FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  NZHerald Ratings

NZHerald Ratings

Started by bobbok...6 REPLIES3,689 VIEWS· 17 Sept 2018, 11:17
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
BO
bobbok...Captain10,129 posts
17 Sept 2018, 11:17
#1
17 Sept 2018, 11:17#1


Rugby Championship: All Blacks v Springboks player ratings 15 Sep, 2018 10:18pm 5 minutes to read The Springboks have claimed a legendary victory against the All Blacks in an incredible match ending in 36 - 34. Footage for Sky By: Andrew Alderson Sports reporter, NZ Herald andrew.alderson@nzherald.co.nz @aldersonnotes

See who shone and who struggled in South Africa's 36-34 win over the All Blacks.

All Blacks

15. Jordie Barrett - 6

Raced into fifth minute gap like he was late for a bus. Glitch with rushed throw-in nabbed by Le Roux in 25th. Glided well into line.

14. Ben Smith - 7

Poise as he accelerates is a trait which will be lauded in All Blacks history. Ensured opponents were constantly pirouetting.

13. Anton Lienert-Brown - 6

Sitting duck as Le Roux snared 25th min Jordie Barrett lineout pass. Composed hot kumara-ing Ioane try. Fed Kolbe for intercept.

12. Ryan Crotty - 6

Constant forays to try to pierce Springbok defence in return from concussion. Faced a Fenway Park Green Monster defence.

11. Rieko Ioane - 6

Related articles:

SPORT | All Blacks

How ref's missed call killed the All Blacks

15 Sep, 2018 9:40pm 3 minutes to read SPORT | All Blacks

Bok Shock! Springboks stun All Blacks for famous win

15 Sep, 2018 9:29pm 4 minutes to read SPORT

Brain explosion! Wallabies crash to new low as Pumas make history

16 Sep, 2018 12:11am 3 minutes to read SPORT | All Blacks

As it happened: Springboks stun All Blacks for famous win

15 Sep, 2018 7:00pm 3 minutes to read

Pace might challenge a cheetah or greyhound but few opportunities to unleash. Fred Astaire footwork in second half try.

10. Beauden Barrett - 5

Kicking boot struggled at key moments, like at 36-34. Courage in 56th as Boks loomed, but stepped by Dyantyi later.

9. Aaron Smith - 6

Struggled under Springbok swarming defence in pursuit of victory. Graceful hongi to swap with Perenara.

8. Kieran Read - 7

Constant threshing in the rucks and mauls. Key lineout take in 79th and stepped up — but to no avail — in final stanzas.

7. Sam Cane - 6

Spilt ball early but buried himself in graft work to keep All Blacks' chances alive. Met steely Springboks' resolve at breakdowns.

6. Liam Squire - 6

Useful lineout mitts and handy running off teammates' shoulders. Struggled against opposition might.

5. Scott Barrett - 6

Dragged into maul as Marx came free in 32nd minute try. Kept tackling but physicality appeared to take its toll.

4. Samuel Whitelock - 6

Did plenty of mahi against unrelenting opponents. Gave scrum spine but Springboks had measure despite his rangy work.

3. Owen Franks - 7

Tenacious tackling made sure attackers felt his presence. Powerful cornerstone scrummaging.

2. Codie Taylor - 7

Textbook draw and pass in face of 17th minute Kitshoff challenge to set Ben Smith free. Roamed with flair.

1. Karl Tu'inukuafe - 7

Could safely lay out silver service setting to dine off his back in the scrum. Teased with a Meads-esque one-handed run.

Reserves

16. Liam Coltman - 6
17. Tim Perry - N/A
18. Ofa Tuungafasi - 6
19. Patrick Tuipulotu - 6
20. Ardie Savea - 7
21. TJ Perenara - 8
22. Jack Goodhue - 7
23. Damian McKenzie - 7

South Africa

15. Willie le Roux - 7

Exquisite grubber and perseverance in chase set up 25th minute try. Got yellow card in 68th after desperation at ruck.

