MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
17 Jun 2018, 16:20#9
No need to mess with The Team where it's functioning well. Subs can always be brought on earlier to give them exposure. We don't need to see a Bok team losing now. We scraped the first test, were more convincing yesterday...we need to blow these Poms away in the third to build on that momentum.
This is a new team and needs to play together as much as possible. But where there are uncertainties, a bit of experimenting makes sense.
1 Dyantyi looks too vulnerable defensively...but then so does Mapimpi in Super rugby. I'd stick with Dyantyi. He has been clever ball in hand, never dying with the ball and his defensive issues are judgement based, his tackling is decent.
2 Am would be replaced by Kriel.....no learning there....and Esterhozen/Kriel was already tried against Wales. So give Am another run.
3 A good step forward would be to try Am outside his provincial partner...Esterhosen.....not perfect but we have to try something.
4 Give the second front row a shot....we need to see them against the Pom first team. But bring Wilco back on the bench. Malherbe showed us nothing. That said I'm still not confident about Thomas.....he got folded once yesterday and the Poms haven't scrummed well.
5 I would certainly keep Snyman, but give Stephanie a shot at 5. He is no 4 and he is no 7. If he is going to play regularly for the Boks he has to finally prove it at 5.
6 Vermeulen and unfortunately Kolisi have to be retained...and the much hyped twin has been a flop. But there seems to be little choice but to start him again, Mostert should be given a break.
Which all comes down to this team:
Willie, Nkosi, Am, Esterhozen, Dyantyi, Pollard, Faf...
Kitshoff, Akker, Thomas, Snyman, Stephanie, Kolisi, du Preez, Vermeulen.
In theory that should be the most physical pack we have fielded in the series.
On the bench I'd have Mostert, Wilco, the Beast, Bongi, Notshe, van Zyl, Allende and just for laughs Gelant.