FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Scotland - Springboks game - player ratings

Scotland - Springboks game - player ratings

Started by clevermike3 REPLIES253 VIEWS· 17 Nov 2013, 22:11
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
17 Nov 2013, 22:11
#1
17 Nov 2013, 22:11#1

Although the score line was very much in favour of the Springboks - the performance of some of the players were problematic and hence some of the rather low scores:-

 

Willie le Roux  :   Had a brilliant game - contributed massively to the Springboks efforts

                            Scored try - made another one and saved a try - absolutely safe

                            insofar as ball handling is concerned.               9/10

 

JP Pietersen     :    Scored a try - saved a try and had two good breaks with ball in

                            hand.   Good in defence  Gave away penalty     8/10

 

Jacque  Fourie  :   Did nothing of note - other than to give away 2 penalties to the

                             Scots.   A player ran past him early on no attempted tackle  

                             Twice knocked on balls                                        4/10

 

Jean de Villiers :   Solid performanve on attack and defence              7/10

 

Bryan Habana   :   Nothing much on attack - Saved a try                   6/10

 

Pat Lambie       :   Very good in variation of play.  Defence 100%       8/10

 

Fourie Du Preez :  Solid performance                                              7/10

 

Duane Vermeulen :    Very good performance - real top class            8/10

 

Willem Alberts     :  Had 10 ball carries without much effect - scored push over try

                                Penalty conceded - low tackle count                   6/10

 

Francois Louw     :   Carrried ball 5 times with positive effect. Made 10

                                tackles - missing 2 Penalty conceded                  6/10

 

Flip v/d Merwe    :   Average performance at best.  Made a lot of tackles

                                 but mot really effective in line-outs                   6/10

 

Bakkies Botha     :   No show - missed too many tackles - not effective

                                in line-outs  -  Gave away penalty                      4/10

 

Frans Malherbe   :    Quiet game - strong in scrums                         5,5/10

 

Adriaan Strauss   :    Very solid performance.  Excellent defence         7/10

 

Gurthro Steenkamp :  Scrumming iffy - made some tackles, but gave

                                    away penalty and also a short-arm pennalty     5/10

 

In essence the Springboks as a team deserved the victory - but it is clear that Meyer's testing of Jacque Fourie is an exercise in futility and he was more a hindrance than advantage in the backline.   Going on todays performance Bakkies Botha is not international material anymore - it really was not up to standard.   Gurthro Steenkamp scrumming is just not good enough.  

 

Delighted to see that Pietersen showed some really good form - but he needed a spark to perform and that spark was provide by le Roux.

 

 

 

   

BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
18 Nov 2013, 00:06
#2
18 Nov 2013, 00:06#2
 ou maaaikie have not seen the game but wonder if I can rely on your assessment. I do note you gave Louw only a 6 when the home page article suggets he was man of the match so I am wondering if pre match views are clouding matters again.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
18 Nov 2013, 00:15
#3
18 Nov 2013, 00:15#3
Beenkop.......Louw was not close to MOM..........Willie got that award  
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
18 Nov 2013, 04:42
#4
18 Nov 2013, 04:42#4
 Well done to the Boks ,ach pooer wee Scots didnae even come close ,oh well maybe they will get one over the Womblies !
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news