14. Jesse Kriel - 7

Effective 52nd tackle to snuff out Read scrum move, but not enough to stop All Blacks juggernaut moments later.

13. Lukhanyo Am - 7

Punishing tackler on occasion. Combative in attack but replaced by Kolbe at halftime, who snared crucial intercept.

12. Damian de Allende - 6

Shoulder looked damaged early in second half. Struggled to make an impact through All Blacks defensive line.

11. Aphiwe Dyantyi - 7

Looked like a Dancing With The Stars rookie against Ben Smith footwork but got utu waltzing in for two tries.

10. Handré Pollard - 7

Over-kicked at start but made sound marshalling decisions. Even refused to flinch as Tu'inukuafe bulldozer loomed.

9. Faf de Klerk - 7

Looked like a modern day Jean-Pierre Rives dashing about the fray. Gave forwards plenty of incentive.

8. Warren Whiteley - 8

Roved and revved his way around the field to lend stability and poise to cause. A selfless display. Looked knackered.

7. Pieter-Steph du Toit - 6

Clasping at shadows on occasion against All Blacks' sleight of hand. Ran effectively with ball in hand.

6. Siya Kolisi - 7

Revelled in tackling and led by example to get team to first win in New Zealand since 2009. Stamped the authority of Old Foe.

5. Franco Mostert - 6

Did some maul surfing in the lead-up to Marx try. Handy takes from lineout ensured Springboks had resource to work with.

4. Eben Etzebeth - 7

Rummaged around in rucks and mauls with limited dividends. Safe lineout option. Disciplined with victory on horizon.

3. Frans Malherbe - 7

Meaty early tackle on Beauden Barrett. Squire's right arm and shoulder know the capability of his horsepower.

2. Malcolm Marx - 8

Carried ball like it was a crown jewel for 32nd minute try. Master at drawing defenders and creating space elsewhere.

1. Steven Kitshoff - 7

Leg power in mauls gave Springboks parity and swung hips into a pass like Bruce Robertson in one backline cameo.

Reserves

16. Bongi Mbonambi - N/A
17. Tendai Mtawarira - 7
18. Wilco Louw - N/A
19. RG Snyman - 7
20. Francois Louw - N/A
21. Ross Cronjé - N/A
22. Elton Jantjies - 7
23. Cheslin Kolbe - 7

BL
bluebokPro3,977 posts
17 Sept 2018, 13:55
#2
17 Sept 2018, 13:55#2
According to this, it looks like Whiteley may be one of the unsung hero's of this victory. He did manage to reel in A Smith on the break, which surprised me, even though the AB's scored seconds later. Is Smith a little slow, or is Whiteley faster than he looks? I see they don't rate PSDT as highly as many of the posters on this site. 
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
17 Sept 2018, 14:03
#3
17 Sept 2018, 14:03#3

Bit harsh on Ioane who scored twice !

BL
bluebokPro3,977 posts
17 Sept 2018, 14:17
#4
17 Sept 2018, 14:17#4
Welcome Hamster. G lad you're not a Mole!
DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
17 Sept 2018, 15:26
#5
17 Sept 2018, 15:26#5

HAHAHAHAHA!!! LOL BLUE, PRICELESS!!!!

PA
PakieCaptain17,321 posts
17 Sept 2018, 15:41
#6
17 Sept 2018, 15:41#6

The soap opera continues.

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
17 Sept 2018, 15:51
#7
17 Sept 2018, 15:51#7
Those are better ratings, from a guy who isn't crying when he wrote them. But see the Mozcroscope on why Stephanie should be lower rated than Mostert. In watching the game almost frame by frame to produce that analysis nobody wants to believe, three players loomed massively.....Willie, Faf and Whiteley. The numberof times those three players did smart things at the right moment to save dangerous situations was a revelation.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news