FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Sharks got caught napping

Sharks got caught napping

Started by clevermike4 REPLIES97 VIEWS· 28 Apr 2014, 12:16
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
28 Apr 2014, 12:16
#1
28 Apr 2014, 12:16#1

The following article contains some very interesting comments from Jake White:-


"Sharks boss Jake White admitted that his table-topping side got caught out by the Highlanders who became the first team to win at Kings Park this season.


The visitors outscored the Sharks by four tries to nil to wrap up a valuable bonus-point win at the start of their tour, whilst the Sharks now head  overseas with plenty to think about.

White admitted that his side was outplayed and outsmarted by the team from Dunedin who took advantage of a sluggish performance from their hosts who battled to get any momentum going.

"We weren't at our best and they played really well against us - take nothing away from this performance by the Highlanders," White said.

"Sometimes when we needed to kick we ran, and sometimes when we needed to run we kicked."

The competition leaders missed a golden chance to consolidate their number one position on the overall standings against one of the worst New Zealand teams, going down 34-18, with the visitors dominating against their below-par hosts.

"It was tough. They bossed at the breakdown, they didn't allow us rhythm, they didn't kick out, they didn't give us any set-piece ball, the handling wasn't good."

Richard Buckman, Aaron Smith and Shane Christie all scored tries in the opening 40 minutes, before Malakai Fekitoa's superb solo second-half score wrapped up a bonus-point win.

Despite the Otago outfit dominating, the Sharks were kept in the game by the boot of rookie flyhalf Tim Swiel, who kicked six penalties in total, right until the final 12 minutes.

"At 24-18 we still had opportunities," White said.

"We dropped an overlap on the left when it was three on one and we dropped one on the right hand side. We weren't as good as we should have been."

In their defence, the coastal side were dealt a blow before kick-off when both captain Bismarck du Plessis and Jean Deysel were ruled out through injury. Replacements Kyle Cooper and Ettienne Oosthuizen as well as S'bura Sithole and Jannie du Plessis all appeared to pick up knocks during the game.

"It's massive when you lose your captain and you lose the guy who sets up your whole scrum," White said.

"But what comes out of that is you start to realise how important certain players are and players who do get an opportunity need to be ready when they get called upon.

"I'm not saying anyone wasn't, but it gives us an opportunity in the next couple of rounds to make sure that we've got the right combinations going forward."

The result came at a critical time for the Sharks - in their final home match before they travel to Australia and New Zealand to face the Rebels, Brumbies, Crusaders and Blues.

"It's not an ideal way to set off on tour, but it's highly unlikely teams are going to be unbeaten throughout the competition," White, whose side are now just a point clear at the summit, said.

"You've seen how tough this competition is and people have realised that no matter who you're play against, it's tough to win.

