FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  SA should give Pro14 Tour more focus, and drop some teams from SuperRugby

SA should give Pro14 Tour more focus, and drop some teams from SuperRugby

Started by sharkbok3 REPLIES321 VIEWS· 17 Jun 2019, 21:56
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,251 posts
17 Jun 2019, 21:56
#1
17 Jun 2019, 21:56#1

The SuperRugby tournament is in tatters, with another season of this nonsense planned for 2020- only to finally change in 2021 back to what it was.

More players are now in Europe than in the Southern Hemisphere. 

In the past, the big draw has been to play against New Zealand backlines players- and to some degree Australian teams - or least the Super12 Ozzie teams.

However, with so many of these type of players now in Northern Hemisphere, SuperRugby has less appeal. The whole format is stuffed, and new teams (Other than Jaguars) have fared badly, and for the most part a waste of space. 

This has diluted the various teams- and put some players on the field that are frankly not worthy of our attention. Then with players going overseas- and playing in Pro14- means SA may as well be in it.

The travel demands are much less, and it is the same time zone. 

The Bulls and Lions could put together one team for each tournament, and the Sharks and Stormers one team for each tournament. 

The Pro14 is an embarrassment, even if many of the teams contain Southern Hemisphere players. 

There is no point putting a team in SupeRugby if everyone in the backline players can't catch or pass to the standard required of a professional sportsperson.  The will just get exposed - and blunder basic opportunities of the draw pass and pass to capitalise on overlaps opportunities of fast Southern Hemisphere pitches

The Stormers backline was a comedy of errors on the first phase - with a few counters attacks the only salvation as with the Stormers who finished last...

Our forward depth can match the Pro14 - and kicking is a bigger part with tight defences. 

ST
Stavanger1Pro4,532 posts
18 Jun 2019, 20:27
#2
18 Jun 2019, 20:27#2
W hy do you say the Pro 14 is an embarrassment?
sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,251 posts
18 Jun 2019, 20:38
#3
18 Jun 2019, 20:38#3
@Stavanger, The results by SA teams are an embarrassment. The Cheetas did make the semi last year- but both teams have been hopeless this year. I think the Kings finished last both seasons.

What I meant was that SA should take some players out of SuperRugby, and re-allocate them to Pro14. 
As SuperRugby has declined, Pro14 has gotten better. So much so, that there is less advantage of playing in SuperRugby - as they now contain many quality players from Southern Hemisphere along with Northern Hemisphere stars. SuperRugby used to be light years ahead- but these days it is not half as good as it formerly was.
The global calendar in rugby is apparently going to make the Northern Hemisphere include more Summertime. This would make for a more expansive game, as the December-Feb games can become mudbaths. 
ST
Stavanger1Pro4,532 posts
18 Jun 2019, 23:29
#4
18 Jun 2019, 23:29#4

Sharkbok

I thought you where referring to the Pro 14 in general.

Being pedantic here but the Cheetahs made the playoffs last year but where one short of the semi's, Yeah the Cheetahs where decent in their first season. Good attack but weak defensively and their discipline wasn't good but its hard too know if that's partly down to different interpretation of the laws by northern hemisphere refs. I believe they lost a good few players between the off season and that hurt them this season.

The Kings well I would give them alot a slack for there first season. There whole entry in the Pro 14 was very last minute and the Kings barely had a squad and from what I ready they don't have much in the way of backroom staff either. Technically they did improve in the second season winning 2 games and 1 draw as opposed to just 1 win in season and they did pick up a number of bonus points but still season 2 was disappointing from them.

I think the Pro 14 want the other 4 SA teams to join as well. I believe the Super Rugby contracts are up for renewal at the end of next season and that's when the decision will be made. There is occasional news paper reports up here that some of the SA franchises would like to join. I would personally like to see it happen, but saying that I don't watch Super Rugby so I don't wish it ill but as the Pro 14 is my league I think the entry of the remaining SA franchises would really enhance i t.

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news