess them before I make that decision,” Dr Roberts said.

One player who is not likely to return to the Boks soon is Coenie Oosthuizen. The prop whose experiment at tighthead seemed to lose him his Bok place after struggling in the final weeks of Vodacom Super Rugby is still struggling with a foot ligament injury and has not started training since Super Rugby ended.

“Coenie is struggling with a foot injury, he has a ligament injury in his foot. I’m waiting for feedback from the Cheetahs today,” Dr Roberts said.

Malherbe’s replacement is likely to be either Lourens Adriaanse, who has been part of the Bok squad before, or Marcel van der Merwe, who earned his debut against Scotland earlier this year.

What a pity matfiled didnt paly on satruday. We would have lost and he would have been out. A worthwhile price to pay.

Nowif he comes back and we beat the wobblies - man all the wrong conclusions will inevitably be reached.A re we cursed or what!!!! Freak injury to Malherbe when we really needed him fit with jannie need a break.


If I were an Aussie I would be inebriated and more! What madness rules our rugby!!!



BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
25 Aug 2014, 12:29
#2
25 Aug 2014, 12:29#2
 Did wee matfiled actually del iberately dodge the Argies. He is a wiley show pony that I have always conceded.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
25 Aug 2014, 12:44
#3
25 Aug 2014, 12:44#3
 The idea that Matfield will solve problems and that Alberts is better than Marcell Coetzee is rank lunacy.   The player to call up is Dreyer of the Lions - not the other two.  He is a very good tighthead scrummer - definitely better than the other options.
Mozart will scream Cilliers - but he was scrummed into the ground by Van der Merwe of the Lions on Saurday.   I would say Dreyer is the answer - not the two mentioned in the article - especially since we cannot rely on Jannie to produce anything insofar as scrum solidity is concerned.   
Sorry about Malherbe - he was the obvious answer to our T ighthead problems.    
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
25 Aug 2014, 14:13
#4
25 Aug 2014, 14:13#4
Mike its Julian Redlinghuys who is the star tighthead for the Lions. He also unfortunately is injured. Apparently Marcel van der merwe and Lourens Adrianse are possibles. Dreyer is a pacy prop but not a great scrummager. 
Yes the loss of Malherbe is a big blow.



WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
25 Aug 2014, 14:48
#5
25 Aug 2014, 14:48#5
 As any Tight head will tell you [ so now I'm gonna tell you ] any proper team like is built upon the cornerstone that a good Tight Head provides . All those sea-gulling backs are a dime a dozen and kick a rock in NZ and a half dozen world class players will put there hands up ,even Oz and SA have a few of the  lazy beggars slinking about.I'm even a bit sus on the second row and locks truth be told .Any bugger can catch a ball and run fast ,one needs to be born into the black arts .
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
25 Aug 2014, 21:02
#6
25 Aug 2014, 21:02#6
Malherbe is hopeless....this is no loss. The guy must be  top heavy or something, at the slightest inwards pressure he snaps, twists inwards and the next thing the pootjies are kicking in the air. He ends nearly all his scrums flat on his stomach.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
25 Aug 2014, 21:39
#7
25 Aug 2014, 21:39#7
 Big loss to boks malherbe and beast were a god send after useless steenkamp and jannie got their arse scrummed into their throats. Shit I have NEVER seen such a pathetic scrum performance by a bok scrum ever, it was embarrassing. 
In the 3 scrums that took place when malherbe and beast took the field 2 were as solid as rocks with one going against the boks incorrectly given the inward scrumming of the argies. 
He'll those two showed how it was meant to be done
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
25 Aug 2014, 22:14
#8
25 Aug 2014, 22:14#8
 Mozart
Stop taqlking tripe - with Jannie in serios reverse gear - at least Malherbe brought stability to the scrumming this Saturday.   You are wrong about Malherbe and you are wrong about your National Treasure.       
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
25 Aug 2014, 22:26
#9
25 Aug 2014, 22:26#9
Malherbe brought stability to our scrum....why that's priceless. Scrum one in reverse big time. Scrum two three times flat on his stomach, then penalized. Scrum three twice on his stomach, but  Walsh finally gave up and let the play go on. All that following a test where he scrummed once and gave a potential match losing penalty. 
You and Dave think just making unsupported statements is going to cut it...no way OOmpie, you aren't talking to a fellow Natal provincial Apparatchik
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
25 Aug 2014, 23:12
#10
25 Aug 2014, 23:12#10
 Absolute bullshit scrum one was solid it never budged, second scrum had argies scrumming inwards and 3rd one both sets of props were on their knees having not budged at all and the ref let it go.
Compare that to the scrum retreating at a rate of knots while useless steenkamp and jannie were on the park - it was a disgrace.
The Bok scrum improved when malherbe entered the equation - FACT
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news