"When you win you take all the pleasantries and accolades that go with it but when you lose, you've got to dust yourself and get up."
Conclusions
I am beginning to feel that deficiencies which were not dealt with because of winning of games, will get a high priority from White.   These include -
*  deficiencies in ball skills;*  deficiencies in reading of the game and decision making; and*  speed deficiency of certain players.
White for the first time refers to combinations -"we've got the right combinations going forward" - and here  a key issue is in the backline.   It is evident that the present center combination is deficient and that Steyn is a square peg in a round hole not producing the goods.  Most cases of poor decision making happens with him involved. I think White may move him to full back and adjust the backline accordingly.
The other issue to be addressed is ball skills of players and here there is a massive problem.   I listed the number of ball possession handovers by players and those together with penalties given away was really a horror story.  Something needs to be done about those and about passing skills.   It often enough is not the mistake of the recipient to mess up balls - but the quality of the passes that is deficient.
The real speed deficiencies are those of Pietersen, Steyn and Alberts.   They are too slow in speed and thinking ability to play in the positions they were selected for.  Also Coetzee showed serious deficiencies in decisionmaking and have lost the ability to pass balls to other players 0 his crashballing is totally ineffective and counter-productive.         
BO
BoklogicPro1,978 posts
28 Apr 2014, 14:29
#2
28 Apr 2014, 14:29#2
 Steyn, Alberts, Steyn Alberts, Steyn Alberts, Steyn Alberts, Steyn Alberts...Its tiresome..Its boring..Its relentless, Its personal..Its embarassing...Its taking over his life..Its pathetic!!
Why dont you write a book about Steyn and Alberts and if anyone wants to constantly read your take on them, they can buy the book!Every one of these threads have you mention Steyn and Alberts. Do you realise that Mike?? Its actually concerning now boet!
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
28 Apr 2014, 14:46
#3
28 Apr 2014, 14:46#3
 boklogic
I was just wondering what White will do with the combinations that he said they need to get right.   In essence  I think there are some problems in play and my thinking is what is to my mind wrong with the present combinations.
I know Steyn and Alberts are holy cows that is not to be criticized - but they are two of the deficient players game after game - even when you look at the match  statistics after looking at the games carefully, they stood out as not producing the goods.   
As to the speed issue - that was raised in respect of Pietersen a number of times by other posters and insofar as Steyn and Alberts is concerned there are excellent examples where they under- perform as a result of deficient speed.
I was watching school rugby this morning and their ball handling skills are better than those of the senior Sharks player on Friday.           
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
28 Apr 2014, 15:42
#4
28 Apr 2014, 15:42#4
Mike I think you are quite right re Alberts. He is perhaps an option in NH conditions and against certain types of packs eg England but to me he makes a much better lock. I noted from the very beginning that Marclee was a player full of heart and good natural ability but shockingly bad skills. All he can do is crash ball and tackle!. His passing skills and others skills are virtually non existent. Some halfwits want him in the Bok side!!!
JP is a bit to slow on the wing. This is a big pity as otherwise he is not too bad. Hence the need for the Boks to get JJ on the wing.
I am still disappointed re Steyn and see no sign of the old speed and athleticism. It's only his goal kicking and boot that is okay. He is far too sluggish. Very disappointing so far especially as he has lost weight. One hoped for MUCH better. Can' t really understand it unless injuries have taken their toll.
So Jake must put Alberts at lock and the lose trio is Marcell (Lots of caoching needed here Jake) Kan Kan and Deysel.
Reinach and Lambie are missed so maybe Steyn at flyhalf with Sweil playng 20 minutes to build experience. Jordaan is a must at 13 and then perhaps try Sithole on the wing, JP on bench. Or just leave JP there.
Every team has an off day.Sharks lock pairing if Alberts and Du Toit would have been great. Key injuries may have cost the Sharks the title this year. We shall see. 
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
28 Apr 2014, 16:13
#5
28 Apr 2014, 16:13#5
 Beeno
The problem with Steyn is his decision making - you cannot have him at flyhalf pr at least he is too big a gamble there and I think White realizes it - that is why he is reluctant to start with him at flyhalf.    If you read between the lines you would find that all the kicking and passing mishaps happpened when Steyn was in fact flyhalf non Friday.   
I think the only solution with Steyn is to move him to full back and hope for the best inasmuch as his deficient speed is concerned.   I really would play Jordaan at 12 - he is not a deadhead like Steyn and will do better in all components of the game in that position - play Sithole at 13 and Mvovo and  Ndungane on the wing.  For the time being I would stick with Zeilinga or Swiel at flyhalf - at least they are natural flyhalfs and not bound to be charged down or throwing away balls like Steyn is liable to do.
I think White has some serious thinking to do insofar as combinations are concerned - he spoke about aimless kicking last week and the aimless kicking this week - especially in the second half was really seriously problematic.
I would like to see what  White comes up with  - scratching the surface would not help - he will have to face up to some realities.   I think the issue with Steyn last year was realized by Plumtree early on  and he had to act.   In the case of White it was not so serious early on - the Sharks despite the deficiencies in the backline won their matches.  However, the collapse against  the Highlanders may force White's hand - same as happened last year when the Brumbies rubbished the Sharks in their match.
Plumtree removed Steyn and the subsequent matches against the Rebels and Crusaders were won by the Sharks.   What will happen now?                           
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news