SA Player Ratings in Wellington test

My own performance ratings for the test are as follows:-

                                           Mine            Houwing

15   Wllie le Roux              -   7,5/10

14   Jesse kriel                   -    7/10       -    6,5/10

13  Lukhanjo Am               -    6/10

12  Damian de Allende    -   6,5/10

11  Aphiwe Dyantyi          -    9/10        -    7,5/10

10  Handre Pollard            -    7/10

  9  Faf de Klerk                  -   6,5/10     -     7/10

  8  Warren Whitley          -    8/10        -     7,5/10

  7  P-S  du Toit                   -   9/10        -     8,5/10

  6  Siya Kolisi                      -   6,5/10    -     8/10

  5  Franco Mostert           -   8/10        -     7/10

  4  Eben Etzebeth            -    7,5/10    -     7/10

  3  Frans Malherbe         -    8/10        -      7/10

  2  Lionel Marx                -    8/10        -      7,5/10

   1  Stephen Kitshoff      -     7,510      -       8/10

17  Tendai Mtawarira     -      6/10

18  Wilco Louw                -      6/10

23   Cheslyn Kolbe           -      8,5/10     -     7/10

Comments on the above would be sincerely appreciated.

I have given Houwing's  ratings as the second figure against the player names.   Where I did not give a second figure  it means  that -

*   Houwing's and my ratings are the same; or

*   in the case of the replacement props Houwing did not give a rating 

I have given Houwing's  ratings as the second figure against the player names.   Where I did not give a second figure  it means  that -

*   Houwing's and my ratings are the same; or

*   in the case of the replacement props Houwing did not give a rating 

APD

I agree with you here about how hard it is to play NZ in Wellington.   That was why I gave   6 of the players higher ratings than Houwing did - while he gave only 2 players higher ratings than those I gave.

Have a look again - I do think he was a bit liberal in the c ase of players he rated higher than I did.  

Sure I did celebrate,

Funny enough how Mozart and AO vanish from sight = wonder why?   

Sure Kolbe did more than expected.   By the way I think that wing Delguy of Argentina and Kolbe is something in the Paulsen mode.  Nimble, quick and clever in execution of their job.

`````` 

5   Wllie le Roux              -   7,5/10

14   Jesse kriel                   -    7/10       -

13  Lukhanjo Am               -    6/10

12  Damian de Allende    -   7/10

11  Aphiwe Dyantyi          -    9/10        -

10  Handre Pollard            -    7/10

  9  Faf de Klerk                  -   7.510

  8  Warren Whitley          -    8/10        

  7  P-S  du Toit                   -   9/10        -  

  6  Siya Kolisi                      -   7/10  

  5  Franco Mostert           -   7/10        -

  4  Eben Etzebeth            -    7,5/10    

  3  Frans Malherbe         -    7 /10        - 

  2  Lionel Marx                -     7,5/10

   1  Stephen Kitshoff      -     8/10

17  Tendai Mtawarira     -      6/10

18  Wilco Louw                -      6/10

23   Cheslyn Kolbe           -      6,0/10   

My bad Mike, accept my apologies, I was viewing on mobile and it rendered badly so I assumed the ratings were opposite.

I amend my first statement, your ratings were pretty spot on.

You have not seen anything yet - our self-proclaimed world experts on site (Mozart and AO) have not completed their analysis.   You can bet on your life they will reduce -

*   Du Toit to 6/10;

*   Malherbe to 5/10;  and 

*   De Allende to 4/10.