The following from News 24:-
“After following the past three weeks' Test action, one thing is pretty clear: the Springboks are not ready to go into battle with the All Blacks.
There was much hype and elation on Saturday night after the Boks claimed a 19-13 - and subsequent series - win over Ireland in Port Elizabeth.
But should we really overzealously celebrate scraping home in a home Test series against an Ireland side without several of their frontline stars?
Yes, credit must be given for how the Boks turned things around when they looked down and out after 60 minutes in the second Test in Johannesburg, but similar performances against the world's No 1 team would not suffice.
The All Blacks were below their best in a series against Wales, yet still won comfortably with an overall scoreline of 121-49 over the three Tests.
There was marked improvement on defence from the Boks this past weekend and it was welcome to see, but tactical kicking, discipline and patience on attack are all areas that need to be improved.
The lack of a proper fetcher could also prove problematic later in the season.
For these above-mentioned reasons, Sport24has highlighted five players we feel could add spark for the Boks ahead of the Rugby Championship:
Bryan Habana
As seen during the Ireland series, the Boks were at times found wanting on the wing. Lwazi Mvovo’s weakness under the high ball was badly exposed.
Habana would add some much needed experience and his work ethic could rub off on some of his outside back partners.
He could also add some much needed spark on attack in the often static Bok backline.
Bismarck du Plessis
Adriaan Strauss is now the Bok captain which makes it difficult to see Du Plessis getting a call-up from Montpellier in France, where he currently plies his trade.
Strauss is solid at the set-pieces, but he needs to improve his general play - on defence and with ball in hand.
Du Plessis’ physicality in contact and breakdown prowess were certainly missed during the Ireland series and there’s no reason why the 32-year-old cannot add value to the squad later in the year.
Johan Goosen
The former Free Stater and somewhat forgotten son of Springbok rugby has been in scintillating form for French club Racing 92 this season.
Goosen was one of Racing's heroes in their 29-21 victory over Toulon in the Top 14 final in Barcelona this past weekend - a game in which he played outside centre.
He slotted three long-range efforts from the kicking tee to help Racing win their first Top 14 title since 1990.
His versatility could come in handy, considering the injury worries to flyhalf Pat Lambie, as well as the dip in form displayed by fullback Willie le Roux.
Heinrich Brussow
The absence of an out-and-out fetcher was evident in the series against Ireland and Brussow’s value in this department is well documented.
Imagine how key a cog Brussow could have been had previous coach Heyneke Meyer not had an obsession with size!
He could have been a 70-plus Test veteran by now, but given the fact that he’s still to turn 30, he could yet add value for the Boks, especially on the ground...
Schalk Burger
A fit and available Schalk Burger’s experience could prove invaluable in a game against the All Blacks. There are several newcomers to the squad and the 86-Test capped veteran could play a key mentorship role in what is sure to be trying times during the Rugby Championship.”
I have some serious problems with some of the above since a lot of what is written is based on reputation – more than actual performance. Also some players is already in the declining late years of their careers and in fact are no chance that they would be available for the 2019 WC. If Coetzee makes the same mistake as Meyer did and not build up a squad foir the WC that year – he will end up in the same situation as Meyer did.
So lets look at the five players recommended:-
Bryan Habana
Age - 33 years
Stats – last two matches:-
Montpellier
Pass - 2
Carry - 6
Meters gained - 20
Defenders beaten - 1
TO conceded , 2
Tackles made - 3
Racing Metro
Pass - 1
Carry - 6
Meters gained - 19
Defenders beaten - 1
TO conceded , 1
Tackles made - 5
Tackles missed - 3
There is no indication that he is still the quality player he used to be. His performance in both matches borders on the sub-par and it would not be wise to bring him back especially if his present performances are borne in mind.
Bismarck du Plessis
Age - 32
Although Bismarck is a better hooker than Strauss by some distance and he did well in his last match – it would be much better to look at younger local talent like Malcolm Marx and Akker van der Merwe, The latter to are the players of the future and likely to be the hooker combination in 2019 – so why not phase them in and not fall back what can at best be a temporary arrangement.
Johann Goosen
Age - 23
Goosen has been red-hot in form in recent matches and he played for Racing Metro in three different positions – namely flyhalf, full back and outside center.
Stats – last two matches
Clermont
Try scored - 1
Conversion pts - 8
Kick - 1
Pass - 2
Carry - 11
Meters gained - 33
Clean breaks - 1
Defenders beaten - 3
TO conceded , 3
Tackles made - 4
Toulon
Conversion pts - 9
Kick - 4
Pass - 2
Carry - 10
Meters gained - 57
Clean Breaks - 2
Defenders beaten - 4
TO conceded , 1
Tackles made - 8
Tackles missed - 1
He was repeatedly called the most valuable player in the Racing Metro backline – even though Dan Carter is in the same backline.
With our problem at flyhalf and also in the other two positions he should be called up for the RC. 2015-16 was the first full season when he did not suffer an injury and he may have grown stronger – maybe he was too young when he originally came to the fore.
Heinrich Brussow
Age - 29
He was playing in Japan and there is n real info on his present performances available. The last time he played in SA he was no better than Jaco Kriel and I would rather invest in Kriel for the future than in Brussow.
Schalk Burger
Age - 33
Burger was definitely sub-par in his performances for the Stormers this year and it is clear that age is beginning to take its toll in his case.
