FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  NZHerald Ratings

NZHerald Ratings

Started by bobbok...3 REPLIES284 VIEWS· 19 Sept 2016, 11:10
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
BO
bobbok...Captain10,129 posts
19 Sept 2016, 11:10
#1
19 Sept 2016, 11:10#1

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=11711945




All Blacks

Ben Smith 8

Exemplified the All Blacks as a strong second half slowly but surely saw his team surge away. Another day, another try.

Israel Dagg 8

Proved elusive on the right wing as he continued his excellent Super Rugby form at the home of the Crusaders.

Malakai Fekitoa 7

One unfortunate error but always made good ground when with the ball. Dependable on defence.

Ryan Crotty 7

Another assured display, linking well with Fekitoa in an ever-improving midfield partnership.

Julian Savea 7

Good finish to score his first try against South Africa. Enjoyed fewer opportunities to run but still made defenders miss.

Beauden Barrett 8

Less of the dynamic running of recent weeks but directed his team well and kicked accurately, except from the tee.

Continued below.

Related Content

Rugby: All Blacks storm past South Africa

Video

Watch: All Blacks finish strong against South Africa

Rugby: New age All Blacks one of the best teams ever

Aaron Smith 9

Picked the perfect pass for three of his side's tries. Electric with ball in hand and back to his game-breaking best.

Kieran Read 8

More Rugby

As steady as ever in the lineout and typically direct in the carry. A fine all-round performance on his home turf.

Ardie Savea 7

Made plenty of tackles and won a couple of turnovers. One grubber showed an attribute not shared by Sam Cane.

Jerome Kaino 7

One memorable line break that almost produced points. Injury prematurely ended his evening.

Sam Whitelock 7

Crossed for his fifth test try after substitutions saw him switch to loose forward. Effortlessly effective in the lineout

Brodie Retallick 6

Fewer carries but as hard-hitting as always in the collision. Needs to find more effective contact lenses.

Owen Franks 7

Tackled relentlessly. Didn't get his hands on the ball as his long wait for a try extended into record-breaking territory.

Dane Coles 9

Brilliant hands to set up the first two tries. Thrived inside the tram lines all evening, though the chip and chase needs work.

Joe Moody 6

Held his own in the scrum while rarely featuring around the field. Replaced early in the second half.

Reserves

16 Codie Taylor 5/10
17 Wyatt Crockett 6/10
18 Charlie Faumuina 6/10
19 Luke Romano 6/10
20 Matt Todd 7/10
21 TJ Perenara 7/10
22 Lima Sopoaga N/A
23 Anton Lienert-Brown 7

South Africa

Johan Goosen 7

Made the initial bust that led to the Spingboks' opening try. Cleaned up and kicked well at the back.

Bryan Habana 6

Still has plenty of pace and can still run a fine line, as illustrated by his try. Essentially a bystander after that early spark.

Jesse Kriel 5

Anonymous on defence and only a little better in attack. Struggled to make his mark in the midfield.

Juan du Jongh 4

Missed too many tackles in defence and never made his presence known on attack.

Francois Hougaard 5

Struggled to restrict the influence of Dagg and provided no such pain when South Africa enjoyed possession.

Elton Jantjies 3

Big mistake handed back the initiative after taking the lead. Another error from the kickoff set the tone for the second spell.

Faf de Klerk 5

Blown away by his opposite number. Made no in-roads around the fringes and fell off tackles when targeted.

Warren Whiteley 8

Threw a fantastic pass to set up Habana's try. One of the better Boks with ball in hand. A handful at the breakdown.

Oupa Mohoje 5

Quiet in all aspects as the All Blacks' loose forwards attracted much of the attention. Subbed early in the second half.

Francois Louw 5

Made little impact as only Whitely held his own in the loosie battle. Generated no turnover ball.

Pieter-Steph Du Toit 7

Regularly found the ball in his hands and regularly made good metres. A consistent presence in the lineout.

Eden Etzebeth 6

Proficient in his few carries and contributed well in the lineout until Strauss exited the field.

Vincent Koch 7

Enjoyed some nice touches around the park. An uneven effort in a scrum that was steady and then struggled.

Adriaan Strauss 5

Quiet on both sides of the ball before being forced off shortly after the break. Did operate a functioning lineout.

Tendai Mtawarira 5

Not quite as beastly as his nickname would suggest. Scrummaged well but ineffective around the field.

Reserves

16 Malcolm Marx 5/10
17 Steven Kitshoff 5/10
18 Lourens Adriaanse N/A
19 Franco Mostert 6/10
20 Willem Alberts 5/10
21 Jaco Kriel 5/10
22 Morne Steyn 6/10
23 Damien de Allende 6/10

- NZ Herald

AB
ABasquefanPro2,549 posts
19 Sept 2016, 12:20
#2
19 Sept 2016, 12:20#2
 

"Brodie Retallick 6  Needs to find more effective contact lenses."  


too true,..... he's always losing his lenses



BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
19 Sept 2016, 13:45
#3
19 Sept 2016, 13:45#3
 Juan du Jongh 4

Missed too many tackles in defence and never made his presence known on attack. Some food for thought for Dr Mozzzzz.


He is very generous with old man Alberts


Note the 6 for Allende.


Jantjes is clearly the biggest problem. 




MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
19 Sept 2016, 15:04
#4
19 Sept 2016, 15:04#4
Actually factually if the reporter who wrote this had read the Herald's own stats he would have noted de Jongh missed no more tackles than Hougaard, Jantjies and Faf and he made one brilliant try saving tackle from behind on Ben Smith.
The reason de Jongh is there is not because he is a brilliant test solution....he simply isn't big enough. It's because none of the other guys like Kriel, Mapoe or Allende even know the basics of the position....where to stand, when to come up....when to shift.
As for Allende he did nothing accept hang back allowing Coles to make the try scoring pass to Whiteley. You have to watch the game HasBeen.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news