Rugby 365 ratings
In most cases a waste of time to rea d.
lowerevery rating by 2 to 3 points and you have the truth. Nobody really played the complete game except Mapimpi.
I have made some corrections
15 Willie le Roux – 4.5/10
Calamity James in the first half, everything he touched, turned to sh$t. A total liability under the high ball, and maybe Kolbe should be moved to XV for the Welsh test. He blundered any easy catch that only required a draw and pass to set up his outside winger to score. Was better in the second half as a playmaker.
14 Cheslin Kolbe – 5/10
Possibly injured, did not get much ball.
13 Lukhanyo Am - 6/10
Solid defender, but needs to run off the shoulder of Delande on attack more.
12 Damian de Allende 9/10
His best test. His defence probably stopped the two best-attacking movements of Japan. He got at least 2 turnovers and helped protect possession when Bok backs were isolated. Very all-round, even if at times he seems more like a loose forward.
11 Makazole Mapimpi 8/10
A wing is on the pitch to score tries, and he is consistent at what he does. Could maybe contribute more in other areas of the game, and be stronger under the high ball- but he is an excellent finisher. Almost got a third try near the end.
10 Handré Pollard – 6/10
Reasonably quiet test, but did get his backline running well. Unfortunately, he did not get more possession – but that was down to the box kick game plan
9 Francois de Klerk 4/10
Everything he did was good, except box kicks. He is the worst box kicker in world rugby. Why persist with this strategy using this player.
8 Duane Vermeulen 6.5/10
Another solid outing being an allrounder.
7 Pieter-Steph du Toit 5.5/10
Stephanie was shown up for his lack of pace against a fast Japanese team. As usual had a high work rate, albeit the impact was limited
6 Siyamthanda Kolisi (captain) 5.5/10
Taking the captain off the pitch to replace Beast was a surprise, but he is the weakest link in the back row.
5 Lomp de Jager 8/10
Another good game. Strong at the rucks and rolling mauls. Very good in the lineouts.
4 Eben Etzebeth 610
A decent shift, with the lineouts being his main contribution. Needs to be substituted earlier.
3 Flab Malherbe 7/10
Flab had one of his best tests contributing outside the scrum, while still scrumming well.
2 Bongi Mbonambi – 6/10
Usual physical self, but Marx did appear to be better.
1 Tendai Mtawarira -6/10
Solid, but fortunate to not get a red card.
Vermu was a 5 looked gased early obviously too old for this level now. Dimian was a 5 too many mistakes crappy passing and unstructured. Kolbe a 3 did bugger all and got run over he was easily tackled. Du Toit a 7 for his carries and cleaning. Pawlard a 5. Etz was invisible mostly a 5. Willie looks like a hasbeen mostly a 3. Am is a BEE appointment mostly a 3.
Willemse needs to start next game. Bring on Elton and get that ball wider quicker. RG must start now. Whats up with Brits?? Looks awesome every time I see him.
Unbelievable Allende drops a ball, destroys a try scoring situation with obstruction, turns the ball over 3 times in 9 carries.....and gains 24 metres against weak opposition. And the media explodes.
Stephanie is gassed all over the park misses 3 tackles and makes 5 metres in 6 runs, while losing the ball once. And they all mention his one lineout steal on an under thrown ball never mentioning the 4 others delivered by Etzebeth and Lomp against the short Japanese locks.
Our media is clueless and biased. These are good centre performances today:
Its called low standards. Bokkies always do this shit, beat up on a minnow and then beat their chests like a mighty silver back but when daddy gorilla comes to the party they are Abu from Aladdin again.
Mozart's assessments are always BS and CAMB is going to see his own arse without a mirror this coming Saturday,
Find three reasons to criticize De Allende and none to criticize anybody else. Not a word about the critical turnovers and nothing one can call sense. Why the leaving out the zero contribution by Fatso? Normal Mozart BS and his stupidity reached maximum with Du Toit again, Nothing about line-out and other work by Du Toit, Wonder why he did not go bananas about De Jager and Malherbe as well?
Allende made one good turnover and he tractored a few times at 2.5 metres a carry. But he made no offloads.....just died with the ball.
In fact Japan made 12 offloads and we made only 2. One by Marx and one by Frans.
Just another example of the cul de sac that Allende is. Was he poor? No, it was one of his better games....against weak opposition admittedly. But he still failed to create anything.
Allende was excellent as was Du Toit and Lood.
Stick with Beeno and avoid going astray.
Bye the way oaks much as I disliked Faf's never ending box kicks please note how poor the follow ups were.
The Japs took the high ball very well so the box kicks were to no avail.
yeah but everytime they caught them they got hammered - was actually good tactic in the end it belted the poor japanee into surrender like at the hands of the yanks in WW2...
Credit to Japanee for 1st half of entertaining rugby... it gets real next week for all................
Faf a 4.5 you guys are mad... allende a 9 for cold dropping a try scoring opportunity..?!?
your metrics are messed up... are these quota effected by height ?
And Mozart is misleading us again. De Allende was involved in two possession turnovers and not one. There is nothing Mozart will not falsify and distort in his effort to discredit De Allende, Du Toit and De Jager. Dave is right about Mozart prejudice.


