FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Smal in the Western Cape

Smal in the Western Cape

Started by clevermike6 REPLIES157 VIEWS· 18 Sept 2014, 09:31
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
18 Sept 2014, 09:31
#1
18 Sept 2014, 09:31#1

Am I smelling the roses or has Smal's appointment as Director of Rugby had a very postive impact on WP - Stormers Rugby?   Looks like they will have a strong team next year in Super 15 as well - that is if injuries does not destroy their chances again.


The team could look something like the following:-


15   Taute,  14  Van Wyk,  13 De Allnde,  12  De Villiers(?),  11  Senatla,  10  Catrakillis,  9   Groom,  8   Vermeulen,  7   Elstadt,  6  Carr,  5   Botha,  4   Etzebeth,  3  Malherbe,  2  Ntsubene  1  Kitshof


16  Coetzee,  17  Cilliers,  18  Harris,  19  Rhodes,  20  Kolisi,  21  Schreuder,  22  Coleman,  23  Kolbe 


I am not sure whether De Villiers will still play next year.  If he decides not to - then De Allende will move into the 12 position.   The issue is what to do with De Jongh.   His questionable defense (the worst defending center in any SA Super 15 outfit over the past two seasons)  is a huge problem and he does not really have the ability to make line breaks himself and beat defenders - only  a good finisher if somebody else puts him into space.   For Super 15 I think Howard would be a better bet at 13 for the Stormers.   


I think Kolbe will be a good impact player - hence my believe he should be on the bench.   


WP can still contract other players.  I wish they try to get  Van der Walt - the flyhalf of the Lions - he really will be a good buy.  I still am not sold on Catrakillis and Coleman as flyhalfs.   Another option at 10 would be Du Preez - he is better than the other 2.   They could also think of Small-Smith as a 13 and try to contract him - he is very good.


          

DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
18 Sept 2014, 10:00
#2
18 Sept 2014, 10:00#2
 It's Kolbe Mike, and yes, there seems to be some improvement under Smal at WP
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
18 Sept 2014, 11:22
#3
18 Sept 2014, 11:22#3
 DbDraad 
Thanks I have corrected same.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
18 Sept 2014, 15:15
#5
18 Sept 2014, 15:15#5
 Ceradyne
Thanks for the info.  
CE
CeradynePro9,374 posts
18 Sept 2014, 15:20
#6
18 Sept 2014, 15:20#6
 You didn't know that?
sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,294 posts
18 Sept 2014, 17:39
#7
18 Sept 2014, 17:39#7
Kolbe must start for the Stormers at 15. 
Although I also have massive reservations about his defense due to his size, especially againt backline players of PI descent (e.g. the Crusaders wing that weighs 125kg).
Some of the one on one tackles against the biggest fastest backs are probably going to result in missed tackles anyway. When Julian Savea has a one on one and he has space and running at full speed, he is usually going to win all the one- on-one tackles anyway.

Someone else commented on another thread that his defense is much better than Willie LeRoux. 
I saw him make an excellant tackle on that Lions prop that is called the Rhinoceros. He tackled him round the waist and slide down quickly to trip him up and save a certain try.
Aplon and Breyton Paulse were the same type of players. 
Maybe too light on defense to pull people down in the tackle, but then if he is only 7-10KG lighter than someone like Willie Leroux who has a poorer technique then it does not really matter. 
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news